Malaysian state implements heavier penalties for Muslims found “cross-dressing”

Under the amended Syariah law, any man or woman in Pahang found “cross-dressing” could face a maximum of one year behind bars or be fined up to RM1,000, or both.

Malaysian state implements heavier penalties for Muslims found “cross-dressing”
04 January 2014

In what is seen as a sign of increasing Islamisation in a country that is officially a secular state with Islam as its official religion, the northern state of Pahang has introduced heavier penalties on "cross-dressers" under an amended Syariah law, according to local news reports.

Malaysia’s state-run news agency Berama reported that those arrested under the new law could face a maximum of a year’s jail or be fined up to RM1,000 (£ 185) or both if convicted. Under civil law, non-Muslim transwomen are usually charged under section 21 of the Minor Offences Act and fined RM 25.

The amended law, which came into effect on Dec 1, 2013, will only apply to Muslim men or women found to be wearing clothes of the opposite gender.

Pahang Islamic Religious and Malay Customs Council (Muip) deputy president Datuk Seri Wan Abdul Wahid Wan Hassan was quoted in the New Straits Times as saying that the lack of stern punishment against mak nyahs (men dressed as women) and pengkid (women dressed as men) had resulted in a rise in immoral activities in the state.

“Previously, when it came to cross-dressing, Muip only detained and advised them to change their behaviour. However, such activities have become rampant, forcing the council to introduce a more severe punishment,” he added.

No reports of arrests had been made by the council since the amended law was introduced.

Other offences include khalwat (close proximity between unmarried opposite-sex couples), consuming alcohol and not fasting during Ramadan.

Women’s Aid Organisation executive director Ivy Josiah questioned the definition and existence of "cross-dressing" law.

"Modern attire is eclectic in nature and many women these days wear trousers and sport short hair. How do we even define what cross-dressing means? Cross-dressing is not about hurting other people or taking property from anyone. It’s a personal choice." She told the Times.

Syariah lawyer Nizam Bashir Abdul Kariem Bashir has also spoken out against the law as being unconstitutional and against the Pahang state department for acting beyond its rights in regulating attire.

The Quran doesn’t specifically address "cross dressing" although it urges its followers to dress modestly.

Nizam explained that there must be a concrete link between cross-dressing attire and immoral activities before one may justify such an action, and that laws should not based on vague probabilities.

He told Malaysia’s The Starnewspaper: “If you refer to the Quran, surah An-Nur verse 30 and 31, at best it only talks of modest attire and nothing more. Nevertheless, to be fair, the position does become more nuanced if Hadith (the Prophet’s sayings) are accounted for. When states propose to enact any Islamic law, they must first be able to characterise the legislation as conforming to Islamic law.

“If the Quran is accepted as the primary source of Islamic law, then state legislative assemblies are legislatively incompetent to enact laws regulating attire.”

Pahang has a population of 1.4 million of which 1 million are Muslims.

Each of the country’s 13 states enforces its own religious laws and moral guidelines governing Muslims ranging from interaction between unmarried couples – in public and in private – to strict dress codes to ban on alcohol consumption. 

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

Gorgeous picture book teaches kids about marriage equality

Gorgeous picture book teaches kids about marriage equality

Beautiful illustrations explain what it’s like when your dads can’t get married - as seen through the eyes of a small child
No thumbnail available

Nest in Cagliari, Sardinia this spring

Urban flamingos and a gay scene make the historic seaside city of Cagliari, capital of the Italian island, pretty in pink
No thumbnail available

Singer Missy Higgins praises Australian high school’s ban of ‘it's gay’

Australian singer says she’s ‘really proud’ of kids pledging not to use ‘gay’ as an insult
No thumbnail available

Adam Pally reflects on his gay character on ABC's Happy Endings

Says for a lot of people, Max is 'an honest representation of who they are'
South Korea takes down gay venue map website over 'moral values'

South Korea takes down gay venue map website over 'moral values'

South Korea's government appear to be attacking LGBTI spaces
No thumbnail available

UN chief Ban Ki-moon says gay activists are his 'inspiration'

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon hails 'brave' gay activists, says anti-gay abuse is a human rights violation and insists countries have a legal and moral duty to deal with it, whatever their culture
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Wisconsin governor has attended a gay wedding reception

The Republican is not a supporter of marriage equality
No thumbnail available

Video game with gay character option to get ‘beautiful’ sequel

The popular Mass Effect game, controversial for its third installment that allows players to engage in same-sex story lines, will continue with gay and lesbian player options in Mass Effect 4
No thumbnail available

Senator Rob Portman asked not to be Romney running mate to protect gay son

A new book claims Republican Senator Rob Portman asked to be taken off the list of potential vice-presidential running mates for Mitt Romney because he was concerned how running would affect his gay son