Clay Aiken complains that American Idol has become all about the judges

'I don't even know if they remember there are contestants anymore'

Clay Aiken complains that American Idol has become all about the judges
17 December 2012

This spring will mark 10 years ago that Clay Aiken was launched to stardom after finishing as runner-up on American Idol.

He’s one of the show’s biggest breakout stars along with Kelly Clarkson, Jennifer Hudson, Carrie Underwood and Chris Daughtry.

But don’t Aiken doesn’t expect to be invited back to mark the 10 year anniversary of his season.

‘I don’t know that I would commemorate it on the show,’ he tells Billboard.com. ‘I don’t know that they did it with Justin Guarini and all those folks. But ‘Idol’ back in those days was about the contestants. Kelly (Clarkson) and Justin and Tamyra (Gray) and Nikki McKibbin, they were all the stars of the show. And when I was on, Ruben (Studdard) and myself and Kimberly Locke were the stars of the show.’

He has noticed a shift from those early days when Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson were the longtime trio of judges.

Since then, Ellen DeGeneres, Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler have come and gone and most of the upcoming season’s media coverage has focused on a feud between new judges Mariah Carey and Nicki Minaj.

‘Now Idol is about the judges,’ says Aiken. ‘I don’t even know if they remember there are contestants anymore.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

It’s time the US eased the ban on gay men giving blood

Campaigner Michael Kevin Hernandez wants more gay and bisexual men to have the right to be superheroes and give blood
No thumbnail available

Photo one for test slideshow

If you are seeing this article, we are sorry for the inconvenience.
No thumbnail available

Update: AllOut call for emergency international call-in over St Petersburg bill

Campaign group urges bombardment of foreign ministries to prevent 'promotion of homosexuality' bill
No thumbnail available

SPLC adds 'Sodomist Semen' pastor's church to list of anti-LGBTI hate groups

Pastor James David Manning's ATLAH World Missionary Church and three other anti-LGBTI organizations have been added to the 2014 list
No thumbnail available

Sexual harassment and sex trade plagues annual transgender festival in India

Hundreds of transgender women were in Koovagam, Tamil Nadu for the festival but sexual harassment and sex trade is degrading the celebration
No thumbnail available

Gay Star News named Publication of the Year by Stonewall

Gay Star News has been honored as the Publication of the Year 2012 at the prestigious Stonewall Awards – just 11 months after we launched.
First Division II US college basketball player comes out

First Division II US college basketball player comes out

22-year-old Derek Schell has become the first ever Division II basketball player with the US National Collegiate Athletic Association to come out publicly while still playing
No thumbnail available

Australian lesbian Senate leader rejects marriage equality referendum call by Prime Minister

Australian openly lesbian Senate leader Penny Wong has rejected plans by her own prime minister for a referendum or plebiscite on same-sex marriage
No thumbnail available

Looking back through the years of black gay love

Before homosexuality was even legal, black LGBT people burst through discrimination to celebrate their relationships
No thumbnail available

Co-founder of America’s first gay police association, Sam Ciccone has died

Sam Ciccone, who co-founded New York’s Gay Officers Action League in 1982, died 10 May in his home aged 71