Alabama man whose spouse was killed in car wreck is suing to overturn state’s gay marriage laws

Paul Hard wants to be listed as surviving spouse on death certificate and proceeds from pending wrongful death lawsuit

Alabama man whose spouse was killed in car wreck is suing to overturn state’s gay marriage laws
14 February 2014

A federal lawsuit has been filed by a surviving spouse who is challenging Alabama’s laws banning gay marriage.

Paul Hard is fighting for his 2011 Massachusetts marriage to David Fancher to be recognized in Alabama, the state the couple was living in when Fancher was killed in a car crash in 2012.

The lawsuit, filed on Hard’s behalf by the Southern Poverty Law Center, seeks to overturn the Alabama’s Marriage Protection Act, a 1998 law that bans the recognition of same-sex marriages from other states.

The suit also seeks to overturn the Sanctity of Marriage Amendment which in 2005 made the ban part of the state constitution.

Hard is demanding that Fancer’s death certificate be corrected to list him as the surviving spouse and that he receive his share of any proceeds from a pending wrongful death suit he has filed.

Fancher died after being brought to the hospital following a collision in the dark with a large truck strewn across the northbound lanes of Interstate 65 north of Montgomery.

‘Most married couples take for granted that if tragedy strikes they can proceed through the worst of times without the state saying at every turn that their marriage doesn’t even exist,’ Hard said in a statement. ‘Marriages are significant, and my marriage is due the same respect as any other.’

Hard is suing the trucking companies involved in the wreck.  But he cannot receive a share of the proceeds if successful with the suit because he cannot be deemed the surviving spouse in Alabama.

This despite Fancher’s will naming Hard as the sole beneficiary.

David C. Dinielli, deputy legal director for the law center, calls this ‘unconstitutional.’

‘Alabama has created two classes of marriages within its borders and deemed one of those classes – marriages between people of the same sex – to be inferior to the other,’  Dinielli said in a statement.

‘The only purpose of refusing Paul the right to share in the proceeds from the wrongful death lawsuit is to punish him for having married a man, and to express moral disapproval of this choice,’ Dinielli added.

‘These purposes are improper and unconstitutional. Alabama must treat its LGBT citizens with equal dignity and respect under the law.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Activists to picket gay 'leper' conference

Activists plan protest in Belfast, Northern Ireland, against Christian 'gay cure' group.
No thumbnail available

Long before NBA's Jason Collins came out, there was baseball's Glenn Burke

Billie Jean King calls the 'honest and forthright' Burke the real gay male pioneer of US pro team sports
No thumbnail available

Federal judge orders February trial on challenge to Michigan's gay marriage ban

Supporters had hoped judge would strike ban down today
No thumbnail available

New Zealand PM says he will vote for gay marriage

New Zealand’s centre-right prime minister John Key says he will support same-sex marriage bill in parliament
No thumbnail available

US State Department to appoint special envoy for gay rights

New post will be filled by an openly gay Foreign Service officer
Thousands march at Pride in London to fight for and celebrate equality

Thousands march at Pride in London to fight for and celebrate equality

Alan Turing's living members of his family walked to celebrate his heroism
No thumbnail available

Kate McKinnon nails Ellen DeGeneres impersonation on Saturday Night Live

Says Ellen: 'I’m going to invite her to LA because I want her to go to Thanksgiving for me'
No thumbnail available

Pope Idol: The top 7 and their stance on gay rights

As the cardinals start to gather for the conclave to elect the next pope, we give a run-down of the top popefuls and find a bleak picture on LGBT issues
How to set up an LGBT employee resource group or network

How to set up an LGBT employee resource group or network

Are you wanting to start an LGBTI network group at work but are unsure how to start? Read some advice from people involved with such groups
No thumbnail available

At least 15 men arrested in the Gambia, suspected of being gay

Reports that a raid on a bar in the capital Banjul resulted in 15 arrests, some may be under-age