Hong Kong trans woman back in court to win right to marry boyfriend

W is in the Court of Final Appeal for legal ruling on her right to marry her boyfriend as a woman

Hong Kong trans woman back in court to win right to marry boyfriend
18 April 2013

A transgender woman is back in court in Hong Kong this week to appeal a 2010 decision not to allow her to marry her boyfriend, despite being described as female on her identity card.

The woman, who is referred to as Ms W in court, had government-subsidized gender realignment surgery and has been allowed to alter her identity card.

Hong Kong’s Registrar of Marriages told W that she could not marry her boyfriend because her birth certificate says she is male.

The case is now being heard in the Court of Final Appeal.

‘We say the laws of marriage can and should recognize that sexual identity can change,’ W’s lawyer David Pannick told the court in his opening arguments, The Jakarta Globe reports.

‘The right to marry is fundamental… the birth certificate is a record of historical facts. [W is now] medically, psychologically and socially [female]’.

Same-sex marriage is far from being legally or socially accepted in Hong Kong. LGBT rights activists said last week that marriage was not a priority for them as criminalizing discrimination is a more pressing matter.

‘We are not planning to fight for same-sex marriage legislation at this point of time,’ said Women’s Coalition of Hong Kong chair Connie Chan Man-wai who was part of a meeting on LGBT rights with new Equal Opportunities Commission chair York Chow Yat-ngok, The Standard reports.

‘We hope to focus on legislation on discrimination against homosexuals as the first step, as many homosexuals are being discriminated against at school and work,’ added Chan.

Chow said the commission would launch a public consultation into discrimination against LGBT people within three years, the activists who met him reported.  

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

UK lawyer urges Jamaica to keep buggery laws

Paul Diamond believes Jamaica should resist pressure from the US or UK to remove buggery laws  
No thumbnail available

UKIP's McKenzie says gay adoption is like throwing kids to 'dogs'

UK Independence Party would-be MP loses election but still rants over gay adoption saying it is like the fall of the Roman Empire
No thumbnail available

Effort launched to crack down on camps where 'troubled' LGBTI kids are sent by parents

Says one survivor: 'They blanketed their abusive practices under the guise of Christianity'
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

California anti-trans referendum may not qualify for ballot

Only 76.76% of signatures on initiative against trans student rights are valid 
Angela Merkel's Christian Democrats reject gay marriage in first faction poll

Angela Merkel's Christian Democrats reject gay marriage in first faction poll

First in a planned series, the poll amongst members of the Berlin faction reveals 3% consider marriage equality 'not important'
No thumbnail available

Cameroon lawyer honored for work on gay rights

Alice Nkom: ‘Every time a homosexual is negatively affected, it’s a negative effect on all of humanity.’
No thumbnail available

Bible thumpers should read the whole good book

Extremist Christians in the US are using the Bible to argue against gay marriage and get Mitt Romney elected – but the good book has plenty which would make life difficult for straight people too
No thumbnail available

WIN: a trip for two to Vienna for the Eurovision Song Contest with the Gay Star Travel Expo – details revealed...

To be in with a chance of winning, register your attendance at the Expo (taking place at London's Heaven nightclub on 17 Jan)
No thumbnail available