Barney Frank calls Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia ‘a flat out bigot’

Gay congressman unhappy anti-gay judge will help decide California's Propsition 8 case next year

Barney Frank calls Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia ‘a flat out bigot’
20 December 2012 Print This Article

In his final days as a US congressman, Barney Frank is slamming Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia for his anti-gay views and remarks.

During a lecture at Princeton University earlier this month, Scalia answered a student’s question about his position on sodomy laws and the judge equated his moral opposition to homosexuality to his moral opposition to murder.

Frank, the first openly gay congressman in US history, says that ‘for a guy who is supposed to be so smart,’ some of Scalia’s remarks on homosexuality have been ‘quite stupid.’

‘This young man said to him, ‘Why do you compare sodomy to murder?’ And he said, ‘Well because I have a right to say if I think something is immoral.’ Well the question wasn’t about his right,’ Frank tells Huffington Post. ‘The question was, By what morality is expressing your love for someone in a physical way equivalent to killing that person? It makes it clear that the man is an unreconstructed bigot, and given that you have a bigot on the Supreme Court like that, it is useful to know.”

Frank adds: ‘I was glad that he made clear what’s been obvious, that he’s just a flat out bigot. I’d previously said he was a homophobe. And Fox and the right wing said, ‘Oh just because he’s not for same-sex marriage? And I said, ‘No, let me be very clear. That’s not it. This is a man who has said you should go to prison for having sex.’ It was an extraordinarily abusive sentiment and it was dead wrong.’

The outspoken Frank is not pleased that the nine-member Supreme Court with Scalia as a member will be hearing am appeal to a ruling that would abolish California’s Proposition 8 law which makes gay marriage illegal in the state.

‘I was critical of the decision to take Prop 8 to court,’ he sys. ‘I don’t the think the five-member Supreme Court majority that we have is ready to declare that there is a constitutional right to marry everywhere. To bring a lawsuit when you’re not likely to win it, prematurely, is a mistake.’

Frank believes the court will uphold a lower court’s ruling that Proposition 8 is unconstitutional which would, once again, allow same-sex couples to marry in the state.

But he sees that as a narrow victory.

‘It’s people being rescued from themselves,’ Frank says.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Sports gay haters are ‘stupid’ says NBA star Amaechi

Star-studded British Student Pride debate also discusses bullying, female invisibility, trans issues and marriage
No thumbnail available

Edith Windsor talks about being plaintiff in DOMA case to be heard by US Supreme Court

'It’s almost a deliriously joyous thing for an old lady'
Harvey Milk Street unveiled in San Diego

Harvey Milk Street unveiled in San Diego

Stuart Milk attends launch of street renamed after his gay activist uncle in California
No thumbnail available

President Hollande's girlfriend backs gay marriage in France

Valerie Trierweiler is looking forward to being a witness at one of France's first gay weddings after her partner passes an equal marriage law
No thumbnail available

Australian former councilor forced to apologize for gay slur after 9-year legal battle

Entitled to express homophobic views but 'Gay Rights? Under God's law the only rights gays have is the right to die' bumper sticker goes too far, says Tribunal
No thumbnail available

Justice Department releases report on bullying

US Justice Department looks at effects of bullying
No thumbnail available

I’m tired and aching but sticking with PEP

The second part of a diary charting one gay man’s experience taking PEP, the cocktail of drugs which may save you from contracting HIV if taken fast enough after exposure to the virus
No thumbnail available

Suicide of gay self-help book author leaves friends and family stunned

Publication of Bob Bergeron's book has been cancelled
No thumbnail available

LGBT groups boycott Hong Kong Government equality forum

LGBT rights groups in Hong Kong have decided to boycott a government organized LGBT rights forum after the government included ex-gay groups in it and failed to organize a meeting in over two years
No thumbnail available

Gay Star Travel Expo 2015 exhibitor profile: Atlantic Pride

One-stop travel shop takes place at London's Heaven nightclub