Motion to stop challenges to state gay marriage laws fails

A motion to stop Australian federal government from challenging states’ same-sex marriage laws fails

Motion to stop challenges to state gay marriage laws fails
11 October 2012

A parliamentary motion to stop the federal government from challenging state same-sex marriage laws has failed in the Australian parliament.

Marriage equality proponent Greens Senator Sarah Hanson-Young brought the motion to the Senate today but it was defeated by 38 votes to 10.

‘Today the Gillard government refused to let the states get on with the business of representing the majority of Australian people who support marriage equality without the fear of a legal challenge from the Commonwealth,’ said Hanson-Young after the vote, AAP reports.

Hanson-Young added that the Prime Minister, who opposes legalizing gay marriage ‘is choosing to further hinder this inevitable reform’.

Fears of a constitutional challenge in the High Court was one of the main reasons cited by members of Tasmania’s upper house who rejected a state same-sex marriage bill last month.

Same-sex marriage bills have also been tabled in Victoria, Western Australia, New South Wales (NSW), South Australia and the Australian Capital Territories (ACT).

In South Australia a same-sex marriage bill was tabled in the upper house last February by Greens MLC Tammy Franks and the state’s Liberal Party leader Isobel Redmond has promised a free conscience vote on the issue. 

Australian Marriage Equality national convenor told Gay Star News yesterday that he is most hopeful about legislation moving forward in South Australia, NSW and the ACT.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Malaysian deputy education minister suggests ‘early corrective measures’ for LGBT people

Minister denies connection to guidelines, but says the government is taking ‘this LGBT issue seriously’
No thumbnail available

Russian region blames banning Gay Pride on sewer drain

Gay rights activists were originally banned from fighting for LGBTI rights because the event would have taken place on the same day as International Children's Day
No thumbnail available

More bigots than gay people on Time’s top 100

Frank Ocean among few LGBT people chosen by Time in its 2013 list of most influential figures
No thumbnail available

Gay diver Matthew Mitcham was surprised when Tom Daley came out

'I’d even had dinner with him a month before it happened and I never knew anything'
No thumbnail available

Trinidad and Tobago prime minister: gay rights 'not legally possible'

Kamla Persad-Bissessar hinted that a referendum may be called on decriminalizing gay sex
No thumbnail available

Civil rights groups call on federal judge to make marriage equality legal in Alabama

'Alabama couples deserve the security and protection that marriage provides'
No thumbnail available

Meet the first gay couple to marry in New Jersey

A lesbian couple of 27 years were the first to walk down the aisle and celebrate the historic moment
No thumbnail available

Putin’s new law may be used against gay marches

A new law in Russia fining people for ‘unsanctioned rallies’ could also be used to crack down on gay prides, says Amnesty
No thumbnail available

Gay man gets unexpected apology from one of his junior high school bullies - 20 years later

ChadMichael Morrisette recalls being bullied so severely that 'I couldn’t even walk to classes without an adult escort or friends with me'
No thumbnail available

Man accused of killing gay lover in crystal meth S&M extreme sex session

WARNING: Graphic details. Newcastle Crown Court hears how a former government vet indulged in 'inflicting pain on others' in sex session that allegedly went too far