Indonesian judge apologizes to LGBTs for anti-gay comments

An Indonesian judge has made a public apology to the country’s LGBT community, but maintains his stance against the idea of same-sex marriages

Indonesian judge apologizes to LGBTs for anti-gay comments
14 March 2013

Indonesian Constitutional Court judge Arief Hidayat has apologized to that country’s LGBT community after a gay activist wrote to him to tell him of his struggles as a gay Muslim living in Indonesia.

Hidayat had spoken out against the idea of same-sex marriage during a confirmation hearing in the Indonesian House of Representatives, which prompted LGBT rights activist Hartoyo, the secretary general of the group Ourvoice, to write an open letter to the judge.

Hartoyo told the judge of how he and his partner had been dragged from their home by a mob in 2007 and beaten before being dragged to a police station where they were verbally abused by six officers who then turned a hose on them.

Hartoyo wrote that his sexuality was innate and not something imported from Western cultures.

‘I have never been to any Western countries and I have fallen in love with men even before I understood what Indonesia and Islam were,’ Hartoyo wrote to Hidayat according to the Jakarta Globe.

‘I have been a homosexual even before I knew that homosexuality is considered to be a sin by many religious teachings.

‘If gay marriage is part of Western culture then how would you explain the fact that gay marriage is still disputed in Western countries, such as the United States, even today? Will those who are against gay marriage in those countries then argue that homosexuality is an Eastern, Southern or Northern reality?

‘History in fact proves that when western countries criminalized homosexuality, it was us who actually celebrated sexual diversity in our culture.’

Hidayat responded to Hartoyo’s letter after it was brought to his attention by David Mills, an openly gay Massachusetts judge, who urged him to respond to him.

Hidayat maintained that he believed that same-sex marriage would be unconstitutional and was offensive to religious sensibilities in Indonesia but apologized if he had caused any offense and stressed that LGBT people should be protected from violence.

‘I apologize if my opinion offended the gay community. I will ask for God’s forgiveness,’ Hidayat wrote in an email to Hartoyo.

‘As a citizen of the country, you and your community should be protected from violent acts.’



No thumbnail available

Retired Aussie judge calls on high-profile gays to come out

Former Australian High Court judge Michael Kirby urges other high-profile gay Australians to help fight discrimination
No thumbnail available

Australian short film about gay first love gets 20,000 views on YouTube

17-year-old's film about first love striking during a French exam is heart-felt and poignant
No thumbnail available

CNN poll shows positive shift in attitudes towards gays

Sixty percent of respondents say they have a close friend or family member who is gay
No thumbnail available

Tatchell says Leveson Report will help protect gay private lives

Gay campaigner Peter Tatchell says tougher rules are needed on British press to stop LGBT hate and give right to reply for false allegations
No thumbnail available

Germany’s top court rules gay couples are banned from joint adoption

Despite the Constitutional Court ruling last year that gay couples could adopt together on a technicality, they have thrown out a referral asking them to rule on joint same-sex adoptions
No thumbnail available

Californian man suspected of killing gay partner in domestic dispute

Police found a dead man inside a bedroom while the suspect was sitting on the doorstep of their house
Launching your own business? Read our essential advice for budding entrepreneurs

Launching your own business? Read our essential advice for budding entrepreneurs

The majority of businesses will fail within two years. Do your research and learn lessons from those who have already taken the plunge
No thumbnail available

Attorney General: ‘Nothing justifies excluding gay couples from their human rights’

‘Marriage bans inflict concrete harms’ head of Department of Justice says
No thumbnail available

Greece gay civil union delay draws protests

Bill that criminalizes inciting homophobic violence is approved
No thumbnail available

Judge rules Oaxaca, Mexico ban on same-sex marriage is unconstitutional

A judge has declared the ban on same-sex marriage in the Mexican state of Oaxaca to be invalid – paving the way for same-sex couples to marry in the state