Edith Windsor talks about being plaintiff in DOMA case to be heard by US Supreme Court

'It’s almost a deliriously joyous thing for an old lady'

Edith Windsor talks about being plaintiff in DOMA case to be heard by US Supreme Court
11 December 2012

The US Defense of Marriage Act prohibited the Internal Revenue Service from treating Edith Windsor as a surviving spouse after her longtime partner’s death in 2009.

Windsor and Thea Spyer had gotten married in Canada two years earlier after 40 years together. But DOMA prevented the US government from recognizing this or any same-sex marriage.

As a result, Windsor was required to pay a $350,000 federal estate tax bill that she would not have had to pay if their marriage had been recognized.

Instead of staying silent, the 83-year-old Windsor sued and won. Then a federal appeals courts in New York ruled that the law is unconstitutional – a ruling appealed to the Supreme Court by the Republican leadership of the House of Representatives.

The Supreme Court announced last week that it would be hearing the case this spring – a development that has Windsor thrilled.

‘It’s thrilling for me to be in this position,’ Windsor tells The New York Times in an interview inside the eighth-floor apartment on Fifth Avenue that she shared with Spyer for three decades. ‘It’s almost a deliriously joyous thing for an old lady.’

She has every confidence in her case.

‘We did our homework, and we got here, and it’s joyous to be here,’ Windsor says. ‘I think we’ll win if there’s justice, meaning they read the briefs and pay attention to the content. But if it doesn’t happen this time, it will happen next time or the next. But it will happen.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Topless Ghost hunk Mark Evans helps Gotye tribute go viral

London's Ghost The Musical leads - gay heartthrob Mark Evans and Siobhan Dillon - make sexy video homage to Somebody That I Used To Know
No thumbnail available

Johnny Weir is on comeback trail

Skating champ says new husband supportive of his latest Olympic bid
No thumbnail available

Young man assaulted and injured on a Jerusalem bus for being gay

A young man from Jerusalem, Israel was verbally abused and brutally assaulted on a night bus for being gay, while passengers and security stood by and did not intervene
No thumbnail available

France's Senate debates gay marriage amid large protests

As France's marriage equality and adoption for same-sex couples bill reaches the next stage, large protests are being planned aiming to persuade Senators to vote against the bill
No thumbnail available

Malaysian deputy prime minister says LGBT rights activists are 'poisoning' the minds of Muslims

Muhyiddin Yassin warns of threat of 'LGBT movement' to Muslims, as the country prepares for a general election on 5 May
No thumbnail available

Witness videotapes two men threatening gay youngsters on a NYC subway after Pride

One suspect threatens a group of young men with sexual violence and to kill a woman
No thumbnail available

First gay man appointed to lead US rabbinical association

Baltimore rabbi Jason Klein has been elected to the role of president of the Reconstructionist Rabbinical Association in what is the first time that a gay man has been appointed to lead a Jewish religious order in the US
No thumbnail available

Gay Star News hits the red carpet of star-studded Trevor Live event in Hollywood

Adam Lambert, Fergie, Andrew Rannells, Kathy Griffin, Chris Colfer, Jane Lynch and others turn out
No thumbnail available

Trans murder toll rises again in Turkey

Another trans women was murdered in Turkey, bringing the 2012 toll to six
No thumbnail available

Ben Cohen takes on rugby hate as teams prepare for gay cup

Ben Cohen and Gareth Thomas back the 39 clubs from 15 countries competing for the gay rugby Bingham Cup