Costa Rican lawyers claim ‘accidental’ bill does nothing for same-sex unions

Constitutional lawyers say that same-sex couples still lack the ‘legal capacity’ to enter into any type of civil unions.

Costa Rican lawyers claim ‘accidental’ bill does nothing for same-sex unions
06 July 2013

Experts claim Costa Rica is no closer to allowing same-sex unions.

In a landmark ‘mistake’ this week, 45 Costa Rican politicians unknowingly approved a bill some believe could be a legal gateway to same-sex partnerships.

According to Costa Rican newspaper La Nación which broke the story earlier this week, lawyers Marvin Carvajal, Rubén Hernández and Pedro Beirute along with Judge Hector Amoretti believe that a ‘legal capacity’ clause in the new bill will hinder the wording from applying to same-sex couples. 

The text, included in Paragraph 4 of the Law of Young People, recognizes ‘the right to recognition without discrimination contrary to human dignity, social and economic effects of domestic partnerships that constitute publicly, notoriously unique and stable, with legal capacity for marriage for more than three years’.

The legal capacity, however, has been established Paragraph 6 of Article 14 of the Family Code, which by law prohibits the marriage between people of the same sex.

The attorneys suggest that the amendments to the Law of Young People do not in effect change Article 242, which states that only a man and a woman can possess the ‘legal capacity’ to marry, or also enter into a civil partnership with all the corresponding rights and benefits. 

The new bill, already signed by president Laura Chinchilla, is now at the center of a legal and political debate as to whether or not the controversial wording has any standing to legalize same-sex partnerships.

Politicians begged Chinchilla to veto the very bill they had approved, but the Costa Rican president said: ‘No, we’re going to go forward and I will sign this law.

‘We understand that the debate is over how some interpret the law and this alone is not sufficient for the executive to veto the law.’

Moving forward, Judge Amoretti said individual case analyses will have to consider which elements hold more weight: the legal capacity to marry or the legal protection from discrimination.
 

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Wrestler at Catholic high school in Iowa comes out to coach - who also happens to be his dad

Cole Fox leaves remarkable two-page coming out letter in dad's pocket who later texts son: 'You are still a great son and I am proud of you'
No thumbnail available

Nepal committee recommends legalizing same-sex marriage

'Nepal will have the marriage equality law, it's just a matter of time'
No thumbnail available

Robbie Williams makes gay joke about John Travolta

British pop singer Robbie WIlliams points to pregnant wife as proof he's not gay
No thumbnail available

Ben Cohen launches grooming range with Jet2.com

Rugby star teams up with British airline for first foray into nail care
No thumbnail available

GLAAD determined to carry on with workload after resignation of its president

Spokesman Wilson Cruz tells GSN: 'GLAAD has been here for 28 years and we're not going anywhere'
Gay teen, 14, 'hanged from tree' at boys' summer camp in Iran

Gay teen, 14, 'hanged from tree' at boys' summer camp in Iran

Unconfirmed reports: Cleric told the boys' camp the young teen was 'deserving of death'
No thumbnail available

Beautiful Thing returns to West End, will tour UK

Britain's best gay play will star Eastenders' actress Charlie Brooks
No thumbnail available

London Pride gets ‘go’ with parade, party and rally

Lesbian tennis superstar Martina Navratilova to launch week of events. Summer Rites music festival added. Gala dinner with London mayor
No thumbnail available

Days of Our Lives gay couple will finally have a sex scene on daytime soap

See preview of Will and Sonny's upcoming love scene
No thumbnail available

What is in Labour's LGBT manifesto?

British political party pledges to review gender identity law, tackle homophobic bullying and deliver 'Turing's Law'