Gay couple win lawsuit against B&B which refused them

Two British men, both in their 60s, were turned away when asked to be shown to a room with a double bed

Gay couple win lawsuit against B&B which refused them
18 October 2012

A gay British couple has won a lawsuit against the owner of a bed and breakfast after she refused to let them stay because of her religious beliefs.

Michael Black, 64, and John Morgan, 69, were awarded £1,800 each at Reading County Court for ‘injury to feelings’.

The couple, who booked by email and paid a deposit, were turned away by Christian owner Susanne Wilkinson when they arrived at the Swiss Bed and Breakfast in Cookham, Berkshire in March 2010.

Despite protestations from Black that it was unlawful discrimination, the owner refused to allow the couple to stay as it was ‘against her convictions.’

However, the judge found that Black and Morgan suffered direct discrimination and also made clear that, even if she had not found direct discrimination, she would have found that the owner’s professed policy of only giving double rooms to married couples was indirectly discriminatory.

The judge dismissed the owner’s argument that she had not acted in a discriminatory way because she objected to homosexual sexual behaviour rather than homosexual sexual orientation.

It was also found that, although the refusal of a room could be seen as a manifestation of the owner’s religious beliefs, her right to manifest these beliefs was not unfairly limited by the Equality Act – which requires that service providers do not discriminate on grounds of sexual orientation.

‘Naturally, my husband and I are disappointed to have lost the case and to have been ordered to pay £3,600 in damages for injury to feeling,’ said Wilkinson in response to the ruling.

‘We believe a person should be free to act upon their sincere beliefs about marriage under their own roof without living in fear of the law. Equality laws have gone too far when they start to intrude into a family home.’

Lawyers from human rights organization Liberty took up the case.

James Welch, legal director of Liberty, said: ‘Liberty defends the rights of religious groups to manifest their beliefs, even when we disagree with them. But it is simply unacceptable for people running a business to refuse to provide a service because of someone’s sexual orientation.

‘Hopefully today’s ruling signals the death knell of such ‘no gays’ policies – policies that would never be tolerated if they referred to a person’s race, gender or religion.’

UK-based gay rights group, Stonewall, applauded the ruling.

The charity’s chief executive Ben Summerskill said: ‘This judgement vindicates Stonewall’s hard work to make sure businesses can’t turn people away simply because they happen to be gay.

‘It’s a shame tens of thousands of pounds have been wasted reiterating this well-established principle, when any good Christian would surely prefer to have seen that money spent on relieving poverty or tackling hunger.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Gay twins turn their devotion to Dolly Parton into film

'Hollywood to Dollywood' chronicles Gary and Larry Lane's cross-country adventure
No thumbnail available

Gay teen torture mastermind arrested in Cuba

Russian neo-Nazi leader Maxim Martsinkevich, who posts videos on Youtube of him torturing gay men, has been reportedly arrested in Cuba after fleeing Russia
No thumbnail available

IBM to Louisiana’s Jindal: Religious freedom bill ‘is antithetical to our company’s values’

The tech giant, which is currently expanding in Monroe, has spoken out against proposed legislation that would allow business to refuse to provide services for same-sex weddings
No thumbnail available

We can work it out

How the Stonewall Workplace Equality Index decides which are the best employers for lesbian, gay and bisexual staff in Britain
No thumbnail available

Bhutan lawmaker says law criminalizing gays may go

Bhutan MP Sangay Khandu says the country will have to revisit its laws criminalizing gay sex as attitudes change towards LGBTs
No thumbnail available

Four arrested for being gay in Cameroon

Gay prisoners in Cameroon send New Year message of hope.
143 days to go: Selfridges opens Christmas department

143 days to go: Selfridges opens Christmas department

It's never too early to deck the halls with boughs of holly
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Queen's jubilee celebrated with gay Beaton exhibition

V&A Museum in London celebrates Queen Elizabeth's diamond jubilee with a retrospective of royal portraits by gay photographer Cecil Beaton
No thumbnail available

Naomi Campbell: 'I owe my life to gay men'

British supermodel joins the cast of Fox's new hip hop drama Empire