Anti-gay slurs ruled hate speech in Mexico

The Mexican Supreme Court has ruled that two popular anti-gay slurs are hate speech and are not protected under freedom of speech in the country’s constitution

Anti-gay slurs ruled hate speech in Mexico
09 March 2013

Mexico’s Supreme Court has ruled that the anti-gay slurs ‘punal’ and ‘maricon,’ both roughly translating as ‘faggot,’ constitute hate speech and are not constitutionally protected free speech.

The Supreme Court judges voted 3-2 on Wednesday in a case where a publisher and his colleagues at the Synthesis newspaper had been slandered with both terms in a column by a journalist at a rival newspaper named Intolerance.

Both newspapers are based in the state of Puebla.

Intolerance writer Quiroz Nunez Prida Huerta had written that Synthesis publisher Enrique Quiroz Nunez was a ‘punal’ and that only ‘maricones’ wrote for him.

‘Even though they are deeply rooted expressions in Mexican society, the fact is that the practices of the majority of society can’t validate the violations of [a] basic right,’ the judges wrote in their majority opinion.

The judges wrote that the terms were ‘offensive and discriminatory,’ and found that people subjected to the terms should be allowed to sue for ‘moral damages.’

‘The social problems of such speech is that, by the expressions of contempt and insult they contain, they generate social feelings of hostility against [particular] persons or groups.’

However the judges wrote that the terms, ‘can validly be used in studies in scientific or artistic works of nature,’ in quoting sources that used the terms.

Homosexuality has been legal in Mexico since 1871 when the country adopted the Napoleonic Code during a brief period of French occupation.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Former Mr Gay Namibia runs for parliament

Despite having a bounty on his head, Wendelinus Hamutenya is a well-known politician, in an openly gay relationship, who has put LGBT issues to the top of the agenda
No thumbnail available

Top gay Christian says new archbishop’s plan to attack gay marriage is ‘horrific’

Reverend Sharon Ferguson comments as church document claims letting gay wed would destroy ‘traditional institution of marriage’
No thumbnail available

Mr Gay India hopes to change views on reality TV show

Sushant Divgikar is a housemate in the country's version of Big Brother
No thumbnail available

Anderson Cooper sunburns his eyeballs, goes blind for 36 hours

Incident occured while newsman was on assignment for 60 Minutes
No thumbnail available

20,000 attend Taiwan gay marriage concert

20,000 people attended a free concert by Taiwanese pop star A-mei in Taipei on Sunday aimed at showing support for efforts to legalize same-sex marriage in the Asian nation
No thumbnail available

29 Gay Prides and parties in July you need to get ready for

From Marseilles to Miami, Porto to Provincetown, here’s a growing and ever-changing list of what’s going on in the world of LGBTI parties this month
No thumbnail available

Boy Scouts of America will hire criminals, but not gays

The American scout group's application form says it will not hire homosexuals 'in any capacity', but 'conviction of a crime is not an automatic bar to employment.'
No thumbnail available

Curious straight guy realises he's gay after watching How To Get Away With Murder

'When he touched me, I literally got chills down my spine. I loved it.'
No thumbnail available

Britain has elected the most LGBTI MPs in the world

As the Liberal Democrats lose all their LGBTI MPs, seven fresh faces take seats in the House of Commons
No thumbnail available

UK McDonald's suspends guard after he told gay man: 'No gay kisses allowed'

A man and a woman kissing would have apparently been acceptable