Catholic group claims ‘gay’ dog rescued from death is anti-straight discrimination

The president of a Catholic group aimed at defending religious liberties has claimed that the rescue of a dog that was due to be put down because its owner thought he was gay shows anti-straight bias

Catholic group claims ‘gay’ dog rescued from death is anti-straight discrimination
03 February 2013

The president of America’s Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights has claimed that a dog being saved from being put down after its owner refused to care for him because he thought he was gay is evidence of pro-gay and anti-straight bias.

In a January 31 news release entitled ‘Euthanizing Gay Dogs’ Catholic League president William A Donohue compared the issue of Elton the dog’s rescue to medically assisted suicide in the US state of Washington and the Netherlands – arguing that gay people now received better treatment than straight people or the disabled.

‘This week in Tennessee a dog was rescued from being euthanized … because the condition driving the dog’s death was his alleged homosexuality,’ Donohue wrote in a news release posted on the group’s website.

‘The place where Elton was dropped … encourages dog adoption, but it also promotes dog euthanasia. Not, however, in Elton’s case. The shelter has no stomach for putting dogs down on the basis of sexual orientation.

‘It must be said, though, that the shelter is not exactly inclusive in its policies. … Had poor Elton not been identified as a homosexual, his heterosexuality would not have been enough to save his hide.

‘The moral of the story is being gay is not only a bonus for humans these days, it is a definite plus for dogs as well. As for straights, the lonely and the disabled, that’s another story altogether.’

However Donohue’s version of events is factually incorrect. The shelter that the dog was dropped at, Jackson Rabies Control, did not decide to not put down Elton the dog.

Elton was saved because he was adopted by a member of the public before the shelter’s put-down deadline was reached after a volunteer group that tries to get dogs at the shelter rehoused publicized his case.

Neither the Netherlands or Washington state euthanize people against their will.

But in 2011 the Royal Dutch Medical Association updated its guidelines to allow doctors to consider factors such as ‘vulnerability, loss of function, confinement to bed, loneliness, humiliation and loss of dignity’ in determining if someone is eligible for assisted suicide, while Washington state is debating whether to allow euthanasia for people who are disabled but not terminally ill.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

US state of Virginia considers gay segregation bill

Makes it legal for business owners to deny service to LGBTI people under 'religious and moral convictions'
No thumbnail available

George Takei will join Ohio mom Jennifer Tyrrell and GLAAD at NYC Pride

Star Trek icon is a former Boy Scout: 'Some of my best memories from my boyhood are of my scouting days'
No thumbnail available

Ohio politician says murder of trans woman was a ‘hate crime’

Cernia Acoff, 20, was stabbed, dumped in a pond tied to a concrete block and a steel pipe three weeks after she went missing
No thumbnail available

I was told I would go to hell for supporting gay rights, says UK minister

Edward Davey MP, Energy and Climate Change Minister, wants government and business to do more for LGBTI equality globally
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Gay Games shrugs off jibe that global event is not 'serious sport'

Gay Games organizers 'reach out' to head of South Africa's Olympic committee after he sparked fury over his 'clearly derogatory' remarks
Obama on US Supreme Court's gay marriage ruling: 'Real change is possible'

Obama on US Supreme Court's gay marriage ruling: 'Real change is possible'

In remarks outside The White House, Obama pays tribute to 'countless small acts of courage' of gays and lesbians
No thumbnail available

Aussie actor Harry Cook comes out on YouTube

Nearly 35,000 people in less than 24 hours have watched a coming out video posted online by young Australian actor Harry Cook in which he says he had to come out as gay to be true to himself
No thumbnail available

Gok Wan's spec-tacular Red Nose Day campaign

UK charity fundraiser slated for 13 March
No thumbnail available