New York attorney claims murderer of trans woman shouldn’t face harsh sentance

NY attorney John Scarpa claimed his client shouldn't face the same punishment as if he killed someone 'in the higher end of the community'

New York attorney claims murderer of trans woman shouldn’t face harsh sentance
07 December 2013

A New York defence attorney has caused outrage by claiming a murderer of a trans woman shouldn’t face the same punishment as if he had killed someone ‘in the higher end of the community’.


John Scarpa made the claim on Thursday (05 December) as his client, Rasheen Everett, was sentenced to 25 years to life for the brutal murder of Amanda Gonzalez-Andujar in 2010.


Speaking on Everett’s sentence, Scarpa said: ‘A sentence of 25 years to life is an incredibly long period of time, Judge. Shouldn’t that be reserved for people who are guilty of killing certain classes of individuals?


‘Who is the victim in this case? Is the victim a person in the higher end of the community?’


Scarpa was immediately scolded by the judge, Supreme Justice Richard Butcher, who said: ‘This court believes every human life is sacred… It’s not easy living as a transgender, and I commend the family for supporting her.’


Everett, 32, was convicted of murdering Gonzalez-Andujar last month.


After meeting for sex in March 2010, Everett found Gonzalez-Andujar had male genitalia. He then proceeded to strangle and stab her.


Gonzalez-Andujar’s naked body was found in her apartment days later, which had been ransacked.


Everett showed no remorse during the trial – even going so far as to chuckle through an emotional testimony by Gonzalez-Andujar’s brother, who said: ‘The pain my family feels is unbearable… It’s all like a nightmare, and I’m still waiting to wake up.’


At the sentencing, Butcher criticized Everett, saying: ‘The defendant is coldhearted and a violent menace to society’.



No thumbnail available

Out and proud Mika 'not sick' of gay question

Singing sensation Mika releases his most intimate album yet, featuring material about his 'horrific breakup' with his boyfriend
No thumbnail available

Anti-LGBT slurs taken seriously

Actor Neil Patrick Harris learns quickly that using the word "tranny" can be very upsetting to people.
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Student Pride returning for its 10th birthday in February – details revealed

Tenth annual LGBTI event takes place in London; celebrations include a screening of Boy Meets Girl
No thumbnail available

Marriage equality number one civil rights issue for young Australian voters

A new poll shows that allowing same-sex couples to marry is the number one civil rights issue for Australians under 25 with only education and cost of living issues rating higher
No thumbnail available

AFA’s Bryan Fischer compares anti-gay Indiana pizzeria owners to Holocaust diarist Anne Frank

The American Family Association’s Bryan Fischer has likened the owners of an Indiana pizzeria to Nazi Holocaust victim Anne Frank because they temporarily closed their restaurant and went into hiding after a public backlash
No thumbnail available

Mayor of Columbus, Ohio, publicly supports lesbian teacher fired from Catholic high school

'No one in Columbus or in the United States should be denied employment because of their choice of who to love'
No thumbnail available

HSBC boss in UK: 'Being a short, bald, Portuguese, gay guy' is good for my job

Top banks and financial services firms unite for summit on LGBTI issues in London
No thumbnail available

Michael Sam plays first preseason NFL game

'The hardest critic is going to be myself. I'm not mad about my first game, but I know I could have done better'
No thumbnail available

Ruth Bader Ginsberg: US Supreme Court's timing on gay marriage could depend on Sixth Circuit ruling

Associate justice says there will only be urgency for high court if a state ban is upheld