Hong Kong Equal Opportunities boss says civil unions possible

Hong Kong Equal Opportunities Commission chair York Chow says civil unions for gay and lesbian couples could be a ‘feasible' alternative for same-sex marriage

Hong Kong Equal Opportunities boss says civil unions possible
23 October 2013

The head of Hong Kong’s leading human rights body has sad that Hong Kong should consider civil unions for same-sex couples as an achievable alternative to letting them marry because of conservative views in the Chinese territory.

Equal Opportunities Commission chair Dr York Chow Yat-ngok told the South China Morning Post that while governments elsewhere consider the issue of equal treatment under the law to be a ‘matter of human rights,’ conservative views in Hong Kong will make it difficult to have full equality in marriage.

‘To use “marriage” for same-sex couples would be rather difficult to accept for Hongkongers, especially the conservative ones,’ Chow told the newspaper.

‘Overseas governments first thought of dropping the term “marriage” and replacing it with “civil union.” Legally, though, the protection is identical. I think this is feasible.

‘I, and the commission, are of the view that the LGBT community should be provided with the same opportunities [as heterosexuals] wherever possible.’

Chow hopes an upcoming amendment to allow post-operative transgender people to be legally recognized as their preferred gender will spark debate around the issue.

The amendment came about when a transgender woman who was seeking to marry a man took the issue to the Hong Kong High Court which gave the Security Bureau a year to decide whether the law needed to be amended to reflect its ruling that the legal definition of woman should include a post-operative male-to-female transsexual.

‘If a person gets married and then changes his or her gender, this becomes a same-sex marriage,’ Chow said.

‘Whether this should be legally enforceable remains contentious. And an ensuing question is should same-sex marriage be allowed as well?’

The Catholic Diocese of Hong Kong says it will oppose civil unions, with a spokesman saying that ‘to compare homosexuals’ rights with heterosexuals’ rights is like comparing apple and orange.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Now Israel is embracing LGBTI rights, whether you are religious or not

Israeli gay and trans rights activist Avi Soffer argues the new government has seen a big shift on promoting LGBTI equality in the country
No thumbnail available

Feminist group’s HQ in France goes up in flames, linked with gay hate

Topless band of female protestors' Paris offices are hit by fire, and they think it could be something to do with the stamp controversy
No thumbnail available

GSN and G-A-Y call for marriage petition support

Gay Star News and top London nightclub G-A-Y hosting special free night to boost signatures for same-sex marriage equality in Britain
No thumbnail available

Slovenia legalizes gay marriage

First central European country to recognize same-sex marriage
No thumbnail available

Actor fired for throwing out heckler who was shouting ‘faggot’

An audience member, who was allegedly drunk, was shouting anti-gay slurs during emotionally tense scenes of Cat On A Hot Tin Roof
No thumbnail available

From a lesbian kiss to a 95-year-old: Eurovision semi-finals return

Vampires, the Salvation Army and a lesbian kiss... it's the Eurovision semi-finals part two!
No thumbnail available

Serbia is Mecca for trans surgery

Trans around the world join Chaz Bono in choosing Eastern European country for gender reassignment surgery
No thumbnail available

From lesbian queens to stories of love: Lords gay marriage debate

Britain’s House of Lords debate same-sex marriage equality with lesbian and gay peers taking a leading part in the debate
No thumbnail available

Calls to help Molly's amnesia

As Molly Meldrum's condition improves, medical teams treating his post-traumatic amnesia ask for help
No thumbnail available

Carole Cameron: ‘Even if someone is uncomfortable with gay people, you can win them over with your work’

A senior manager with aerospace and defense company, Lockheed Martin, Cameron reflects on the advantages of being out at work from the day you join a company