The new Archbishop-elect of Glasgow Philip Tartaglia, an outspoken critic of marriage equality, has linked a gay Catholic Member of Parliament's early death to being gay.
Tartaglia previously attacked the Scottish government’s and Westminster proposals to legalise gay marriage, but now it's emerged he linked the Labour MP’s death to his sexuality.
David Cairns MP, a former Catholic priest and member of the Scottish Labour Party, died in May 2010 from acute pancreatitis at the age of 44.
Philip Tartaglia’s suggestion prompted criticism from friends and the partner of the late Cairns.
The Scottish Herald has uncovered that last April, during a debate at Magdalene College Oxford, the then-Bishop of Paisley made his opinion known as a response to an audience question.
The question was posed by Lesley Pilkington, the Christian psychotherapist who was struck off by British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) for offering to turn a gay man straight through therapy.
Pikington, who sat next to Mike Davidson of the Core Issues Trust, a ‘gay cure’ campaign group asked why the ‘homosexual agenda has become so powerful’ further alleging it was ‘intimidating, bullying and generates fear’, stressing people should ‘stand against it’.
She then proceeded to mention that Bob Bergeron, who wrote a book about happiness for mature gay men, committed suicide at the age of 49.
Tartaglia welcomed her opinion and proceeded to state: ‘Recently in Scotland there was a gay Catholic MP who died at the age of 44 or so, and nobody said anything, and why his body should just shut down at that age? Obviously he could have had a disease that would have killed anybody.
‘But you seem to hear so many stories about this kind of thing, but society won’t address it. You’re right, Lesley, thank you.’
Speaking with the Glasgow Herald, Dermot Kehoe, Cairns' partner said: ‘This is genuinely very upsetting and painful for David’s family and friends. I can’t believe that someone who claims to be a man of God and is seeking to give moral leadership should speak from such a position of ignorance.
‘I don’t care what his views on gay marriage are, but to bring in my dead partner to justify those views is wrong.’
Kehoe told BBC Radio Scotland's Good Morning Scotland program that implication that Cairns' death was due to his sexuality shows the bishop to be ‘in complete ignorance of all the facts in this case'.
‘David died of pancreatitis, a gallstone blocked his pancreatic tract,' he said. 'So that's what happened to David, which could have happened to anybody. To take a personal tragedy like this and seek to use it to make a political point, it's more than upsetting, it's deeply painful.’
On his appointment yesterday Bsihop Tartaglia expressed fears that he and other priests could face prosecution if such legislation goes ahead.
Speaking with Gay Star News, Colin Macfarlane director of Stonewall Scotland, slammed the bishop’s comments: 'Day one into the new job and the archbishop has sunk to a new low.
'Not only will his comments cause deep distress to David Cairns family and friends but they will cause great offence to the majority of Scots.
'It's deeply disappointing that someone who should be preaching about love and respect is instead speaking from a position of utter ignorance.'
The bishop has been an outspoken critic of the Scottish government’s plans to legalise same-sex marriage which has been announced today.
Last year the bishop wrote a letter to Alex Salmond, First Minister of Scotland, stating that the Scottish government does not ‘have the authority to say what marriage is or to change its nature or to decree that people of the same sex can marry’.
He also warned in the letter that if such legislation will take place there would be a ‘serious chill’ between the Catholic Bishops’ Conference and the Scottish government.
In 2010, Tartaglia told Prime Minister David Cameron: ‘You and your government need to be aware from the outset that the Catholic Church will not register civil partnerships nor celebrate same-sex unions: not now, not in the future, not ever, no matter what legislation or regulations your government enacts or endorses.’
Watch the panel discussion with Tartaglia:
Religious Freedom and Equality: Keynote by Bishop Philip Tartaglia from The Berkley Center on Vimeo.
Comments
Coach Handbags
with my parents
cheap burberry handbags
house for the summer
wholesale designer purses
preparing for the university
coach outlet online
and was in no hurry
coach outlet coach
interfered with my freedom
cheap designer bags
parting with my last tutor
cheap designer purses
never been able to get
furla handbags
that he had fallen
gucci handbags
sluggishly in bed with
gucci wallet
exasperation on his face
hermes handbags
with careless kindness
jimmy choo handbags
though she had no
cheap juicy couture handbags
cares completely
juicy couture wallet
young and very handsome
cheap louis vuitton bags
her from mercenary
cheap louis vuitton wallet
ten years older than
mk purses
was for ever agitated
mk wallet
very much afraid of him
prada handbags
never seen a man more
prada wallet
at the country house.
roberto cavalli handbags
we left town on the
louis vuitton outlet
about in our garden
louis vuitton bags
beyond the town gates
louis vuitton belts
often than anythingt
louis vuitton store
a great deal of
Louis Vuitton Damier bags
and my heart ached
handbags louis vuitton
hope and anticipation
louis vuitton sunglasses
frightened of something
louis vuitton louis vuitton handbags
wonder at everything
louis vuitton wallets
imagination played continually
outlet louis vuitton
about the same fancies
louis vuitton handbags
the tears and through
louis vuitton purses bags
inspired by a musical verse
louis vuitton men bags
in spring the delicious
louis vuitton monogram bags
and effervescent
louis vuitton bags handbag
gallop and fancy
purses louis vuitton
my face towards
cheap louis vuitton
its shining radiance
louis vuitton purses
that time the image
louis vuitton sale
arose in definite shape
bags louis vuitton
presentiment of something new
louis vuitton louis vuitton purses
settled for the summer
louis vuitton bags purses
in the lodge on
louis vuitton wallet
for the manufacture
coach purses
once strolled that way
cheap handbags purses
at about a dozen thin
cheap handbags and purses
boys with greasy smocks
outlet coach online
jumping on to wooden
coach online outlet
pressed down the square
cheap coach purses
blocks of the press
coach purses outlet
struck off the variegated
cheap purses and handbags
lodge on the right
cheap purses handbags
and was to let
purses and handbags cheap
lodge were drawn up
cheap gucci bags
had installed themselves
purses handbags wholesale
inquired of the butler
wholesale purses handbags
hearing the name of
wholesale handbags purses
observed with some respect
handbags purses wholesale
three hired flies
handbags and purses wholesale
he handed a dish
cheap louis vuitton handbags
their own carriage
wholesale purses and handbags
so much the better
china handbags
not be a rich woman
china purses
so dilapidated and small
prada bags
have consented to
purses from china
went in at one ear and
bags from china
had just been reading