Gay couple sues bed and breakfast owner for discrimination

Two British men, both in their 60s, claim they were turned away when asked to be shown to a room with a double bed

Gay couple sues bed and breakfast owner for discrimination
18 September 2012

A gay British couple has sued the owner of a bed and breakfast after she refused to let them stay because of her religious beliefs.

Michael Black, 64, and John Morgan, 69, sought damages from the Christian hotel owner Susanne Wilkinson at Reading County Court yesterday (17 September).

The couple, who booked by email and paid a deposit, were turned away by the owner when they arrived at the Swiss Bed and Breakfast in Cookham, Berkshire in March 2010.

Despite protestations from Black it was unlawful discrimination, the owner refused to allow the couple to stay as it was ‘against her convictions.’

Lawyers from human rights organization Liberty have taken up the case.

James Welch, legal director of Liberty, said: ‘A business with a ‘no gays policy’ is as bad as one that says ‘no blacks; no Irish’.

‘Liberty defends the rights of religious groups to manifest their beliefs, even when we disagree with them, but not to discriminate in the provision of goods and services.’

Welch is arguing under the Equality Act, it is unlawful for service providers to discriminate on grounds of sexual orientation.

Lawyers for Wilkinson argued a person offering bed and breakfast in their own home was entitled to refuse to allow people who were not married or in a civil partnership to share a double bed.

They say as the two men are not in a civil partnership, there was no direct or indirect discrimination.

If Morgan and Black win the case, which will give them about £3,600 ($5,843, €4,467) each in damages, they have promised they will give the money to charity.

Judge Claire Moulder reserved judgment at Reading County Court for one to two weeks.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Gay marriage bill passes New Jersey Assembly

Lawmakers vote 42-33 for passage but governor plans to veto
No thumbnail available

UKIP politician resigns after calling gays 'disgusting poofters'

He blamed the remarks on taking painkillers
No thumbnail available

Trans Navy SEAL Kristin Beck says Warrior Princess book deal led to suicide attempt

War hero blasts her co-author and publisher in scathing Facebook post
No thumbnail available

Top tips for your dream wedding on a budget

Romance began at the office for Shona and Sharon, but when they wed they made sure it didn’t leave them in debt. Read their top tips for a magical wedding at a price you can afford
No thumbnail available

British MP fights against anti-gay abuse in football

John Leech MP will highlight a report pointing out the levels of homophobic abuse suffered by Brighton fans
Australia: Port Hedland is latest council to recognize gay couples

Australia: Port Hedland is latest council to recognize gay couples

'While it's not equivalent to same sex marriage it is a formal recognition of the relationship'
No thumbnail available

Teenage Australian Labor Party candidate expelled for homophobic statements

Candidate in rural Queensland linked to homophobic and racist statements
No thumbnail available

British MPs clash in debate on same-sex marriage

Prime Minister David Cameron has released a televised statement saying marriage equality will make 'society stronger'
No thumbnail available

Ellen DeGeneres tells Robin Roberts it is profound when people really 'get' you

Openly gay GMA host has relaxed and candid interview with openly gay Oscar host
No thumbnail available

Gays still second class in new Moldova equality law

Moldova has adopted a law on equality today, but it has left the gay, bi and trans community as second-class citizens