Catholic cardinal snubs talks with Scottish government due to gay marriage

Britain’s most senior Roman Catholic cleric, Cardinal Keith O’Brien, is suspending direct talks with the Scottish government

Catholic cardinal snubs talks with Scottish government due to gay marriage
19 August 2012

Britain’s most senior Catholic, Cardinal Keith O’Brien, is now refusing to talk to Scottish ministers in protest about their plans for gay marriage equality.

According to the BBC, the cardinal made this decision following the Scottish government support for the introduction of same-sex marriage and ahead of the resumption of parliamentary session in September.

The BBC also reported that the cardinal refused to meet with government ministers to discuss the new marriage equality legislation.

A spokesman for the Scottish government said the cardinal and the first minister of Scotland, Alex Salmond, had ‘entirely amicable conversation on first name terms’ this Saturday (19 August).

However, in a letter to Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, the cardinal asked for any future discussions between the church and government on the issue to take place between officials.

Speaking with BBC Scotland, Peter Kearney, the cardinal’s spokesman, said: ‘The situation we find ourselves in is one where we want to maintain a dialogue, and the cardinal wants to maintain a dialogue with the government, but that can be difficult when you feel all the things you have to say, to date at least, have been completely ignored.’

Previously the cardinal’s call for a referendum on gay marriage was rejected by the Scottish government.

Following a consultation and with polls showing overwhelming support for the introduction of full same-sex marriage, the Scottish government has pledged to put to a parliamentary vote a bill for marriage equality.

The earliest ceremonies could take place by the start of 2015.

Marriage equality is also supported by all the leaders of the five parties in the Scottish parliament, as well as by LGBT rights campaigners and many faith groups.

The Roman Catholic Church along with the evangelical churches in Scotland remain vehemently opposed declaring a ‘war’ against marriage equality.

A spokesman for the first minister told the BBC that ‘while this is an honest disagreement over policy, on a personal level relations between the first minister and the cardinal are extremely good, as they are with Scotland’s other faith leaders – Mr Salmond holds the cardinal in the highest regard and will always do so.

‘We have made clear that we will protect religious freedom and freedom of expression – we are currently undertaking a focused stakeholder consultation to make sure that this happens, and we are delighted that officials from the church and government are to meet in order to discuss these very important matters.

‘Faith groups and their celebrants will not be obliged to solemnise same-sex marriages, and we also intend to protect the current situation whereby the faith content of the curriculum in Catholic denominational schools is determined by the Scottish Catholic Education Service.’

Speaking with GSN, Tim Hopkins, chair of Scotland’s Equality Network said: ‘The Cardinal and his colleagues have been wrongly claiming that Catholic priests will be forced to conduct same-sex marriages and will go to prison for speaking out against them.

‘If that is a genuine concern, it is surprising that he is refusing to discuss the Government’s legal provisions which will ensure the Church’s continued freedom to opt out and oppose.

‘We call on him to accept that the Government’s proposals guarantee freedom of religion both for religions that support same-sex marriage and those that oppose it.’

Gay and lesbian couples in Scotland can already have civil partnerships which offer similar rights to marriage but are seen by many as a ‘separate but equal’ system, making LGBT people into second-class citizens.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Michigan sued by civil rights group for not recognizing gay marriages

American Civil Liberties Union wants state to recognize the 300-plus same-sex marriages that took place last month
No thumbnail available

Former senator Larry Craig being sued by Federal Election Commission

Former senator Larry Craig faces a suit over alleged misuse of campaign funds
No thumbnail available

US Supreme Court to hear Proposition 8 and DOMA cases

Justices step into the forefront of gay marriage debate in the US
No thumbnail available

Billy Graham's son says gay marriage is sending the US off a 'moral cliff'

Franklin Graham says gay marriage is 'far more destructive to our nation than any economic concerns'
No thumbnail available

World to remember victims of trans violence

Vigils, plays and candlelit marches will be held around the world to mark Transgender Day of Remembrance
No thumbnail available

Increase in attacks on gay rights activists in Americas

Amnesty International report calls on governments to ensure safety of gay rights campaigners
No thumbnail available

Police break into homes and arrest 20 trans women in Istanbul

On the night before International Women's Day, the homes of trans women was broken into by police on suspicion of 'providing space for sex work'
No thumbnail available

‘Demonic alters’ bishop thanks God for Mugabe’s gay hate

Zambian bishop Dr Bernard Nwaka salutes Zimbabwe’s President Robert Mugabe for standing up to same-sex marriage and says ‘Africa is not for sale’ on gay rights
No thumbnail available

Gay marriages will begin in New Jersey at 12:01 am on Monday

State's Supreme Court rules that same-sex couples can get married as court case is being appealed
No thumbnail available

Morning news host Robin Roberts publicly mentions her female partner for the first time

In a Facebook post Robin Roberts, the host of Good Morning America, mentions her long-term partner Amber Laign