Federal appeals court in Boston rules that DOMA is not constitutional

Case against federal ban on same-sex marriage could wind up in US Supreme Court

Federal appeals court in Boston rules that DOMA is not constitutional
31 May 2012

In two separate cases that test the law as never before, a three-judge panel on the First Circuit Court of Appeals in Boston has found that the Defense of Marriage Act is unconstitutional.

DOMA prevents the US government from recognizing same-sex marriages even in states where such marriages are legal so couples cannot file joint federal tax returns or receive survivor benefits if one spouse dies.

The judges found that denial of federal benefits that opposite-sex couples automatically enjoy violates the guarantee of equal protection under the US Constitution.

The case is next likely to be heard by the US Supreme Court.

DOMA was passed by both houses of Congress by wide margins in 1996 and signed into law by then-President Bill Clinton. Last year, President Barack Obama instructed the Justice Department to no longer defend the constitutionality of DOMA.

The judges wrote in their opinion: ‘Invalidating a federal statute is an unwelcome responsibility for federal judges; the elected Congress speaks for the entire nation, its judgment and good faith being entitled to utmost respect. But a lower federal court such as ours must follow its best understanding of governing precedent, knowing that in large matters the Supreme Court will correct mis-readings (and even if it approves the result will formulate its own explanation).’

The cases at the center of the appeal are Gill v. Office of Personnel Management, which was filed by Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders (GLAD), and Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Department of Health & Human Services filed by Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley.

The ruling comes in the same month that Obama announced his support of same-sex marriage. White House spokesman Jay Carney told reporters Thursday that the appeals court ruling is ‘in concert with the president’s views.’

The American Foundation for Equal Rights, which scored a federal victory of its own by getting California’s Proposition 8 declared unconstitutional, called the  First Circuit Court of Appeals decision ‘momentous.’

AFER Executive Director Adam Umhoefer called it ‘yet another example of the clear pattern of consistent recognition among federal courts that marriage inequality—by any level of government—violates our nation’s core constitutional principles. Whether it is California’s Proposition 8 or the so-called Defense of Marriage Act, court after court has affirmed that marriage discrimination against gay and lesbian Americans is unfair, unjust, and unconstitutional.’

Since DOMA was passed in 1996, many states have instituted their own bans on gay marriage. Meanwhile, eight states have approved it, including Massachusetts, Connecticut, New York, Iowa, New Hampshire, Vermont, Maryland, Washington state and the District of Columbia.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Why does George W Bush refuse to talk about gay marriage?

Former US president says he does not want to 'wade back into politics' but feels free to talk about Obama's immigration policies
No thumbnail available

Uruguay votes to legalize gay marriage

Uruguay is set to become to second country in Latin America to pass a national gay marriage law
No thumbnail available

Canada's first openly gay senator dies aged 83

Tributes pour in for former controversial TV host Laurier LaPierre, who died suddenly on Monday (17 December)
No thumbnail available

Gay uncle of reality star Honey Boo Boo reveals that he is HIV positive

Lee Thompson, known as Uncle Poodle, was infected by boyfriend who 'had not bothered to tell me about it'
No thumbnail available

Arkansas churches refuse funeral for gay man, give hateful Bible verses to husband

Family is handed 10 pages of anti-gay scripture and a sympathy card
No thumbnail available

The rise in popularity of sperm donation from known donors

With the law in the UK now requiring sperm donors to disclose their identity to the authorities, more and more patients are choosing donation from someone they know and trust, says Venessa Smith, of the London Women’s Clinic’s Sperm Bank
No thumbnail available

Gay men to apply to Home Office to wipe pre-1967 convictions

The UK Government has announced the process by which gay men will be able to apply to have any pre-1967 consensual sex convictions wiped from their records
No thumbnail available

Soccer's Robbie Rogers thought more gay pros would be out of closet by now

'I thought for sure when one of us came out other people in our sports would come out too'
No thumbnail available

Australian minister angers gay marriage activists

Australian gay marriage advocates have hit back at their shadow communications minister for suggesting civil unions substitute marriage equality
Trans teen Jazz Jennings’ family are so supportive it hurts

Trans teen Jazz Jennings’ family are so supportive it hurts

We can all learn poignant lessons about being true to yourself, as relatives reveal what it’s really like living with the teen LGBTI activist and YouTube star