Gay couples banned from suing churches for not marrying them

Equalities Minister Maria Miller has said there will be primary legislation preventing gays from using European law to sue

Gay couples banned from suing churches for not marrying them
12 November 2012

British gay couples will be barred from using European human rights laws to demand a church marry them.

According to Maria Miller, the equalities minister and culture secretary, the new safeguards will prevent couples from suing churches by saying they must abide by the European Convention on Human Rights.

As reported by The Sunday Times, Miller said: ‘To make sure there is no element of doubt, we would be legislating to protect the rights of religious institutions to continue to have freedom on this matter.

‘We would achieve that through some very clear and absolute locks on that freedom within primary legislation.’

It is currently believed the same-sex marriage legislation in the England and Wales government would not allow any gay couples to marry in a religious building, even if the church was happy to host the wedding.

Despite Miller’s pledge, anti-gay group Coalition for Marriage warned the legal ‘lock’ would still be overturned.

‘The government’s solution of primary legislation, a lock, as the minister describes it, is a cheque that will bounce,’ it said.

‘No minister can make this pledge because of European legislation and the European courts, unless the minister is planning to come out of the [convention].’

In contrast, Scotland’s government which held its own marriage equality consultation has described this argument as ‘scare-mongering’. Under the Scottish consultation, churches will be able to ‘opt-out’ of performing ceremonies for gay couples.

The England and Wales same-sex marriage legislation is set to become law in 2015.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Activists take Botswana ban on LGBTI people donating blood to court

Botswana’s National Blood Transfusion Services is refusing to accept blood donations from gay, lesbian or transgender people in a move that activists say violates non-discrimination clauses in the country’s constitution
No thumbnail available

Dubai men get three years in prison for ‘gay prostitution’

Emirates men entrapped and jailed for three years for working as male prostitutes, local rights group slam police procedures and laws
Sandra Day O'Connor marries gay couple at US Supreme Court

Sandra Day O'Connor marries gay couple at US Supreme Court

Former justice once voted to uphold Boy Scouts of America's ban on gays
No thumbnail available

Obama speaks out on Supreme Court and DOMA

'It is very important for us to remember that we're a nation where everybody is supposed to be equal before the law'
No thumbnail available

'Hate truck' preacher calls off Sydney rally

Right-ring Christian pundit Peter Madden is now asking supporters to pray for his cause
No thumbnail available

Missiles at Croatia pride and Greece gay bashings blamed on EU failings

Amnesty International has released a 16-page report condemning the European Union for failing to enforce laws that protect sexual orientation and gender identity in member states
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

David Hyde Pierce on coming out: 'I wouldn't presume to tell people that they should, when they should'

Iconic Frasier actor also chatted to GSN about working with his husband on the musical It Shoulda Been You
No thumbnail available