DOMA lawyer uses 1885 case to support the law

Defense of Marriage Act lawyer returns to a 1885 polygamy ruling to defend the law

DOMA lawyer uses 1885 case to support the law
29 September 2012

The lawyer defending the Defense of Marriage Act is using an 1885 polygamy case as one of the reasons why the US federal government cannot honor gay marriages.

Paul Clement was in a New York court this week supporting DOMA’s language. The law was passed in 1996 and prohibits the US government from recognizing same-sex marriages, even in states where such unions are legal.

According to Buzzfeed, the lawyer pointed to an 1885 US Supreme Court  case involving polygamy in the then Utah territory. The court wrote that the traditional definition of marriage, one man and woman, is ‘"the sure foundation of all that is stable and noble in our civilization; the best guaranty of that reverent morality which is the source of all beneficent progress in social and political improvement.’

Clement’s clients are the Republican leaders of the US House of Representatives. They have defended DOMA cases ever since 2011 when President Barack Obama informed the Justice Department not to argue for the constitutionality of DOMA. The House may support laws, in courts, if the president refuses to do so.

In this Second Circuit Court of Appeals case, a Edith Windsor maintains DOMA is unconstitional. The widow is suing because she was required to pay a $350,000 federal estate tax bill. The government does not recognize her marriage to a woman.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Russell Grant climbs aboard the HMS Pinafore

Gay Strictly Come Dancing astronomer star to appear in special performances of Gilbert and Sullivan classic
No thumbnail available

Conservative activist says he would claim to be transgender to watch girls changing

Dan Joseph of the right-wing Media Research Center says he would lie and say he was transgender just get into girls’ bathrooms and changing rooms to perv on women
No thumbnail available

South Africa ‘could lose gay rights now Nelson Mandela is gone’

Gay rights activists have said without the figurehead of equality, politicians could easily take away the ‘Rainbow Nation’
No thumbnail available

South Africa and Brazil demand UN action on gay rights

United Nations ambassadors of South Africa and Brazil call for action on sexual orientation and gender identity as universal human rights and want to combat hate crimes
Circuit party Ascension boycotts Fire Island Pines and relocates to Greece

Circuit party Ascension boycotts Fire Island Pines and relocates to Greece

Party's producer says he was influenced by calls to boycott properties owned by gay hotelier Ian Reisner after he hosted party for GOP senator Ted Cruz
No thumbnail available

ACT UP documentary shines light on group able to 'surmount the insurmountable'

How to Survive a Plague opening in LA, NYC, San Francisco and other US cities
No thumbnail available

Harry Styles, Rita Ora and other stars take selfies to support gay charity

Other stars to support Stonewall's 25th anniversary include Sam Smith, Alan Carr and Paloma Faith
No thumbnail available

Beauties demand rights

A transgender woman from the Philippines recently won an international beauty competition, but Filipina trans rights advocate Naomi Fontanos tells Gay Star News there’s more to transgender life than looking beautiful
No thumbnail available

Ty Burrell gets a gay kiss from Matthew Broderick on Modern Family

His character of Phil is clueless as he also shares shirtless hug with gay man
No thumbnail available

Lunch with Sir Ian McKellen in New Zealand for $1,000

Hobbit and Lord of the Rings actor joins fundraiser for New Zealand Labour Party