Citing religious beliefs, Indiana bakery refuses to bake cake for gay couple’s ceremony

111 Cakery responds to backlash on Facebook: 'We are just a small family business trying to bring happiness with cake'

Citing religious beliefs, Indiana bakery refuses to bake cake for gay couple’s ceremony
14 March 2014 Print This Article

Indiana bakery owners Randy and Trish McGath are facing online backlash for refusing to bake a cake for a gay couple’s commitment ceremony.

The couple, owners of 111 Cakery in Indianapolis, posted a lengthy Facebook message on Thursday (13 March) explaining they have ‘zero hate’ but that their Christian beliefs led them to decline to make a cake for Mike Stephens and Shane Laney.

The reaction on Facebook has been harsh with such messages being posted as ‘Hate is hate, even if you cover it with frosting!’ and ‘Jesus would bake a cake for everyone.’

In their Facebook post, the couple stresses that as Christians they have ‘sincere love’ for people and a ‘commitment to treat every person that walks through the door with respect and kindness.’

The trouble was, they would not be able to ‘find the inspiration’ to make a cake for such an occasion.

‘It was not that we wanted to deny them a cake, it’s just tough to create something that goes against your beliefs,’ they wrote. ‘Was this the right thing to say? Maybe not. But this phone call caused us to do a lot of soul searching because we want to be right with our God as well as respect others.’

Stephens, who made the call to order the cake, tells Fox 59, that ‘we found someone who will do it for us so we are going to focus on the good.’

The bakery owners, clearly surprised by the backlash, say they would welcome the chance to meet with Stephens and want people to know: ‘There is zero hate here.’

They describe themselves as ‘just a small family business trying to bring happiness with cake’ and say they have ‘happily’ done cakes in the past for gay people.

‘We are not judging the lives of our clients,’ they add. ‘We are not trying to make a political statement or change someone’s mind.’

But it may be too late to change the minds of some people who believe the couple are anti-gay bigots.

‘If you’re looking for a judgement and bigotry-flavored cake, you’ve come to the right place,’ wrote Ryan White on the bakery’s Facebook page.

Another man, Philip Steinbacher, wrote on Facebook: ‘I imagine that when Jesus fed the multitudes from the fishes and loaves he did background checks on everyone’s sexuality to make sure they "inspired" him to perform his miracle. You can tell yourself your decision isn’t based on hatred but, hey, the rest of us see right through it. Telling my friends in Indianapolis not to patronize your bakery.’

But there is some support including from Penny Basey Prince who wrote on Facebook: ‘Best cupcakes ever. We stand with you and are praying for you.’



No thumbnail available

Here are the 12 hottest and most romantic gay kisses from TV and film

Warm yourself up this Valentine's Day with GSN reader suggestions of the best male/male romances
No thumbnail available

Colombia minister determined to make gay marriage legal

While the majority of Colombians are opposed to same-sex marriage, the government say they are committed to equality
No thumbnail available

Grandfather, 90, came out to his gay grandson five months before he died

An artist shares his grandfather's story of how he was in love with a boy he played music with at church, and that was the 'love of his life'
No thumbnail available

Idaho Governor Butch Otter pledges to keep fighting to uphold state's gay marriage ban

'Idaho is pro traditional marriage. And I am not going to do anything to put that in danger'
No thumbnail available

Thugs brutally beat gay yoga teacher and partner in US

About five teens viciously attack gay couple on walk home from dinner date in Washington DC
No thumbnail available

Indian slam official hypocrisy over gay sex legalization

Indians have slammed their government for both supporting and appealing against the court decision which decriminalized gay sex
No thumbnail available

Man arrested at protest against police brutality in Sydney

One arrest at peaceful protest calling for an end to police brutality, after heavy-handed behavior of New South Wales police at Sydney Mardi Gras was caught on camera
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Matt Bomer on losing more than 35 pounds to play man dying of AIDS in The Normal Heart

'That's what I signed up for ... and it's the least I could do for (playwright) Larry Kramer'
No thumbnail available

Slovakia’s annual LGBTI pride parade has been cancelled until 2016

The organizers of the annual Duhovy PRIDE march have cancelled the event for 2015 after a failed referendum to strengthen Slovakia’s ban on same-sex marriage stirred up homophobic attitudes in the nation