Delhi High Court judge who legalized gay sex saddened by Supreme Court ruling

The Delhi High Court judge who legalized homosexuality in India in 2009 has spoken out against the Supreme Court ruling that overturned his decision, saying he feels deeply sad for India’s LGBTI community

Delhi High Court judge who legalized gay sex saddened by Supreme Court ruling
23 December 2013

Former Delhi High Court judge AP Shah who legalized homosexuality in India in 2009 has spoken of his disappointment at the decision by two Supreme Court justices to overturn his decision.

‘My first feeling was deep sadness about those people, the LGBT community,’ Shah, who is now India’s Law Commission chairman, said during a interview on CNN India on Sunday.

‘I was disappointed … Given the subject matter of the appeal, I thought that our views would prevail.’

Shah also spoke in depth on the issue to the Indian Express, saying it was ironic that India was holding on to a law the British had passed to suppress what they thought were Indian vices.

‘Some speak of this as a “western disease,”’ Shah told the newspaper.

‘First of all, it is not western. Temple imagery and essential scriptures show there is some evidence of homosexuality being practiced in this country… The British brought in Section 377 and there is the presumption that one of the reasons was they feared their army and daughters would be tainted by Oriental vices.’

Shah said it was vital that the majority did not decide the rights of minorities.

‘What is envisaged by the Constitution is not popular morality,’ Shah said.

‘Public morality is the reflection of the moral normative values of the majority of the population, but Constitutional morality derives its contents from the values of the Constitution.’

‘For instance, untouchability was approved by the majority, but the Constitution prohibited untouchability as a part of social engineering. [Wife burning] was at one time approved by the majority, but in today’s world, it would be completely inconsistent with the Constitution.’

The Indian Government says it wants homosexuality to be legal again but is seeking a judicial review of the Supreme Court’s decision rather than putting forward legislation of its own to solve the issue as there is an election in 5 months.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Protesters call for Ukraine to reject anti-gay bill

Campaigners in Brussels, Belgium, picketed Ukrainian Mission over proposals to ban 'homosexual propaganda'
No thumbnail available

Australian climate change minister comes out in support of gay marriage

Majority of Australian cabinet now support gay marriage, Australian Marriage Equality say
No thumbnail available

Trans actress Laverne Cox presented with GLAAD's highest honor by newly out Ellen Page

Cox praises the organization for making 'sure that the "T" is not silent in the LGBT community"
No thumbnail available

Judge in court-martial of gay US Army soldier reaches a decision

Col. Denise Lind, the presiding judge Col. Denise Lind, the presiding judge in the trial gay Army Pfc. Bradley Manning, will announce her ruling on 30 July
No thumbnail available

Opposition admits involvement in Slipper case

  Former Australian Liberal cabinet minister admits urging Slipper case to go to court
No thumbnail available

Male transgender student can't run for homecoming king, must be on ballot for queen

Decision comes days after California female trans student elected homecoming queen
No thumbnail available

Lesbian super PAC launches to push gay and women's rights

Actress Jane Lynch and tennis star Billy Jean King pledge support to the political action committee formed by a Republican businessman's daughter
No thumbnail available

Canadian Young Liberals want end to gay blood donation ban

The youth wing of the Liberal Party of Canada are campaigning to end their country’s exclusion of gay men as blood donors if they have had sex with another man in the last five years
No thumbnail available

Taiwan Pride promos

The organizers of Saturday’s Taiwan Pride have released heartwarming promotional videos
No thumbnail available

Modern Family, Chaz Bono and Josh Hutcherson receive GLAAD Awards

Star-studded LA ceremony includes appearances by Ellen DeGeneres, Betty White and surprise presenter Cher