Are ‘gay gene’ studies a waste of money?

We would be better off investigating what makes people homophobes or transphobic, rather than studying the origins of sexuality

Are ‘gay gene’ studies a waste of money?
01 August 2012

‘Know thyself’ were the words inscribed above the temple of the oracle at Delphi in ancient Greece and Plato says it’s this phrase that motivated Socrates in his dialogues.

So it’s natural that as lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender people we should be fascinated by why our sexuality or gender identity is different from the majority of the population.

But those questions also frustrate me for two reasons. Firstly, what difference can the answer possibly make? And, more importantly, is it a distraction from a more important question?

Plenty of scientists have secured wodges of research cash to investigate ‘what makes us gay’ but far fewer have bothered to investigate what turns people in to homophobes.

Lets assume that casual homophobia in the media, in schools and in the home play a part. If that was proved statistically through a proper psychological study, the effect would be revolutionary. It would mean governments and the media could be forced to take these issues much more seriously. And it wouldn’t be difficult to provide more scientific evidence about the harm that this does to LGBT people, society at large and the homophobes themselves, further powering a fundamental shift in attitudes.

Researchers could also do more to study and categorize the most effective strategies for tackling anti-gay hate. Armed with this information, campaigners could push for real investment in education, awareness building and more.

I am not arguing that research into why some people are gay is not interesting. As a psychology student turned journalist, I’m naturally inquisitive about it (as well as being pretty nosey about virtually everything).

But there is already ample evidence to demonstrate that we are born gay and that homosexuality is entirely natural – by which I also mean that it exists in virtually every kind of animal species studied to date.

These facts may have helped some people realize that being homophobic is just plain stupid – and for those who can rationalize in that way there is plenty of studies available to let them reach the right conclusion.

Despite this achievement, there is still a swathe of people around the world who either don’t know about this evidence, are unmoved by it or choose to reject it. And I would focus research money on how to change their hearts and minds.

I’m not an automaton about this. I know that no amount of evidence building and strategizing is going to change everyone in the world. It’s also clear that some work has been done in this field with positive effect. I only argue that homophobia and transphobia are two of the greatest human rights crises of the modern era and building the evidence base on how to resolve that is urgent.

I should also note my high degree of cynicism both about how science tackles the issue of ‘what makes us gay’ and how the media presents their answers. Too often it all smacks of reputation building by egotistical scientists and sensationalism by us journalists.

And that’s the least of my concerns. I particularly worry that scientific approaches often seem to ignore bisexuals (there are plenty around, after all!) or can be guilty of treating female and male sexuality as exactly alike. More generally they seek to define patterns where the real story is about individuality and difference. It’s worth noting that scientific research into sexuality – while often sound – is also littered with discredited studies, poor methodology and, as a result, u-turns and apologies from the scientists themselves.

To prove I’m not being hypocritical, I should point out my use of the phrase ‘what makes us gay’ in this article is both deliberate and piss-taking. It hasn’t escaped me, as noted above, that lesbianism and bisexuality are the poor cousins in this research or that nobody ever asks ‘what makes us straight’.

Obviously the biological questions about transgender and intersex people are very different to those related to sexual orientation and it’s clearer to me that greater scientific understanding here would be beneficial to trans and intersex people and society at large.

But that’s not to say that some research into how to reduce transphobia is at least as important – or actually more so.

Homophobia and transphobia are, by their very nature, irrational. As such science, statistical fact and education are silver bullets against these prejudices. Isn’t it logical to invest in the right armory for this war?



No thumbnail available

Stephen Gately's family want new probe into his death

The Boyzone singer's family and husband are battling over his estate
No thumbnail available

US Republican senator 'offended' by gay marriage

'We didn’t have to call it marriage, which offends myself and a lot of people'
No thumbnail available

Budapest pride success despite anti-gay threats

Riot police protect thousands of marchers on LGBT pride parade in Hungarian capital
No thumbnail available

Dykes on Bikes rev up for Mardi Gras

Sydney’s gay pride parade is underway as a posse of leathered up ladies tear up Oxford Street
No thumbnail available

Island police make It Gets Better video

Police in UK counties of Hampshire and the Isle of Wight are fighting homophobic bullying
No thumbnail available

Billy Graham supports North Carolina's anti-gay Amendment One

The 93-year-old evangelist places full-page ads in 14 newspapers touting measure
No thumbnail available

Men arrested on gay cruise say they were taunted while in jail in Dominica

'They paraded us around like we were some oddity'
No thumbnail available

Gay man removed from Big Brother UK for 'inappropriate behavior'

All three LGBTI housemates, one way or another, were the first to leave the house
No thumbnail available

Cardinal Keith O’Brien declares war on gay marriage

Leader of Scotland's Roman Catholic Church has promised an 'unprecedented backlash' if marriage equality is legalized
No thumbnail available

This short film captures exactly what it is like to be a trans teen

Silent T is winning awards, and one of its creators Harry Taylor speaks to Gay Star News about the heartbreaking video