Lawyers clash in court challenge of Singapore’s anti-gay sex law

Human rights lawyer says Singapore's Section 377A which criminalizes gay sex is 'inherently absurd, arbitrary, vague and discriminatory'

Lawyers clash in court challenge of Singapore’s anti-gay sex law
07 March 2013

A case challenging constitutionality of anti-gay sex law was heard in the High Court in Singapore yesterday morning.

Human rights lawyer M Ravi went head-to-head with Aedit Abdullah, a lawyer from Singapore’s Attorney-General’s Chambers, the government’s legal advisors.

The case, Tan Eng Hong v. Attorney-General, began in 2010 when Tan was charged for having sex with a man in a public toilet under Section 377A, the law which criminalizes sex between men.

After several court cases, the constitutional validity of the law is being challenged.

Ravi argued in court yesterday that Section 377A violates article 12 of Singapore’s constitution which states ‘all persons are equal before the law’. Ravi said the anti-gay-sex law is ‘inherently absurd, arbitrary, vague and discriminatory’.

Aedit defended the law, arguing that the Singapore public views gay sex as immoral, citing this study which shows that the majority of Singaporeans still have negative attitudes towards homosexuals.

In the Attorney-General’s Chambers’ written submission, the government’s legal advisors state Section 377A is necessary for ‘preventing the mainstreaming of gay lifestyles’.

Aedit argued that a parliamentary discussion in 2007, after which Prime Minister Lee Hsien-Loong decided the law should stay in place, had been ‘a conscious and considered protection of public morality’.

Aedit added that the law, which he says is not enforced, is ‘a political compromise meant to appease a variety of parties’, Singapore’s Today Online reports.

Ravi countered that ‘criminalizing a minority group for who they are does not advance public morality in Singapore. It merely perpetuates prejudice, which is quite a different thing’.

The judge, Justice Loh decided to reserve his judgment on the case.

Loh is also presiding on another constitutional challenge to Section 377A from gay couple Gary Lim and Kenneth Chee. He is expected to rule on both cases together.  

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

7 men charged over gay sex and blackmail in Indian city of Bangalore

A gang of seven men who filmed themselves having sex with a doctor and then blackmailed him over it have been charged under India’s reinstated colonial era sodomy law  
No thumbnail available

Sochi accused of going gay with twin toilets in men's cubicles

Can two toilets be accused of gay propaganda? Apparently so, as Russia now has to defend itself from jokes from its 'intimate' bathroom situation at the Olympics
No thumbnail available

HomoLAB 49

This week we interview Turner Prize winning artist Grayson Perry about class and being the wrong sort of tranny.
No thumbnail available

Sex scenes are no problem, US go-go dancer turned actor tells GSN

One of the stars of film Getting Go, Matthew Camp plays a go-go dancer and tells us why sex scenes are a breeze for him
No thumbnail available

Gay congressman Barney Frank uses last day in office to protest defense secretary candidate

Says Chuck Hagel 'voted consistently against fairness for LGBT people'
No thumbnail available

Gay travel firm Mantrav goes bust after Gran Canaria hotel troubles

British gay travel firm to file for insolvency. Trouble hit when a resort they were selling in Gran Canaria failed to open, leaving customers wanting refunds
No thumbnail available

Poll: Repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell has little impact on US Military

Sixty-nine percent say policy change has had no repercussions
No thumbnail available

Actor who played gay role on US soap has chance to make Daytime Emmy history

Chandler Massey going for third win in a row for his portrayal of Will Horton on NBC's Days of Our Lives - earns fourth nod overall
No thumbnail available

Drunk Canadian woman jailed for threatening gay Mountie with violence

A woman who called an openly gay Royal Canadian Mounted Police officer a ‘faggot’ over 60 times has been jailed for 60 days after she threatened to beat him up
No thumbnail available

LGBTs support UK plans to tackle emotional domestic abuse

One in four people in same-sex relationships suffer from domestic violence or abuse in the UK