Death certificate case deals Ohio’s gay marriage ban a major legal blow

Federal judge opens the door to further challenges with his comments that the ban is unconstitutional

Death certificate case deals Ohio’s gay marriage ban a major legal blow
23 December 2013

A week after gay marriage bans in New Mexico and Utah were struck down, a legal ruling in Ohio on Monday (23 December) may have paved the way for the end of a ban in that state as well.

Judge Timothy Black has ordered that gay marriages be recognized on Ohio death certificates. In his written opinion, he makes clear he believes the state’s ban on same-sex unions is unconstitutional.

This is expected to lead to further legal challenges of Ohio’s ban. Such challenges are experiencing increasing success since the US Supreme Court gutted the Defense of Marriage Act in June.

Writes Black: ‘ … The question presented is whether a state can do what the federal government cannot — i.e., discriminate against same-sex couples … simply because the majority of the voters don’t like homosexuality (or at least didn’t in 2004). Under the Constitution of the United States, the answer is no.’

Black had previously ruled that the marriage of Ohio residents John Arthur and Jim Obergefell be legally recognized after Black’s death.

The couple went to great lengths to get married in July because Arthur was dying from ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig’s disease.

They were forced to raise $12,700 to charter a private plane and get married in Maryland where same-sex marriage is legal. Their seven-minute ceremony took place on an airport tarmac.

Arthur died in October.

They filed the federal lawsuit claiming it was unconstitutional for Ohio to not recognize their marriage.

Black writes: ‘ … Once you get married lawfully in one state, another state cannot summarily take your marriage away. … When a state effectively terminates the marriage of a same-sex couple married in another jurisdiction, it intrudes into the realm of private marital, family, and intimate relations specifically protected by the Supreme Court.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Discomfort over homosexuality helps spread HIV in China

Stigmas about homosexuality have kept people from seeking HIV testing, leading to a dramatic increase in the number of cases among gay men
No thumbnail available

Daniel Docherty: ‘The reaction to our ally program was overwhelming’

A Vice President at Bank of America Merill Lynch, Docherty reflects on the success of the organization’s Ally program in fostering an environment of diversity and inclusion
No thumbnail available

Gay coal miners and female-to-male transgenders win film funding in China

LGBT film training in Beijing awards two fledgling filmmakers the chance to make documentaries
No thumbnail available

TV show starring Cedric the Entertainer takes on same-sex marriage

The National Black Justice Coalition describes the gay marriage episode of The Soul Man as 'loving and light-hearted.'
No thumbnail available

Sweden ends forced sterilization of trans

Sweden repeals law which meant a trans person must be sterilized to have their gender change recognized legally
No thumbnail available

Turkey's new draft army bill still punishes gays and trans

Turkish government’s revised draft regulation for the army continues to criminalize gay and transgender people as ‘unnatural intercourse’ and will be used as reason for discrimination and punishment  
No thumbnail available

WWE wrestling star Darren Young comes out as gay

US sporting professional is believed to be the first in WWE wrestling to come out and continue competing professionally
No thumbnail available

Even after 60 pound weight loss, Lee Daniels still directs in his pajamas

But the out writer-director wore a suit when explaining why to crush Seth Meyers
No thumbnail available

Cartoonist says anti-gay violence comic was 'only a joke'

A student newspaper in Arizona has apologized for publishing a cartoon which has been accused of promoting homophobic violence
No thumbnail available

Jim Davidson: 'I'm no gay hater, I had ladyboy sex'

British comedian and Celebrity Big Brother contestant says he is not homophobic because he had oral sex with a Thai ladyboy