Delhi High Court judge who legalized gay sex saddened by Supreme Court ruling

The Delhi High Court judge who legalized homosexuality in India in 2009 has spoken out against the Supreme Court ruling that overturned his decision, saying he feels deeply sad for India’s LGBTI community

Delhi High Court judge who legalized gay sex saddened by Supreme Court ruling
23 December 2013

Former Delhi High Court judge AP Shah who legalized homosexuality in India in 2009 has spoken of his disappointment at the decision by two Supreme Court justices to overturn his decision.

‘My first feeling was deep sadness about those people, the LGBT community,’ Shah, who is now India’s Law Commission chairman, said during a interview on CNN India on Sunday.

‘I was disappointed … Given the subject matter of the appeal, I thought that our views would prevail.’

Shah also spoke in depth on the issue to the Indian Express, saying it was ironic that India was holding on to a law the British had passed to suppress what they thought were Indian vices.

‘Some speak of this as a “western disease,”’ Shah told the newspaper.

‘First of all, it is not western. Temple imagery and essential scriptures show there is some evidence of homosexuality being practiced in this country… The British brought in Section 377 and there is the presumption that one of the reasons was they feared their army and daughters would be tainted by Oriental vices.’

Shah said it was vital that the majority did not decide the rights of minorities.

‘What is envisaged by the Constitution is not popular morality,’ Shah said.

‘Public morality is the reflection of the moral normative values of the majority of the population, but Constitutional morality derives its contents from the values of the Constitution.’

‘For instance, untouchability was approved by the majority, but the Constitution prohibited untouchability as a part of social engineering. [Wife burning] was at one time approved by the majority, but in today’s world, it would be completely inconsistent with the Constitution.’

The Indian Government says it wants homosexuality to be legal again but is seeking a judicial review of the Supreme Court’s decision rather than putting forward legislation of its own to solve the issue as there is an election in 5 months.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Graham Norton warned by BBC for wearing AIDS ribbon

Irish gay chat show host was reprimanded by the British Broadcasting Coporation for supporting World AIDS Day on his programme
No thumbnail available

It's too much pressure for New York Giants player to be asked about having a gay teammate

Terrell Thomas also concerned about players being able to freely walk around locker room naked
No thumbnail available

‘Church gay marriage ban open to legal challenge,’ says Peter Tatchell

Veteran gay rights campaigner says the Church of England and Wales ban on performing same-sex unions is illegal according to European law
No thumbnail available

Taiwanese actress sparks gay marriage controversy

Amber Kuo says proposals to legalize same-sex marriage in Taiwan are 'worrying'
No thumbnail available

Moldova repeals ‘gay propaganda’ ban

The former Eastern Bloc country of Moldova has decided to repeal its ban on the so-called propaganda of homosexuality to minors in the hopes of building greater ties with the European Union
No thumbnail available

Gay film director makes cast and crew go vegan

He and his lead actor have already agreed to strip naked to fund the movie
No thumbnail available

SS16 London Collections: Men - Day 1

We wrap up some of our highlights from the first day of mens fashion mayhem
No thumbnail available

UK’s first gay marriage could take place two weeks earlier

Gay couples where one partner is terminally ill or due to leave for military service can apply to marry as soon a law comes into effect on 13 March
No thumbnail available

First ever EU-wide LGBT survey launched

First online survey on lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender lives covering whole of Europe
No thumbnail available

NZ advertising authority dismisses complaints against Pope gay marriage ad

New Zealand Advertising Standards Authority rules billboard advert depicting the Pope blessing a male couple did not cause widespread offense