Gay marriage opponents appeal Prop. 8 case to US Supreme Court

Court to decide after its summer recess whether to hear landmark case

Gay marriage opponents appeal Prop. 8 case to US Supreme Court
31 July 2012

Gay marriage opponents on Tuesday (31 July) asked the US Supreme Court to overturn a federal appellate court decision that struck down California’s Proposition 8 which stripped same-sex couples of the right to marry.

Proposition 8 sponsors Protect Marriage described the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruling in February that California’s ban on gay marriage unconstitutional as ‘misguided.’

In their petition to the high court, the group states: ‘Our Constitution does not mandate the traditional definition of marriage, but neither does our Constitution condemn it. Rather, it leaves the definition of marriage in the hands of the people, to be resolved through the democratic process in each state.’

The lawsuit challenging Prop. 8 was filed on behalf of two California couples who want to marry: Kris Perry and Sandy Stier and Paul Katami and Jeff Zarrillo.

The American Foundation for Equal Rights (AFER) is the group which brought forth the lawsuit that led to the court case and lead co-counsel David Boies said in a statement that the freedom to marry is ‘one of the most fundamental rights’ of all Americans.

‘As we have said from the very beginning of this case, the denial of that fundamental right seriously harms gay and lesbian Americans and the children they are raising,’ Boies said. ‘ Today’s petition presents the justices with the chance to affirm our Constitution’s central promises of liberty, equality, and human dignity.’

Rick Jacobs, founder of the Courage Campaign, blasted Proposition 8 proponents for carrying on the legal battle.

‘As the late Ronald Reagan would say, ‘Well, there they go again.’  The President of the United States, a majority of the American public, two federal courts and most of America’s NATO allies view marriage equality as a fact,’ Jacob said.

He said the conservative argument ‘that America will cease to function if gays and lesbians can marry’ has already proven to be untrue.

‘The major problem with this thesis is that seven states and the District of Columbia welcome marriage for all and the country functions just fine, the sun still shines and the world still rotates on its axis,’ Jacobs said. ‘We can only hope that the Supreme Court will once again act for all Americans on the right side of history, not for a few hysterical ones scared of love.’

The Supreme Court is expected to decide whether or not to hear the case when it returns from vacation. 

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

First steps towards more LGBT-friendly offices in China

A meeting in Shanghai highlights inequalities and obstacles to LGBT people feeling comfortable enough to come out at work in China
No thumbnail available

AFA’s Bryan Fischer urges people to call gay marriage ‘sodomy based marriage’

The American Family Association’s Bryan Fischer has encouraged opponents of same-sex marriage to embrace the term sodomy in their campaigns – saying it is an ugly word for ugly things
No thumbnail available

Nations squabble over UN vote on gay and trans killings

The United Nations is set to vote whether LGBT people should get specific protection from extrajudicial executions and other murders
No thumbnail available

Carol Ann Duffy wins Pen Pinter prize

Britain’s lesbian poet laureate wins prize in memory of Harold Pinter
No thumbnail available

Scotland unveils draft gay marriage bill

Scotland makes history by becoming the first part of the United Kingdom to publish legislation to allow same-sex marriage
No thumbnail available

Isn’t this some of the cutest children's wear you’ve ever seen?

Launched by a pair of gay moms, clothing label Little Figs offers kid's wear that celebrates alternative families
No thumbnail available

Lucy Spraggan threatens to quit X Factor

Lesbian UK X Factor finalist Lucy Spraggan allegedly sick of being forced to sing cover songs
No thumbnail available

Mitt Romney's former foreign policy spokesman says he wasn't forced out because he is gay

Richard Grenell says he quit after just a few weeks on the job because publicity surrounding his sexuality was obscuring message
No thumbnail available

Australian Defence Force disciplines failed politician for comments about Islam and the Sydney Mardi Gras parade

Bernard Gaynor, who was deselected as a candidate for senate by Katter's Australian Party, disciplined by the Australian army for anti-Islamic and anti-LGBT comments
No thumbnail available

Arizona State Senator who supports anti-gay bill is stumped when asked to justify it on US television

Al Melvin can't think of a single example of when SB 1062 has been needed