Catholic agency wants right to deny adoption to gay couples

Adoption agency Catholic Care has resumed its appeal against anti-discrimination laws

Catholic agency wants right to deny adoption to gay couples
13 September 2012

A UK Catholic adoption agency is asking a judge to grant it the right to deny its services to gay couples today (13 September).

Catholic Care has gone to the Upper Tribunal in London to ask the court to defy anti-discrimination laws, and agree only heterosexual couples should be allowed to raise a child.

Justice Sales told the group it is forbidden from restricting their services to married heterosexual couple, the Times reports.

He believes it would be in violation of the Equality Act 2010, which says no company is allowed to discriminate based on sexual orientation.

It is the fourth time the Leeds-based charity has gone to appeal against anti-discrimination laws, and they say they are prepared to go to the European Court of Human Rights.

The Charity Commission has twice turned down Catholic Care, stating being gay does not affect your ability to be a parent.

Catholic Care’s Monica Carss-Frisk said if the charity’s objection to placing children with gay couples was not acknowledged, she said the adoption agency would cease to exist from lack of donations.

She said: ‘The alternative is the services are not provided at all, to the detriment of children in need of adoption.’

Referring to the charity’s predicament, she said the Charity Commission’s focus on the rights of same-sex couples, rather than children in need of adoption, was ‘tantamount to putting the interests of the helper before those of the helpless’.

Gareth Morgan, professor of Charity Studies at Sheffield Hallam University, said he felt Catholic Care’s argument was implausible.

He said: ‘On the contrary I think most Catholics will be very cautious about supporting a charity with such a narrow interpretation of Catholic social responsibility.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Rosie O'Donnell glad 'robotic pundit' Elisabeth Hasselbeck won't be on The View this time

'I’ve come to expect nothing from her, even though I feel I continually make the effort to break through'
No thumbnail available

Stop using hook-up sites: Judge to gay man accused of knowingly exposing partners to HIV

Accused of knowingly exposing an ex-boyfriend and potentially dozens of other men to HIV, a 29-year-old San Diego gay man has been ordered by a judge to stop using Internet dating sites
No thumbnail available

Russian gay activists march alongside 90,000 others in Labor Day march in St Petersburg

Police prevents anti-gay legislator Vitaly Milonov and his supporters from blocking the gay contingent
No thumbnail available

Italian gay man given paid leave for same-sex marriage

Tuscan company Publiacqua ignores law to give employee two-weeks off to marry his husband
No thumbnail available

Trans model Andreja Pejic: ‘It’s taken me 10 years to get here’

The high fashion model and muse speaks about her career, being able to live her dream and the tragedy of Leelah Alcorn
No thumbnail available

LGBT: your hottest prospect this summer

Click here to find out more.
No thumbnail available

British actress Tilda Swinton donates £1000 to funeral for Russian gay rights activist Alexey Davydov

Donations from Swinton and generous people around the world have helped cover the cost of funeral for inspirational gay activist
No thumbnail available

Striker Antonio Cassano fined for homophobic comment

Football star denies meaning to cause offence after given €15000 fine from UEFA
No thumbnail available

8 states that shaped US gay history

We travel through time and the United States in honor of LGBT History Month, looking at where gay rights history was made
No thumbnail available

Vice President Biden appears to support gay marriage

Vice President Joe Biden says he supports gay marriage and Obama reelection campaign tries to walk the statement back