Delhi High Court judge who legalized gay sex saddened by Supreme Court ruling

The Delhi High Court judge who legalized homosexuality in India in 2009 has spoken out against the Supreme Court ruling that overturned his decision, saying he feels deeply sad for India’s LGBTI community

Delhi High Court judge who legalized gay sex saddened by Supreme Court ruling
23 December 2013

Former Delhi High Court judge AP Shah who legalized homosexuality in India in 2009 has spoken of his disappointment at the decision by two Supreme Court justices to overturn his decision.

‘My first feeling was deep sadness about those people, the LGBT community,’ Shah, who is now India’s Law Commission chairman, said during a interview on CNN India on Sunday.

‘I was disappointed … Given the subject matter of the appeal, I thought that our views would prevail.’

Shah also spoke in depth on the issue to the Indian Express, saying it was ironic that India was holding on to a law the British had passed to suppress what they thought were Indian vices.

‘Some speak of this as a “western disease,”’ Shah told the newspaper.

‘First of all, it is not western. Temple imagery and essential scriptures show there is some evidence of homosexuality being practiced in this country… The British brought in Section 377 and there is the presumption that one of the reasons was they feared their army and daughters would be tainted by Oriental vices.’

Shah said it was vital that the majority did not decide the rights of minorities.

‘What is envisaged by the Constitution is not popular morality,’ Shah said.

‘Public morality is the reflection of the moral normative values of the majority of the population, but Constitutional morality derives its contents from the values of the Constitution.’

‘For instance, untouchability was approved by the majority, but the Constitution prohibited untouchability as a part of social engineering. [Wife burning] was at one time approved by the majority, but in today’s world, it would be completely inconsistent with the Constitution.’

The Indian Government says it wants homosexuality to be legal again but is seeking a judicial review of the Supreme Court’s decision rather than putting forward legislation of its own to solve the issue as there is an election in 5 months.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Republican Senator Marco Rubio is anti-gay marriage but says he's not a bigot

'I respect people who disagree with me on certain things, but that means they have to respect me too'
No thumbnail available

LGBTs rejecting Rhode Island’s flawed civil unions

LGBT couples in the US state of Rhode Island are refusing to make use of the state’s civil unions which can be legally ignored by any entity owned by a religious group
No thumbnail available

Same-sex marriage bill fails in South Australia

A bill to legalize same-sex marriage in the Australian state of South Australia has failed in the Lower House despite having the support of the state’s Premier, but another bill is before the Upper House
No thumbnail available

Five Russian thugs film their vicious attack on trans woman

LGBT young people are being left traumatized, with some reportedly committing suicide, after they are captured by neo-Nazis and humiliated in front of video cameras
No thumbnail available

Murdered man had left Egypt for a freer life in Sydney

Family say Ahmed Ghoniem came to Australia to live free from persecution over his sexuality
No thumbnail available

Uzbekistan's president: being gay is 'disgusting' and causes moral decay

According to a US diplomatic cable leaked by Wikileaks, Uzbekistan's president thinks that being gay causes the moral 'decay' of Western 'style' democracies
No thumbnail available

Good Morning America's gay weather anchor is leaving ABC after 25 years

Sam Champion accepts 'amazing opportunity' with the Weather Channel
No thumbnail available

Bangladesh opposes UN call to legalize gay sex

The country's UN ambassador says LGBTI rights 'go against our values'
No thumbnail available

Fatboy Slim joins Freemasons at Brighton Pride

Weapon of Choice chart-topper to get pride partygoers' blood pumping at UK city's annual LGBT festival