Gay marriage ban is not sex discrimination, Australian judge rules

Federal court judge Jayne Jagot rules same-sex marriage ban is lawful as both sexes are treated equally

Gay marriage ban is not sex discrimination, Australian judge rules
22 February 2013 Print This Article

A judge ruled yesterday that the ban on same-sex marriage in Australia does not constitute sex discrimination.

Gay rights activist Simon Margan brought a legal challenge against the Australian government and the states of Queensland and New South Wales for not allowing same-sex marriage. 

Margan said he lodged the complaint on behalf of ‘a number of homosexual and bisexual men and women and transgender and intersex persons’ who experienced ‘unlawful discrimination based on sex and marital status by reason of the inability of those persons to register same sex marriages’.

Justice Jayne Jagot ruled yesterday that the ban on same-sex marriage cannot be seen as sex discrimination because ‘the treatment of the person of the opposite sex is the same’.

‘Hence, a man cannot enter into the state of marriage as defined with another man just as a woman cannot enter into the state of marriage with another woman as defined,’ said Jagot in her ruling.

Australian Marriage Equality (AME) said that the Federal Court’s ruling shows that politicians should take action on same-sex marriage.

‘If our courts feel powerless to remove discrimination the majority of Australians oppose then it’s up to politicians to act,’ said AME national director Rodney Croome.

‘This issue has become a test of the capacity of Australia’s democratic institutions to respond to popular and over due reform.’

Same-sex marriage bills were defeated in the Australian Senate and House of Representatives last year. 

HAVE YOUR SAY

OTHER POSTS

No thumbnail available

Ball boy 'kicked' by Chelsea footballer faces gay Twitter abuse

Welsh teen Charlie Morgan is being blamed for Chelsea losing after Eden Hazard was sent off and given a three match ban
No thumbnail available

Two gay parties face off in Florida

A Florida HIV group that benefits from White Party Miami sales is disappointed Gay Days Fort Lauderdale has been scheduled for the same Thanksgiving weekend
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Ellen chats to the straight guy who invited his gay best friend to prom

One of the best feel good stories gets even better after both receive $10,000 each
No thumbnail available

Gay couple risk mob violence by holding public wedding in Myanmar

In a country that punishes gay sex with a life sentence in prison, several are hailing the bravery it took to hold Myanmar's first public gay wedding
No thumbnail available

Cameroon to celebrate national anti-gay day

Cameroon association to mark the 21 August as a national anti-gay, promising a homophobic parade through the streets of the capital
No thumbnail available

LGBTI Londoners protest closure of iconic gay venue

The Black Cap in Camden was closed without warning last week, and is significant for its drag and queer history
Alan Turing family joins tech company Fujitsu at Pride in London

Alan Turing family joins tech company Fujitsu at Pride in London

In keeping with this year’s theme, technology giant Fujitsu is honoring Turing as its Pride hero
No thumbnail available

UK bouncer says 'gays should be fed to dogs'

Doorman unleashes a homophobic rant at a student who isn't even gay
No thumbnail available

Parisians celebrate being gay and Muslim at end of Ramadan

A group of LGBT Muslims celebrated Eid Al-Fitr, the end of Ramadan, with pride and joy on the banks of the River Seine, Paris