Catholic group claims ‘gay’ dog rescued from death is anti-straight discrimination

The president of a Catholic group aimed at defending religious liberties has claimed that the rescue of a dog that was due to be put down because its owner thought he was gay shows anti-straight bias

Catholic group claims ‘gay’ dog rescued from death is anti-straight discrimination
03 February 2013

The president of America’s Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights has claimed that a dog being saved from being put down after its owner refused to care for him because he thought he was gay is evidence of pro-gay and anti-straight bias.

In a January 31 news release entitled ‘Euthanizing Gay Dogs’ Catholic League president William A Donohue compared the issue of Elton the dog’s rescue to medically assisted suicide in the US state of Washington and the Netherlands – arguing that gay people now received better treatment than straight people or the disabled.

‘This week in Tennessee a dog was rescued from being euthanized … because the condition driving the dog’s death was his alleged homosexuality,’ Donohue wrote in a news release posted on the group’s website.

‘The place where Elton was dropped … encourages dog adoption, but it also promotes dog euthanasia. Not, however, in Elton’s case. The shelter has no stomach for putting dogs down on the basis of sexual orientation.

‘It must be said, though, that the shelter is not exactly inclusive in its policies. … Had poor Elton not been identified as a homosexual, his heterosexuality would not have been enough to save his hide.

‘The moral of the story is being gay is not only a bonus for humans these days, it is a definite plus for dogs as well. As for straights, the lonely and the disabled, that’s another story altogether.’

However Donohue’s version of events is factually incorrect. The shelter that the dog was dropped at, Jackson Rabies Control, did not decide to not put down Elton the dog.

Elton was saved because he was adopted by a member of the public before the shelter’s put-down deadline was reached after a volunteer group that tries to get dogs at the shelter rehoused publicized his case.

Neither the Netherlands or Washington state euthanize people against their will.

But in 2011 the Royal Dutch Medical Association updated its guidelines to allow doctors to consider factors such as ‘vulnerability, loss of function, confinement to bed, loneliness, humiliation and loss of dignity’ in determining if someone is eligible for assisted suicide, while Washington state is debating whether to allow euthanasia for people who are disabled but not terminally ill.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Jennifer Lopez pays tribute to lesbian aunt at GLAAD Awards in LA: "I always wanted to be like her"

JLo is honored along with ABC Family's The Fosters which she produces
Lesbian soccer teammates get married, shut down haters with one Instagram post

Lesbian soccer teammates get married, shut down haters with one Instagram post

'Thank you for teaching me what truly loving someone and others is all about, amen'
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Gay celebrities tweet holiday wishes to all

John Barrowman, Ellen DeGeneres, Jesse Tyler Ferguson spread holiday cheer and share their wishes for others
No thumbnail available

World Bank suspends $90 million loan to Uganda over anti-gay law as currency dips

Uganda is seeing further financial consequences over the passing of its notorious Anti-Homosexuality Bill that jails gays for life with the World Bank suspending a major development loan
No thumbnail available

Michelle Obama goes head-to-head with gay rights heckler

First Lady of the United States scolds lesbian protester by threatening to leave the Democratic fundraiser
No thumbnail available

Rev. Luis Leon says gays created 'in God's image' during benediction at Obama inaugural

Leon replaced Louie Giglio who had anti-gay sermon in his past
No thumbnail available

Bisexual Bret Easton Ellis claims porn star cast in Fifty Shades of Grey

American Psycho author tweets that US porn actor James Deen will play Christian Grey in forthcoming adaptation of erotic bestseller
No thumbnail available

National Assembly of France votes for gay marriage

The French National Assembly have voted within the last hour to approve gay marriage
No thumbnail available

President Obama appoints gay black man to federal bench

William Thomas would serve on US District Court in Florida