Christians who refused to help gays take case to European court

Lillian Ladele and Gary McFarlane, who refused to provide services for gay people, are among four Christians taking appeals to European Court of Human Rights today

Christians who refused to help gays take case to European court
04 September 2012

A man and a woman who refused to do their jobs for gay people are among four British Christians taking employment tribunal appeals to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) today (4 September).

The two, who said their religious beliefs meant they shouldn’t be asked to provide services for lesbian, gay and bisexual people, are joined by two more people who fought to be able to wear a crucifix symbol at work.

Lillian Ladele was a marriage registrar for Islington Borough Council in north London who refused to conduct civil partnership ceremonies for same-sex couples when they were legalized in 2004.

But in 2007 bosses changed the way she was employed, so she could no longer choose to avoid civil partnerships.

She argued Islington bosses were forcing her to chose between her religious beliefs and her job. She won her case in 2008 but an Employment Tribunal Appeal hearing reversed that decision in December of that year and that new ruling in the council’s favor was upheld in 2009 by the Court of Appeal.

Gary McFarlane’s worked for relationship counseling organization Relate at a time when it was making big strides to include lesbian and gay couples as well as heterosexuals.

He was a sex therapist – which Relate describes as ‘unshockable’ counselors dedicated to people improving their sex lives to help them improve their relationship.

But as a Christian, McFarlane said he wouldn’t be prepared to work with gay and lesbian couples in that way if the subject ever came up.

He was suspended in October 2007 and eventually dismissed for gross misconduct in March 2008.

His case was turned down by an internal appeal board within Relate, then by an Employment Tribunal. An appeal also failed and in 2010 the Court of Appeal twice refused to allow him further appeals.

They will be joined at the ECHR by two other Christians, Nadia Eweida and Shirley Chaplin who both lost their fights to wear their crucifixes at work.

Robert Pigott, religious affairs correspondent for BBC News, predicted the rulings in the cases would be significant.

He said: ‘By making this as an oral hearing, the European Court is clearly troubled by it and taking it very seriously.

‘Attention will focus especially on the ruling in the cases where Christians claim they faced discrimination by being forced to provide services to gay people despite their belief that homosexual practice was wrong.

‘It seems likely that, whatever is decided in Strasbourg, Christians will soon be able to wear crosses at work, but the judgment on their beliefs about homosexuality will be far-reaching.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Trailblazer: La Voix – 'I have custom-made headphones – on-flight ones don't fit over my hair!'

The former Britain's Got Talent star on her life in travel – from cruising around Fort Lauderdale to a holiday romance with a sexy Frenchman...
No thumbnail available

Nigerian author risks jail by coming out as gay

'The culture of shaming and silence has harmed us as people, especially in Africa.'
No thumbnail available

India ‘party of the people’ promises to legalize gay sex, marriage

Upcoming political party has stunned the LGBTI community, who the Supreme Court made illegal last year, by fighting for equality
No thumbnail available

Supreme Court halts gay marriages in Utah

As more than 900 couples have married in the US state since the ban on same-sex marriage was ruled unconstitutional, they will all be waiting to see whether these unions will become void
No thumbnail available

Support for gay marriage growing in Malta

A survey reveals majority of young people in Malta are in favor of same-sex marriage
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Anti-gay US pundit slams GLAAD survey

Family advocate Brent Bozell accuses GLAAD of intimidating pro-family Hollywood writers, producers, and directors
No thumbnail available

Republican US Senator who supports gay marriage says run for national office will be difficult

Ohio's Rob Portman came out for marriage equality after his son came out as gay
No thumbnail available

Zachary Quinto pays moving tribute to fellow Spock, Leonard Nimoy, during TV appearance

'We should all be so lucky to live half as a fulfilled life as he did'
No thumbnail available

Michael Sam leaves CFL training camp before first preseason game

'The team has left the door open and Michael is welcome to come back whenever he feels ready'