Lesbian court battle could redefine law on sperm, egg donors

Feuding lesbians in Florida spark global debate on motherhood

Lesbian court battle could redefine law on sperm, egg donors
05 March 2012

A lesbian who took the biological daughter of her partner to Australia has sparked a global debate on the question of motherhood and egg donors.

The American women, known only in the court papers as their initials, are both in their 30s and were police officers in Florida.

One partner donated an egg that was fertilized and implanted in the other, who gave birth in 2004, nine years into their relationship.

The couple separated two years later, and the birth mother eventually left without a trace taking the child with her.

The woman who donated the egg, and calls herself the biological mother, used a detective to track her former partner down. The detective found her ex-girlfriend, the birth mother, and the now eight-year-old girl living in Australia.

The egg donor has now launched a ground-breaking custody battle in the Florida Supreme Court, creating problems whether the constitutional right to procreate includes outside-the-body technologies used to conceive.

Also at debate is the constitutional question about gay people’s right to raise children and claim equal protection under law.

A trial judge ruled in favor of the birth mother, and said the biological mother has no parental rights under state law which states egg donors ‘relinquish all maternal or paternal rights’.

The 5th District Court of Appeal in Daytona Beach sided with the biological mother, saying both have parental rights.

The birth mother cites the state's law on sperm and egg donation to argue the biological mother wasn't the child's parent.

In response, the lawyers of the biological mother state she was not a donor as she also raised the child.

In the Court of Appeal, the judges said: ‘Their separation does not dissolve the parental rights of either woman, nor does it dissolve the love and affection either has for the child.'

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Gay beaches, French vineyards and 300 days of sunshine: A gay guesthouse at the heart of the Mediterranean

Cinq & Sept, in the traditional winemaking village of Roujan, is the ideal base to discover the local naturist beaches, oyster beds and traditional southern French cuisine
No thumbnail available

Jane Lynch, author of new children's book about a bully, admits she was one as a kid

'Bullying works on a level. You get to be part of the group. The catch is, you’re never really equal. People are afraid of you'
No thumbnail available

Former High Court judge condemns 'discrimination and hatred' against LGBT people in Australia

LGBT rights advocate speaks at meeting for gay and lesbian business people in Brisbane
No thumbnail available

President of Catholic High School in Minnesota resigns after revealing he is gay

William Hudson: 'I need to be truthful about my life'
No thumbnail available

Will Neil Patrick Harris be People Magazine's first openly gay Sexiest Man Alive?

Multi-talented performer is reported to be among finalists
No thumbnail available

Asian Human Rights Commission slams treatment of LGBTs by Myanmar police

The Asian Human Rights Commission has expressed its concern about Burmese police targeting gay men and transgendered people for harassment in Myanmar
Saudi Arabia school fined $25,000 over 'homosexual' rainbows on building

Saudi Arabia school fined $25,000 over 'homosexual' rainbows on building

Administrator responsible for the 'emblems of homosexuality' is in jail awaiting trial
No thumbnail available

Federal judge says there is no 'sufficient justification' for South Dakota's gay marriage ban - strikes it down

Judge Karen Schreier places stay on her ruling pending expected appeal from state
No thumbnail available

Dominican Catholic Cardinal attacks gay US ambassador over pride month video

Cardinal Nicolas de Jesus Lopez Rodríguez has told ambassador James Brewster to ‘take his gay pride elsewhere,’ after he released a video with his husband for Gay Pride Month
No thumbnail available

'Gay panic' petition gains momentum

The Australian 'gay panic' petition, created by catholic priest Father Paul Kelly, has now reached over 18,100 supporters