Anti-gay slurs ruled hate speech in Mexico

The Mexican Supreme Court has ruled that two popular anti-gay slurs are hate speech and are not protected under freedom of speech in the country’s constitution

Anti-gay slurs ruled hate speech in Mexico
09 March 2013 Print This Article

Mexico’s Supreme Court has ruled that the anti-gay slurs ‘punal’ and ‘maricon,’ both roughly translating as ‘faggot,’ constitute hate speech and are not constitutionally protected free speech.

The Supreme Court judges voted 3-2 on Wednesday in a case where a publisher and his colleagues at the Synthesis newspaper had been slandered with both terms in a column by a journalist at a rival newspaper named Intolerance.

Both newspapers are based in the state of Puebla.

Intolerance writer Quiroz Nunez Prida Huerta had written that Synthesis publisher Enrique Quiroz Nunez was a ‘punal’ and that only ‘maricones’ wrote for him.

‘Even though they are deeply rooted expressions in Mexican society, the fact is that the practices of the majority of society can’t validate the violations of [a] basic right,’ the judges wrote in their majority opinion.

The judges wrote that the terms were ‘offensive and discriminatory,’ and found that people subjected to the terms should be allowed to sue for ‘moral damages.’

‘The social problems of such speech is that, by the expressions of contempt and insult they contain, they generate social feelings of hostility against [particular] persons or groups.’

However the judges wrote that the terms, ‘can validly be used in studies in scientific or artistic works of nature,’ in quoting sources that used the terms.

Homosexuality has been legal in Mexico since 1871 when the country adopted the Napoleonic Code during a brief period of French occupation.

HAVE YOUR SAY

OTHER POSTS

No thumbnail available

Lily Savage grants fans wishes with panto reprisal

Paul O'Grady's drag queen alter-ego Lily Savage will return again for panto in London, UK
No thumbnail available

Google marks gay pride month with rainbow banner

To mark June as gay pride month, Google now shows a rainbow banner when users do a search for gay and LGBT-related terms
No thumbnail available

Gay suicides should be counted, say campaigners

As Britain releases suicide stats, groups say gay mental health issues should be better recorded and acted on
No thumbnail available

Clementi trial begins

Dharun Ravi's trial starts in New Jersey
No thumbnail available

Rupert Everett defends controversial comments on gay parents

Openly gay actor defends saying he 'couldn't think of anything worse than gay parents'
No thumbnail available

Welcome Back Kotter co-star Ron Palillo dies

Starred with John Travolta on 70s sitcom, is survived by male partner of 41 years
No thumbnail available

You have to watch this romantic proposal from a couple who found love on Instagram

Ryan Donegan sent his partner on a romantic Instagram-style scavenger hunt
No thumbnail available

Pitch Perfect 2 is not homophobic and other reasons we need to stop being so sensitive

The a capella comedy sequel is being attacked for being racist, homophobic and sexist. But is it?
No thumbnail available

Adam Lambert voted most eligible bachelor - again - by a landslide

Jonathan Groff, Ricky Martin, Clay Aiken and Steve Grand also make top 10 in Out Magazine poll
No thumbnail available

Gay US Marine Corps veteran who lost leg in Iraq is booed by anti-LGBT crowd in Texas

Eric Alva tells crowd: 'Shame on you because God loves me'