Canadian couple win discrimination case against bed and breakfast owners

A Canadian gay couple have won their case against a Christian couple who denied them a room in their bed and breakfast and then tried to claim their home was a place of worship

Canadian couple win discrimination case against bed and breakfast owners
19 July 2012

A gay couple who were refused a room at a bed and breakfast in Grand Forks, British Columbia, have been awarded $4,500 in costs and damages.

Shaun Eadie and Brian Thomas took bed and breakfast owners Susan and Les Molnar to court after Susan initially accepted their reservation before husband Les rang back to check if they were a gay couple.

When Eadie confirmed that they were he was told that it was ‘not going to work out’ and Les Molnar cancelled the booking.

Eadie and Thomas later made a human rights complaint.

Susan and Les Molnar argued they were protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms from having to accept a booking from a gay couple as it conflicted with their Christian beliefs and tried to argue that their home was a place of worship as they had held religious gatherings in their home and had it blessed by priests.

However Section 8 of the B.C. Human Rights Code states that a person must not “without a bona fide and reasonable justification” deny any accommodation “customarily available to the public” on the basis of sexual orientation.

‘[Les Molnar] testified that it would have shamed him and his Lord if he had allowed [Eadie and Thomas] to share one bed,’ British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal member Enid Marion wrote in her ruling.

‘[But] having entered into the commercial sphere, the Molnars, like other business people, were required to comply with the laws of the province … that prohibits discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation,’ Marion wrote.

‘[Eadie and Thomas’] sexual orientation was a factor, if not the sole factor, in the cancellation of their reservation. In this regard, I am not persuaded by the respondents’ argument that a distinction should be made between sexual orientation and sexual conduct and that, had the complainants’ provided certain assurances that they would not engage in sexual relations, then they may have been provided with accommodation.’

The Molnar’s have since retired from the bed and breakfast business.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Gays not ready for their close up when it comes to major Hollywood films

GLAAD report shows six major movie studios all but ignoring LGBT characters
No thumbnail available

Second phase of HIV vaccine trials starts in China

High risk groups, including gay men, volunteer to be part of HIV vaccine trial in Beijing
No thumbnail available

Gay marriages march on in Utah, for now

Judge denies request by state to halt ceremonies pending an appeal of his ruling declaring ban unconstitutional
No thumbnail available

New York Post banned from GLAAD Media Awards red carpet over transgender coverage

Newspaper's use of such terms as  'trannies' and 'she-males' cited as reason
No thumbnail available

Governor who vetoed gay marriage bill says he is not a bigot

New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie: 'I don’t compromise my principles for politics'
No thumbnail available

Gay rugby team makes history by being first to play in pro match

The Sydney Convicts will play in a mainstream rugby competition against Macquarie University at the world famous Allianz Stadium
No thumbnail available

Barclays named most gay-friendly Scottish employer

Seven Scottish employers break into British top 100 of Stonewall's workplace index
No thumbnail available

Sun comes back to London this winter with big gay beach party

Summer comes to London early with a free two-day party featuring a swimwear fashion show, beach, pool, top travel brands and more in central London, hosted by Gay Star News
No thumbnail available

Safer sex lifeguards to save the day at Gay Star Beach Party

To promote good sexual health at home and while travelling abroad, sexual health group Terrence Higgins Trust has joined as charity partner for London’s Gay Star Beach Party and LGBTI Travel Show in January
No thumbnail available

Buzz around new novel about an intersex teenager

This week 25-year old Abigail Tarttelin publishes her second novel, Golden Boy, about intersex teenager Max