Court throws out first case for St Petersburg gay hate law

Police evidence that two gay activists ‘promoted homosexuality to minors’ was insufficient

Court throws out first case for St Petersburg gay hate law
07 April 2012

The two gay activists arrested in St Petersburg on Thursday (5 April) have been released by a court.

They were the first two people arrested in the Russian city under its new legislation which bans ‘the promotion of homosexuality to minors’ and had faced fines of 5,000 roubles ($172 €125) each and 15 days imprisonment if found guilty.

Magistrate Alexei Kuznetsov ruled on Friday that the evidence presented by the police that Alexei Kiselev and Cyril Nepomnyashiy had contravened the now-infamous ‘gay propaganda to minors’ law did not meet legal requirements.

According to reports, Kiselyov and Nepomnyashiy had travelled from Moscow to St Petersburg to challenge the law and displayed placards simply saying ‘Gay – this is normal’.

GayRussia.eu reported this evening that ‘based on available information at our disposal, the police evidence did not specify the detailed content of the activists, even posters’.

Nikolai Alekseev, founder of Moscow Pride and GayRussia, is the legal representative for the two.

He told Gay Star News: ‘Posters themselves were not brought to court by police as evidence’

And the court refused to hear the ‘administrative offence’ that Kiselev and Nepomnyashiy were also charged with – namely that they had not applied for a license to hold their protest.

‘The fate of these administrative cases is dependent on the actions of the police to address the violations,’ Alekseev said. ‘If the records are returned to the court, the magistrate will consider the case and give a verdict. But in such cases, the police often simply close the case.

‘It shows the absolute inoperability of the law, initiated by the deputy Vitaly Milonov. Remember that last Wednesday the activists from the St Petersburg LGBT organisation Equality, Yuri and Maria Gavrikov Efremenkova, held pickets near the Junior Library.

‘The the police did not intervene. But the following day, the two activists from Moscow Gay Pride staged a similar picket at the Palace of Youth Creativity on Nevsky Prospect – and were arrested within half an hour and taken to the police department.’

The pair had spent a night in police cells before being taken in front of the court where they were released.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Pro-gay Catholic Church to ordain a trans male priest

The North American Old Catholic Church, one of the largest Old Catholic bodies in the United States, will ordain Shannon Kearns
No thumbnail available

Ugandan Government spokesman says "we don’t need your aid" to US over gay issue

A spokesperson for Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni has said his country can ‘do without’ humanitarian and development aid from the United States if it tries to force it to back down on making homosexuality an offense worthy of life imprisonment
No thumbnail available

Dolly Parton says she supports same-sex marriage

Country music star and long time LGBTI rights supporter Dolly Parton has announced she supports the rights of gay and lesbian couples to marry
No thumbnail available

Gay film-maker wins best film at India's Oscars

Surprise win for independent film at Bollywood's biggest awards bash
No thumbnail available

Australian states revolt on marriage equality

The state South Australia looks set to become the second Australian state to legalize same-sex marriage while the territory that houses the Australian capital will restore official ceremonies to its civil unions scheme
No thumbnail available

Europe Court of Justice: Lifelong gay blood bans are unjustified

‘Sexual orientation is not in itself a risk' - Gay rights activists are calling for all lifelong bans on gay and bisexual men donating blood to be lifted
No thumbnail available

You can now call a police horse ‘gay’, UK rules

The House of Lords has ruled to amend a law which allowed police to arrest anyone who used insulting behavior
No thumbnail available

House of Cards star Kevin Spacey shuts down when asked about his private life

'Let's let people live their lives and do it the way they want to do it'
No thumbnail available

US Christian radio show host Kevin Swanson claims Disney’s Frozen is gay indoctrination

American Christian radio show host and pastor Kevin Swanson believes that Disney is trying to turn his 5-year-old daughter into a lesbian through the movie Frozen and has suggested the media giant is being controlled by Satan
No thumbnail available

Teachers need more training, says gay charity

Schools Out campaign call for better equality training for teachers