Alaska Supreme Court rules in favor of LGBTI families

'Our senior citizens and veterans should not have to pay more taxes just because they happen to be gay or lesbian'

Alaska Supreme Court rules in favor of LGBTI families
26 April 2014

Alaska’s Supreme Court ruled the state discriminates against same-sex families by not allowing access  to property tax exemptions reserved for senior citizens and disabled veterans.

The legal rights group American Civil Liberties Union announced the court’s decision on 25 April.

The case was brought by three couples denied a $150,000 (€108,000) property tax exemption the western US state makes available to opposite-sex married couples.

Because a constitutional amendment bans gay marriage the state treated the plaintiffs as roommates. Their exemption was only equal to half the value of the couples’ homes.

‘For purposes of analyzing the effects of the exemption program, we hold that committed same-sex domestic partners who would enter into marriages recognized in Alaska if they could are similarly situated to those opposite-sex couples who, by marrying, have entered into domestic partnerships formally recognized in Alaska,’ the Alaska Supreme Court wrote, as reported by Reuters.

The ACLU hailed the judgment.

‘Our senior citizens and veterans should not have to pay more taxes just because they happen to be gay or lesbian,’ Joshua Decker, executive director of the ACLU of Alaska, said in a statement.

The lead plaintiffs, Julie Schmidt, 71, and Gayle Schuh, 66, have been together 36 years. The former educators are originally from Illinois, a midwestern state.

‘Gayle and I built a home and a life here because we loved what Alaska had to offer,’ Schmidt said in a statement. ‘It hurt that the state that we loved so much treated us like strangers. It is gratifying to have our relationship recognized.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Will Neil Patrick Harris be People Magazine's first openly gay Sexiest Man Alive?

Multi-talented performer is reported to be among finalists
No thumbnail available

Bologna's new law means you're better off dead

The Italian city's council has passed a new local law allowing same-sex couples to decide their after-death destiny
No thumbnail available

Student plans gay retirement home in Canada

Student at Nova Scotia's Dalhousie University says LGBT elderly face homophobia in standard retirement homes
No thumbnail available

Sam Smith is 'very upset' that he needs surgery for vocal cord hemorrhage

Resting has not been enough to heal damage - will be out for 6-8 weeks
No thumbnail available

‘Traditional families’ are no longer the norm in the US

Research of census data and other surveys has concluded that an increasing number of children are born outside of marriage or are being brought up by a single parent or same-sex couple
No thumbnail available

Why gay Christians are turning to celibacy

The turn away from ‘curing’ gay people of their sexuality doesn’t mean an end to extremist Christians interfering in LGBTI’s private lives
No thumbnail available

Chaz Bono says he has lost 43 pounds and wants to lose about 40 more

Transgender son of Cher and Sonny Bono had tipped the scales at 250 pounds
No thumbnail available

Money, Money, Money: bookies offer odds as ABBA reunion hinted

With bookies Paddy Power offering odds on an ABBA reunion, it could be a case of the Winner Takes It All
No thumbnail available

Wonderful Wales: one man's quest for foodie heaven in the Brecon Beacons

Food, nature and the quiet life in the greenest of valleys
No thumbnail available

Nigeria: Man stabbed to death over allegedly gay sex

Nigerian media sensationally report a married man has been stabbed to death over allegedly gay sex, while LGBT activists slam the country's press for creating a moral panic