New Mexico Supreme Court rules against photography business that turned down gay wedding

Court finds that Elane Photography violated state's Human Rights Act

New Mexico Supreme Court rules against photography business that turned down gay wedding
23 August 2013

Elaine Huguenin told a lesbian couple in New Mexico that she could not photograph their 2006 wedding because it would violate her religious beliefs.

On Thursday, the New Mexico Supreme Court unanimously ruled that Huguenin had violated the state’s Human Rights Act.

The court stated that in turning away plaintiff Vanessa Willock and her partner, Elane Photography in Albuquerque had violated the act in the same way as if it had turned away a couple of opposite races.

‘We conclude that a commercial photography business that offers its services to the public, thereby increasing its visibility to potential clients, is subject to the anti-discrimination provisions of the [New Mexico Human Rights Act] and must serve same-sex couples on the same basis that it serves opposite-sex couples,’ the court stated in its opinion.

The five justices stated that businesses that choose to be ‘public accommodations’ may express their religious or political beliefs but still must comply with anti-discrimination laws.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Lifting of gay ban must come from people says Sri Lankan activist

Campaigner Rossana Flamer-Caldera says rise in nationalism in Sri Lanka poses major threat to LGBT rights at World Pride conference in London
Chris Brown allegedly throws punch and anti-gay slur

Chris Brown allegedly throws punch and anti-gay slur

Chris Brown and a bodyguard are arrested for felony assault
No thumbnail available

Zak’s Safari: Stunning picture book for the donor-conceived children of same-sex couples

A beautifully illustrated children’s book, that will help to explain to the donor-conceived kids their biological origins, has successfully raised its production costs via Kickstarter
No thumbnail available

Hospital in Padua first to recognize gay parents

When a new baby is born, now the parents are indicated as 'partners' instead of 'mom' and 'dad'
No thumbnail available

Gay-friendly JC Penny’s ‘Adolf Hitler’ kettle sells out online

Clothing and home retailer has landed in hot water after an image of a kettle bearing a resemblance to the Nazi leader went viral
No thumbnail available

Police investigate after Florida church has its gay pride flag ripped down

The Lower Miami Church of the Brethren was flying a rainbow pride flag to show it welcomes LGBTI people but someone tore it down on Saturday
No thumbnail available

Backlash against mocking of Chinese crossdresser

The mocking of a crossdresser on local TV and on a microblog prompted a flurry of online criticism
No thumbnail available

Lady Gaga tells newly out Tom Daley: ‘Never dive in Russia’

Bisexual songstress gave advice to the Olympic diving teen on Alan Carr's Chatty Man
No thumbnail available

Joan Rivers' daughter blasts Kathy Griffin over Fashion Police debacle

'She kind of s**t all over my mother’s legacy'
No thumbnail available

Boy George leaves Twitter after homophobic bullying tweets

80s popstar driven from Twitter and calls in lawyers