Catholic bishops: Gays make good parents but still must not marry

Bishops from the Roman Catholic Church of England and Wales have outlined their reasons why gay couples should not get married

Catholic bishops: Gays make good parents but still must not marry
30 January 2013

The Catholic Church in England and Wales has said gay people may make good parents but must still be banned from marriage.

Bishops have outlined their reasons why they believe same-sex couples should not be allowed to get married.

In the document published in the Catholic Herald, it states: ‘We recognize that many same-sex couples raise children in loving and caring homes.

‘Nevertheless, marriage has an identity that at its core is distinct from any other legally recognised relationship, no matter how much love or commitment may be involved in these other relationships.

‘Marriage has, over the centuries, been the enduring public recognition of this commitment to provide a stable institution for the care and protection of children, and it has rightly been recognised as unique and worthy of legal protection for this reason.

‘Marriage furthers the common good of society because it promotes a unique relationship within which children are conceived, born and reared, an institution that we believe benefits children.’

The bishops also say refusing marriage to same-sex couples is not discriminatory, as gay couples already have civil partnerships.

Despite the differences between civil partnerships and marriages, they say ‘it is not unequal or unfair to treat those in different circumstances differently.’

‘Catholic teaching, whilst it does not condone same sex sexual activity, condemns unfair discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation,’ they add.

‘Our opposition to same-sex marriage is not based in discrimination or prejudice; it is based in a positive effort to ensure that the unique social values currently served by marriage carry on being served by that institution in the future.’

The bishops also warn of a ‘slippery slope’, saying when civil partnerships were introduced in 2004, politicians promised same-sex marriage would not follow.

The Catholic Church now fears it is more likely marriage will be altered more in the coming years.

On 5 February, the UK government will have its first vote on marriage equality.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Bill Clinton says DOMA is 'contrary to our constitution'

Former president says Defense of Marriage Act, which he signed into law in 1996, is contrary to the American principles of freedom, equality and justice
No thumbnail available

Gay US congressman shows off engagement ring on Jimmy Kimmel

Barney Frank's fiancee in the audience as he also handicaps Republican field
No thumbnail available

All gay cops in Filipino LGBT party closeted

Ang Ladlad's 22 cops are all closeted at work, reflecting how insufficient it is for the Philippine National Police just to 'say' it is open to recruiting gays
No thumbnail available

MPs say David Cameron has 'no mandate' for gay marriage

A cross-party alliance of politicians from House of Commons and Lords slam Prime Minister's plans to legalize same-sex marriage
No thumbnail available

DOMA makes it illegal for gay couples to make joint political donations, rules FEC

The Federal Election Commission ruled that gay couples can’t make a single political donation under both spouse's names
No thumbnail available

US federal court hears challenge to Oregon's marriage ban

'Marriage is a fundamental freedom, and freedom means freedom for everyone'
No thumbnail available

Pat Robertson tells TV viewers gays seek to impose 'totalitarian' socialism on America

Makes comments while defending Indiana's 'religious freedom' law
No thumbnail available

Deal struck allowing gay group to march in Boston St. Patrick’s Day parade

A provisional deal has been made to allow a gay group to participate in Boston’s St. Patrick’s Day parade for the first time in over 20 years, but only if members make no reference to their sexual orientation  
No thumbnail available

Study details Khmer Rouge abuse of gay and trans Cambodians

One trans woman was raped by 14 soldiers and performed sex acts for food
No thumbnail available

Gay Games boycott Sochi summit over safety fears

Federation of Gay Games refuse to put delegate in danger during Peace and Sport conference amid tide of homophobia in Russia