Challenge to Singapore sodomy law given green light

A constitutional challenge which may be the key to ending Singapore’s ban on sex between men has been given a green light to go ahead by the country’s Court of Appeal
 

Challenge to Singapore sodomy law given green light
22 August 2012

Singapore’s Court of Appeal has decided that a constitutional challenge to the country’s colonial era law banning sex between men can go ahead.

In March, Singapore’s High Court dismissed the challenge, filed by Tan Eng Hong, a man who was caught having oral sex with another man in a public toilet.

Both men were charged under Section 377A of the Singaporean Penal Code but after Tan launched the constitutional challenge to the law the Attorney General of Singapore withdrew the charge and substituted it with another – committing an obscene act in public.

The High Court found that Tan had a legitimate interest in the issue as he was affected by the law, but that the case was not one of ‘real controversy’ as, since the Section 377A charge had been replaced with another, the matter had become ‘merely hypothetical.’

Appeal judges Andrew Phang, V K Rajah and Judith Prakesh found that the law ‘affects the lives of a not insignificant portion of our community in a very real and intimate way,’ as 377A outlawed both public and private sex acts.

They found that Tan’s rights had been violated by the law as a sexually active gay man, and that there was a prima facie case to be made that the law violated provisions for the equality of the sexes in the constitution as it only criminalized same-sex behavior between men while lesbians went unpunished.

The judges also noted that Singapore’s Attorney General was unable to say whether a law passed before Singapore’s independence could not be struck down by court.

Indulekshmi Rajeswari, one of Tan’s lawyers wrote that the verdict was a breakthrough for Singapore’s LGBT community, who held their forth annual Pink Dot pride festival this year.

‘This judgment is nothing less than earth-shattering for the LGBT community,’ Rajeswari wrote in an op-ed on the Sayoni website.

‘For the first time, the Courts have acknowledged the existence of the gay person, and the gay community, and their interests. Furthermore, for the first time, they have acknowledged that s377A is "alive and kicking", and has effects on the community beyond that of direct enforcement.’

‘While we await the next step, we can take a moment to celebrate a significant step in our march towards equal rights.’

The Singaporean government declared that the law would not be proactively enforced in October of 2007. However lawmakers have refused to act to decriminalize homosexuality despite the country’s revered first post-independence prime minister Lee Quan Yew urging the Government to do so.

Lee Quan Yew’s son is the current prime minister of Singapore and Lee Senior has said that he would accept a gay grandchild.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Birmingham Pride reveals record ticket sales

Huge crowds expected to see Jess Glynne headline this weekend
No thumbnail available

Five men arrested for gay marriage party in Saudi Arabia

Saudi Arabia’s religious police raided a gay marriage party in Mecca, arresting five men
No thumbnail available

Don't ban us from dancing together, say UK same-sex dancers

Ahead of a review of the rules regarding ballroom dance competitions in the UK, dancers demand to be able to compete with same-sex partners if they choose
First Division II US college basketball player comes out

First Division II US college basketball player comes out

22-year-old Derek Schell has become the first ever Division II basketball player with the US National Collegiate Athletic Association to come out publicly while still playing
No thumbnail available

Poet eviscerates anti-gay US congress member Michele Bachmann in spoken word performance

'You buy a new necklace for every hanging, a bottle of Merlot for each overdose'
No thumbnail available

Senior Conservatives launch UK gay marriage campaign

Tories such as London mayor Boris Johnson and Education Secretary Michael Gove are urging backbenchers to back marriage equality
No thumbnail available

Indonesian city seeks gay ban in local Sharia laws

Municipality seeks to ban homosexuality along with prostitution and the consumption of alcohol
No thumbnail available

Texas school district relents, will allow transgender male to wear tux in yearbook

Threatened with federal lawsuit, district has agreed to change its policy to protect gender expression
No thumbnail available

Texas gay couple were denied wedding ceremony 'because of God'

Experts say the refusal from a wedding venue in Texas is legal because gays and lesbians are not a protected class under US law  
No thumbnail available

Second Australian legal expert backs legality of Tasmanian same-sex marriage law

A second leading expert on the Australian Constitution has said Tasmania can pass a law to allow same-sex marriage at a state level and believes a High Court challenge against it by the Australian Government is likely to fail