Gay marriage ban is not sex discrimination, Australian judge rules

Federal court judge Jayne Jagot rules same-sex marriage ban is lawful as both sexes are treated equally

Gay marriage ban is not sex discrimination, Australian judge rules
22 February 2013

A judge ruled yesterday that the ban on same-sex marriage in Australia does not constitute sex discrimination.

Gay rights activist Simon Margan brought a legal challenge against the Australian government and the states of Queensland and New South Wales for not allowing same-sex marriage. 

Margan said he lodged the complaint on behalf of ‘a number of homosexual and bisexual men and women and transgender and intersex persons’ who experienced ‘unlawful discrimination based on sex and marital status by reason of the inability of those persons to register same sex marriages’.

Justice Jayne Jagot ruled yesterday that the ban on same-sex marriage cannot be seen as sex discrimination because ‘the treatment of the person of the opposite sex is the same’.

‘Hence, a man cannot enter into the state of marriage as defined with another man just as a woman cannot enter into the state of marriage with another woman as defined,’ said Jagot in her ruling.

Australian Marriage Equality (AME) said that the Federal Court’s ruling shows that politicians should take action on same-sex marriage.

‘If our courts feel powerless to remove discrimination the majority of Australians oppose then it’s up to politicians to act,’ said AME national director Rodney Croome.

‘This issue has become a test of the capacity of Australia’s democratic institutions to respond to popular and over due reform.’

Same-sex marriage bills were defeated in the Australian Senate and House of Representatives last year. 

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Alaska gay couple's car defaced with homophobic, Nazi and religious signs

'Fag free zone,' 'White power,' 'Fags die, God laughs'
No thumbnail available

Australian HIV+ gay men wanted for online program

Positive Outlook offers online support for HIV positive gay men in Australia, pilot trial seeks participants
No thumbnail available

Israel’s Education Minister says gay people shouldn’t try to call themselves couples or families

Minister of Education Shai Piron says it’s the right of a Jewish state to tell same-sex couples that they are not a family, though he supports them having some basic rights
No thumbnail available

Arizona State Senator Steve Gallardo: 'I'm gay ... and it's OK'

Democratic lawmaker inspired to come out publicly following controversy surrounding vetoed anti-gay bill
No thumbnail available

Drugs, clubs and death: what can South London’s gay community do?

A group of community leaders meet in South London’s clubbing district Vauxhall to discuss the drug GHB, and its relationship to clubbing and the gay community
Supermodel Linda Evangelista speaks up for marriage equality

Supermodel Linda Evangelista speaks up for marriage equality

She thanks gay culture for making her career
No thumbnail available

Republican blames 'new fascism' as the reason why the Mozilla CEO stepped down

'This is just the most open and blatant example of the new fascism...'
No thumbnail available

Elton John hospitalized in Los Angeles

Singer battling serious respiratory infection, cancels shows
No thumbnail available

Now a contender to be US Defense Secretary, former senator apologizes for anti-gay remarks

Chuck Hagel says he is fully 'committed to LGBT military families'
No thumbnail available

Musical with negative portrayal of LGBT people tours Malaysia

'We want to awaken the youths and parents to the issue,' says the director of musical with negative message about LGBT lifestyles