Lesbian court battle could redefine law on sperm, egg donors

Feuding lesbians in Florida spark global debate on motherhood

Lesbian court battle could redefine law on sperm, egg donors
05 March 2012

A lesbian who took the biological daughter of her partner to Australia has sparked a global debate on the question of motherhood and egg donors.

The American women, known only in the court papers as their initials, are both in their 30s and were police officers in Florida.

One partner donated an egg that was fertilized and implanted in the other, who gave birth in 2004, nine years into their relationship.

The couple separated two years later, and the birth mother eventually left without a trace taking the child with her.

The woman who donated the egg, and calls herself the biological mother, used a detective to track her former partner down. The detective found her ex-girlfriend, the birth mother, and the now eight-year-old girl living in Australia.

The egg donor has now launched a ground-breaking custody battle in the Florida Supreme Court, creating problems whether the constitutional right to procreate includes outside-the-body technologies used to conceive.

Also at debate is the constitutional question about gay people’s right to raise children and claim equal protection under law.

A trial judge ruled in favor of the birth mother, and said the biological mother has no parental rights under state law which states egg donors ‘relinquish all maternal or paternal rights’.

The 5th District Court of Appeal in Daytona Beach sided with the biological mother, saying both have parental rights.

The birth mother cites the state's law on sperm and egg donation to argue the biological mother wasn't the child's parent.

In response, the lawyers of the biological mother state she was not a donor as she also raised the child.

In the Court of Appeal, the judges said: ‘Their separation does not dissolve the parental rights of either woman, nor does it dissolve the love and affection either has for the child.'

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Mayor apologises for banning gay signs from family fun day

Australian mayor apologises to LGBT group Twenty10 after they were made to leave Rediscover the River event
This 80s pop star is writing LGBTI-friendly songs for schools

This 80s pop star is writing LGBTI-friendly songs for schools

ViX Fuzzbox, lead singer of an all-girl 80s chart band has been writing songs for primary school kids to celebrate diversity
No thumbnail available

JK Rowling chides Twitter follower angry over Dumbledore's sexuality

It's never smart to show bigotry toward headmaster Albus Dumbledore's sexuality, especially to the writer who loves him most  
No thumbnail available

Australian state Youth Parliament backs marriage equality

The Youth Parliament of the Australian state of New South Wales has voted overwhelmingly to support the rights of same-sex couples
Colorado Republican says gays and pedophiles caused by different kinds of demons

Colorado Republican says gays and pedophiles caused by different kinds of demons

Gordon Klingenschmitt says he would never say that all gay people are child molesters because he believes the two phenomena are the work of separate kinds of demonic entities
No thumbnail available

Teen girls 'convert to Islam', say ‘Justin Bieber is gay’ in Arabic, for free tickets

A Norwegian comedy show tricked five young fans of the Canadian heartthrob to win free tickets for his concert in Oslo
No thumbnail available

Colombia minister determined to make gay marriage legal

While the majority of Colombians are opposed to same-sex marriage, the government say they are committed to equality
No thumbnail available

Michigan woman sues Planet Fitness over trans-friendly locker room policy

Claims policy 'enables sexual harassment and endangers women and kids'
No thumbnail available

Mozilla appoints new CEO after the last one was less than gay friendly

Second time lucky for Mozilla after Brendan Eich was found to have donated to anti-gay marriage campaigns