Moldova’s ban on gay protest violated human rights, court rules

The European Court of Human Rights' ruling against Moldova hailed as 'important victory'

Moldova’s ban on gay protest violated human rights, court rules
12 June 2012

Moldova has been reprimanded by the European Court of Human Rights for banning gay campaigners from holding a peaceful protest outside the country’s parliament.

In 2005, the Chisinau Municipal Council and the Mayor’s office rejected GENDERDOC-M’s application to peacefully demonstrate in front of the Moldovan Parliament, calling for the adoption of laws protecting sexual minorities.

The denial was later upheld by the country’s Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court of Justice.

However, the LGBT group appealed to the European Court of Human Rights, which today (12 June) ruled that Moldova had violated its human rights.

The International Commission of Jurists and gay rights organization ILGA-Europe hailed the court’s ruling as an ‘important victory’.

Both groups submitted a third-party intervention arguing that the protection of public morality could not be an objective and reasonable justification for a difference in treatment under Article 14 of the European Convention of Human Rights.

Evelyne Paradis, executive director of ILGA-Europe, said: ‘The rights to peaceful assembly and expression are the fundamental rights in a democratic society and the European Court of Human Rights confirmed once again that those rights cannot be restricted on the basis of sexual orientation.

‘We hope that today’s judgment is a signal to Moldovan authorities that the discrimination against LGBT people is unacceptable and illegal and we hope that in the future they will act in accordance with the international human rights standards.’

The court heard Moldova argue that the denial of the group’s right to protest was justified because the majority of the Moldovan population did not approve of gay relationships.

Later, however, it agreed that there had been a violation of the right to freedom of assembly but maintained that there was no violation of other rights under the convention.

However, the European Court rejected these arguments and reiterated that ‘particularly weighty reasons need to be advanced to justify’ a distinction based on sexual orientation.

It added that if the reason for a difference in treatment was ‘based solely on the applicant’s sexual orientation, this would amount to discrimination under the convention.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Last mass for gay Catholics held in Soho, London

Vincent Nichols, Archbishop of Westminster, scrapped the services for being 'inconsistent' with Catholic teaching
No thumbnail available

Chick-fil-A continues to get supporters and detractors

Chick-fil-A battle continues with more politicians choosing sides
No thumbnail available

One in four Brits believe people choose to be gay

In a survey, 2,005 British adults were split evenly when asked if they believed in same-sex marriage
No thumbnail available

11 people whose coming out made headlines in 2013

GSN looks at 11 individuals, from A-list celebrities to high school students,  who stepped out of the closet and into the spotlight in 2013
No thumbnail available

Miss California contest gets gay entrant

Mollie Thomas hopes her entry into the Miss California USA pageant will improve gay visibility
No thumbnail available

Anti-gay slurs ruled hate speech in Mexico

The Mexican Supreme Court has ruled that two popular anti-gay slurs are hate speech and are not protected under freedom of speech in the country’s constitution
No thumbnail available

South Africa officially recognizes gay pride flag

South Africa has recognized it’s own version of the rainbow gay pride flag as an officially registered national symbol
No thumbnail available

Pioneering Australian prime minister on gay rights Gough Whitlam dies aged 98

Gough Whitlam, who lead the Australian Government from 1972 to 1975 and was one of the first Labor Party leaders to champion the rights of gays and lesbians, passed away this morning aged 98
No thumbnail available

Ricky Martin to play Che in Evita

Gay Grammy winner will portray ‘everyman’, not the revolutionary
No thumbnail available

Brazil presidential hopeful: gays 'need psychological care'

Tens of thousands of people denounced his comments on social media