Gay father wins right to see son raised by lesbian couple

Appeal Court judges in UK rule father should not be treated as 'secondary' parent because his son is living with two women

Gay father wins right to see son raised by lesbian couple
15 March 2012 Print This Article

The gay father of a two-year-old boy being raised by lesbian parents in the UK has won the right to have access to his child.

Three Appeal Court judges ruled that the father, identified only as A, should not be treated as a 'secondary' parent because his son was living with two women.

Judges at the court of appeal ruled that three parents are as good as two, saying 'a two-parent lesbian nuclear family' might be 'essentially selfish and may later insufficiently weigh the welfare and developing rights of the child'.

The father had entered a marriage of convenience with the mother, known as B, so as not to rouse suspicion from her homophobic parents.

He later agreed to father a child with the pair, who were both described as 'professional woman of considerable achievement’.

The boy's mother argued that the father of the child had agreed over a meal in a restaurant that the lesbian couple would be the boy's 'primary parents' but had later changed his mind.

But cracks in the arrangement soon started to appear and after the dispute was taken to the Family Court, a judge decided A should only see the child as much as was necessary for him to know who his father is.

But Lord Justice Thorpe, Lady Justice Black and Sir John Chadwick have now ruled that A should gradually be allowed greater contact, including overnight stays, at the discretion of a Family Court judge.

Lady Black said the courts were continuing to struggle with ‘an area of family law in which generalized guidance is impossible’.

HAVE YOUR SAY

OTHER POSTS

No thumbnail available

Why I admit my Speedo shoot was wrong

Khalid, frontman of My Kali, an LGBT magazine in Jordan, discusses the controversy he caused when he posed for a scantily-clad photo in front of a mosque
No thumbnail available

'It can only get worse': Gays despair of Iran's elections

LGBT Iranians comment on today's election but with real power held by a religious and military elite and no candidates interested in easing the persecution they face, they say it can only get worse, not better
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Clare Balding to legally marry civil partner Alice Arnold

The lesbian broadcasters announced they would wed after the landmark victory of the majority of MPs voting for marriage equality
No thumbnail available

Nigeria plots secret trial for 10 men charged with being gay

Two Islamic courts were forced to suspend the trials after an angry mob pelted the suspects with stones and called for their deaths
No thumbnail available

Elton John, David Furnish welcome second baby Elijah

Gay pop legend, 65, feels his family is 'completed' with the birth of his second son
No thumbnail available

Canada finance minister investigated for trans snub

Michael Miltenberger accused of transphobia by student Gabrielle Landrie after Governor General’s college visit
No thumbnail available

Rosie O'Donnell glad 'robotic pundit' Elisabeth Hasselbeck won't be on The View this time

'I’ve come to expect nothing from her, even though I feel I continually make the effort to break through'
No thumbnail available

Mission America’s Linda Harvey says homeless LGBTI teens only have themselves to blame

Far-right Christian author Linda Harvey has blamed gay teens for running away from ‘heart-broken’ homophobic parents who want to control their lives – saying they only have themselves to blame for their homelessness
No thumbnail available

Petition to improve police complaints procedure in New South Wales

Following several police brutality complaints after Sydney Mardi Gras, LGBT rights groups petition state parliament for a debate on improving procedure