Lawyer tells Malaysian minister her reading of constitution is ‘narrow’

Syahredzan Johan contradicts deputy minister Dr Mashitah Ibrahim's reading of Article 8 of the Malaysian constitution

Lawyer tells Malaysian minister her reading of constitution is ‘narrow’
21 June 2012

Malaysian lawyer Syahredzan Johan has said a deputy minister’s reading of the country’s constitution is ‘narrow’.

Dr Mashitah Ibrahim, deputy minister in the prime minister’s department said in the senate earlier this week that Malaysia’s constitution does protect citizens against discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity.

Syahredzan Johan said: ‘Article 8(1) is clear – it mentions all persons are equal before the law and should have equal protection of the law, regardless of his race, religion, creed, gender or sexual orientation. So the word "gender" in Article 8(2) should be read to also mean ‘sexual preference or sexuality.’

The constitution of Malaysia was ratified in 1957 after independence from Britain. Article 8 is concerned with equality.

Scientist Hwa Shi-Hsia added to the debate: ‘When you look at a document like the constitution which was written at a point in historical time but is used to guide our lives today, you have to look at its spirit as well as the letter.

‘The key point is not to nitpick over the exact definition of gender. The key point is: No discrimination allowed.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Facebook hate page: ‘Nazis were right’ about gays

Heterosexual Awareness Month page says gay men’s mouths smell of ‘poo poo’ and implies NBA player Jason Collins will give people who tackle him a sex infection
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Charlie Hunnam: Gay sex scenes on Queer As Folk helping me on 50 Shades of Grey

Queer As Folk star Charlie Hunnam is confident he’ll have no problem with the explicit script for the big-screen adaption of the steamy worldwide bestseller
No thumbnail available

Canada will allow Ugandan LGBTI activists to visit for WorldPride after all

A group of Ugandan LGBTI rights activists will be allowed to attend the WorldPride 2014 human rights conference after their applications were initially refused by immigration officials who feared they would seek asylum
No thumbnail available

6 fierce and fabulous things to do at the W Hong Kong

Whoever you are, whomever you love, you will forever be fabulous in W Hong Kong’s eyes!
No thumbnail available

Man dies after ‘abuse’ outside London ‘gay’ club, license suspended

Victim's father believes his son died on the streets of Vauxhall after being manhandled by security staff
No thumbnail available

Indiana state government still appealing recognition of dying lesbian’s marriage

Indiana’s Attorney General is continuing to appeal the legal recognition of a lesbian couple’s marriage that a judge ordered so a dying woman can have her wife recorded on her death certificate
No thumbnail available

HRC head 'laughed' that Modern Family was a favorite show of Romneys

Chad Griffin: 'I initially wondered if they were serious'
No thumbnail available

Priest who denied lesbian communion at mother's funeral leaves church

Christian lesbian in US takes 'great comfort' in hearing vicar who refused her holy sacrament has left archdiocese
No thumbnail available

Santorum rally interrupted by two kissing men

Rick Santorum rally interrupted by two men kissing