Lawyers clash in court challenge of Singapore’s anti-gay sex law

Human rights lawyer says Singapore's Section 377A which criminalizes gay sex is 'inherently absurd, arbitrary, vague and discriminatory'

Lawyers clash in court challenge of Singapore’s anti-gay sex law
07 March 2013

A case challenging constitutionality of anti-gay sex law was heard in the High Court in Singapore yesterday morning.

Human rights lawyer M Ravi went head-to-head with Aedit Abdullah, a lawyer from Singapore’s Attorney-General’s Chambers, the government’s legal advisors.

The case, Tan Eng Hong v. Attorney-General, began in 2010 when Tan was charged for having sex with a man in a public toilet under Section 377A, the law which criminalizes sex between men.

After several court cases, the constitutional validity of the law is being challenged.

Ravi argued in court yesterday that Section 377A violates article 12 of Singapore’s constitution which states ‘all persons are equal before the law’. Ravi said the anti-gay-sex law is ‘inherently absurd, arbitrary, vague and discriminatory’.

Aedit defended the law, arguing that the Singapore public views gay sex as immoral, citing this study which shows that the majority of Singaporeans still have negative attitudes towards homosexuals.

In the Attorney-General’s Chambers’ written submission, the government’s legal advisors state Section 377A is necessary for ‘preventing the mainstreaming of gay lifestyles’.

Aedit argued that a parliamentary discussion in 2007, after which Prime Minister Lee Hsien-Loong decided the law should stay in place, had been ‘a conscious and considered protection of public morality’.

Aedit added that the law, which he says is not enforced, is ‘a political compromise meant to appease a variety of parties’, Singapore’s Today Online reports.

Ravi countered that ‘criminalizing a minority group for who they are does not advance public morality in Singapore. It merely perpetuates prejudice, which is quite a different thing’.

The judge, Justice Loh decided to reserve his judgment on the case.

Loh is also presiding on another constitutional challenge to Section 377A from gay couple Gary Lim and Kenneth Chee. He is expected to rule on both cases together.  

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Lesbian newsreader calls anti-gay marriage MPs 'hurtful'

Alice Arnold, former BBC broadcaster and civil partner of Clare Balding, wants to be public face of equal marriage
No thumbnail available

Trans woman gored by stag in freak accident

A Cambridge academic is fighting for her life and may never walk again after a 'one-in-a-million' attack
No thumbnail available

Gay man attacked in Atlanta, Georgia then pushed into oncoming traffic

A man leaped out of a car and called a gay couple ‘faggots’ for holding hands in the streets before punching one of the men and pushing him in front of oncoming cars but months later police are yet to find the suspect
No thumbnail available

Oklahoma judge bars trans people from changing names

Citing the Bible, Judge Bill Graves says transgender men and women are changing their names for 'fraudulent purposes'
No thumbnail available

Mark Armario: 'I do not want to be defined by sexuality, but rather capability'

A director in the banking industry, Armario says he has got used to the fact that he will have to come out again and again; a process he has dubbed 'Groundhog Gay'
No thumbnail available

Bangladesh refuses to decriminalize homosexuality

Rights activists say discriminatory act gives police a handle to illegally arrest, attack and abuse LGBTI people
No thumbnail available

US band Train order NZ anti-gay marriage website to remove song

Grammy-award-winning band Train say they will tell New Zealand ‘Protect Marriage’ website to remove their song from the home page
No thumbnail available

Military goes ‘Gangnam Style’ thanks to infectious Korean pop vid

PSY’s infectious Korean pop video, spoofing horse-riding and the fashionable Gangnam district of Seoul inspires US military tribute acts
No thumbnail available

Former senator Larry Craig being sued by Federal Election Commission

Former senator Larry Craig faces a suit over alleged misuse of campaign funds
Dear White People reminds us all that there is nothing simple about identity and authenticity

Dear White People reminds us all that there is nothing simple about identity and authenticity

Justin Simien delivers a sharp and fearless debut with his take on race relations today's world.