Man ‘guilty’ of fraud for not telling girlfriend he was trans

Scottish transgender man admitted to 'obtaining sexual intimacy by fraud' in two cases, meaning he will face jail time

Man ‘guilty’ of fraud for not telling girlfriend he was trans
07 March 2013

A transgender Scottish man was sentenced for obtaining sexual intimacy by fraud yesterday (6 March).

Chris Wilson, 25, from Aberdeen, was accused of failing to tell two teenage girls his gender history and real age.

The Edinburgh High Court heard one of the girls was aged between 15 and 16 when she first met Wilson in 2008, when he was 20.

The possibly underage girl found out the truth when another girl from Stonehaven emailed her a copy of Wilson’s passport – which gave Wilson’s birth name Christine. The two kissed but it went no further.

The second girl was 15 when she became friends with Wilson two years later, but told him she was 16, the legal age to have sex in the UK.

Wilson, who said he was 17, started a relationship with the girl and they eventually had sex.

His defense layer Shelagh McCall said her client is transgender, identified as a man from a young age, and is hoping to undergo gender reassignment therapy.

Judge Lord Bannatyne deferred sentence on Wilson, who faces jail, in order for the court to obtain reports.

Wilson was bailed and placed on the sex offenders’ register. He declined to comment after the case.

Nathan Gale, the project development manager for Scottish Transgender Alliance, slammed the tabloid reporting of the case.

Speaking to Gay Star News, he said: ‘We are very concerned for trans people because it could set a precedent forcing them to reveal their gender history to new sexual partners.

‘We are, at the moment, urging for clarification from the Crown Office. We are very concerned for the person involved.’

From the Scottish Transgender Alliance’s understanding after speaking to police and civil servants, obtaining sexual intimacy by fraud would not be used to prosecute transgender people for having relationships in their self-identified gender without revealing their gender history.

Last year, British teen Gemma Barker was jailed for 30 months after supposedly ‘disguising’ herself as a boy to date female friends.

Jane Fae, a transgender activist, made a parallel with Barker and Wilson, comparing Scottish and English law.

Speaking to GSN, she said: ‘The problem here is not that this sets a precedent, but this was a time bomb waiting to explode.

‘Following the Gemma Barker case, I had extensive discussions with the English Crown Prosecution Service and they were absolutely clear that trans identity could not be an absolute protection from charges of sexual assault or rape.

‘This means that in practice any trans man or trans woman who keeps their gender identity to themselves runs the risk, should their partner later find out and object, of being charged in a similar manner.

‘This is a complex issue and needs further consideration.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Plan for Washington DC national LGBT museum

If a group of US philanthropists have their way the United States will have an LGBT specific national museum in the nation’s capital by 2018
No thumbnail available

Watch: Brad Pitt, George Clooney perform in Prop 8 play

Jane Lynch, Chris Colfer read play written by Academy Award winner Dustin Lance Black
No thumbnail available

Rainbows worn in protest against Margaret Court

British tennis player Laura Robson wore a rainbow ribbon in support of gay rights.
No thumbnail available

Political religious leader: Israel cannot recognize gay marriage

A leader of a right wing Israeli political party said Israel must not recognize same-sex marriage
Handholding: Lesbians do it better

Handholding: Lesbians do it better

New study reveals that same-sex female couples are more egalitarian than their heterosexual counterparts.
No thumbnail available

George Takei and husband presented Los Angeles LGBT Center Award by 'heartthrob' Tab Hunter

Takei says of Hunter: 'He was blond and gorgeous ... he was a dreamboat'
No thumbnail available

Wisconsin judge orders clerks to stop giving marriage certificates to gay couples

'In light of the stay, we will do everything we can to expedite the case for a quick ruling on appeal'
Miley Cyrus fully understands why Caitlyn Jenner is living out her transition in the spotlight

Miley Cyrus fully understands why Caitlyn Jenner is living out her transition in the spotlight

'If she doesn't, everyone else is going to tell (her story) for her'
No thumbnail available

Bishop urges support for marriage equality in Rhode Island

Episcopal Bishop Nicholas Knisely has urged clergy to support marriage equality in the US state of Rhode Island ahead of a committee vote on the issue on Tuesday
No thumbnail available

Russian prosecutors assure rainbow lamp post is not gay propaganda

Prosecutors in the Russian region of Chelyabinsk have reassured a concerned citizen that a lamp post painted with rainbow colors in the city of Magnitogorsk is not in breach of the country’s ban on so-called gay propaganda to minors