Citing religious beliefs, Indiana bakery refuses to bake cake for gay couple’s ceremony

111 Cakery responds to backlash on Facebook: 'We are just a small family business trying to bring happiness with cake'

Citing religious beliefs, Indiana bakery refuses to bake cake for gay couple’s ceremony
14 March 2014

Indiana bakery owners Randy and Trish McGath are facing online backlash for refusing to bake a cake for a gay couple’s commitment ceremony.

The couple, owners of 111 Cakery in Indianapolis, posted a lengthy Facebook message on Thursday (13 March) explaining they have ‘zero hate’ but that their Christian beliefs led them to decline to make a cake for Mike Stephens and Shane Laney.

The reaction on Facebook has been harsh with such messages being posted as ‘Hate is hate, even if you cover it with frosting!’ and ‘Jesus would bake a cake for everyone.’

In their Facebook post, the couple stresses that as Christians they have ‘sincere love’ for people and a ‘commitment to treat every person that walks through the door with respect and kindness.’

The trouble was, they would not be able to ‘find the inspiration’ to make a cake for such an occasion.

‘It was not that we wanted to deny them a cake, it’s just tough to create something that goes against your beliefs,’ they wrote. ‘Was this the right thing to say? Maybe not. But this phone call caused us to do a lot of soul searching because we want to be right with our God as well as respect others.’

Stephens, who made the call to order the cake, tells Fox 59, that ‘we found someone who will do it for us so we are going to focus on the good.’

The bakery owners, clearly surprised by the backlash, say they would welcome the chance to meet with Stephens and want people to know: ‘There is zero hate here.’

They describe themselves as ‘just a small family business trying to bring happiness with cake’ and say they have ‘happily’ done cakes in the past for gay people.

‘We are not judging the lives of our clients,’ they add. ‘We are not trying to make a political statement or change someone’s mind.’

But it may be too late to change the minds of some people who believe the couple are anti-gay bigots.

‘If you’re looking for a judgement and bigotry-flavored cake, you’ve come to the right place,’ wrote Ryan White on the bakery’s Facebook page.

Another man, Philip Steinbacher, wrote on Facebook: ‘I imagine that when Jesus fed the multitudes from the fishes and loaves he did background checks on everyone’s sexuality to make sure they "inspired" him to perform his miracle. You can tell yourself your decision isn’t based on hatred but, hey, the rest of us see right through it. Telling my friends in Indianapolis not to patronize your bakery.’

But there is some support including from Penny Basey Prince who wrote on Facebook: ‘Best cupcakes ever. We stand with you and are praying for you.’



No thumbnail available

Jersey church: Gay marriage would make couples more likely to cheat

Jersey Evangelical Church, in a leaked letter, same-sex couples already have civil partnerships and a ‘small minority’ should not be allowed to change the definition of marriage
No thumbnail available

Now TalkTalk blocks Lib Dem gay site as ‘porn’

Liberal Democrat LGBT website isn’t sexed up but it is victim of online blocking by British internet service provider
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Brazil trans stoned to death

A Brazilian trans was stoned to death by a group of assailants in the city of Aracaju 
No thumbnail available

Gay radio host badly beaten up in Denmark

A crowd of young men allegedly attacked the openly gay DJ after he left a bar in central Copenhagen
These seven tubs will get you hot

These seven tubs will get you hot

Seduction is imminent with these exciting and relaxing tubs nestled in chic city hotels, overlooking beaches and hidden at the ends of the earth
No thumbnail available

George Michael cancels Australian tour due to 'major anxiety'

Gay pop legend's Perth concert will be played by Sir Elton John, celebrating 40 years of Rocket Man
No thumbnail available

Illinois governor Pat Quinn sets date for gay marriage law signing: 20 November

But same-sex couples will not be able to get married in the state until next June
No thumbnail available

India moves to officially ban same-sex couples from adopting children

Proposed legislative change is the latest move in the country’s clampdown on LGBTI rights
Meet this year's top 20 Australian employers for LGBTI workers

Meet this year's top 20 Australian employers for LGBTI workers

Australian LGBTI workplace inclusion group Pride In Diversity has announced the winners of its annual business awards and many industry leading companies and institutions are among the winners