Pixar’s Brave ‘lesbian’ character provokes debate

Review said the lead character Merida must be gay because she likes sport and refuses to get married

Pixar’s Brave ‘lesbian’ character provokes debate
04 July 2012

Ever since Pixar’s Brave came out in cinemas, a tale of an independent girl on a task to save her family, the lead character has provoked debate about her sexuality.

When Entertainment Weekly posted a review of the new film, critic Adam Markovitz said the character Merida must be gay because she likes sport and refuses to get married.

In the article, Markovitz says: ‘Could Merida be gay? Absolutely. She bristles at the traditional gender roles that she’s expected to play: the demure daughter, the obedient fiancée.

‘Her love of unprincess-like hobbies, including archery and rock-climbing, is sure to strike a chord with gay viewers who felt similarly “not like the other kids” growing up.’

The review caused a backlash when it was published late last month, with many calling out the writer for his belief in gender and lesbian stereotypes.

Markovitz was not alone. A picture of Merida posted on photo site 9gag.com provoked comments calling her a ‘dyke’.

A writer from feminist blog The Vagenda told Gay Star News she wanted to applaud Pixar for creating a strong female character that defies gender stereotypes.

She said: [They are] presenting young girls with a heroine that they can be truly proud of that is, at no point, defined by her relationship with a romantic lead.’

The Vagenda writer added: ‘The last 16-year-old Disney princess we had was Ariel, who changed her species to get the guy. I’d say Merida is a far more positive role model than that.

‘Whether she’s gay or straight isn’t important, and the fact that question is even being asked demonstrates how important this film is for a young audience growing up in a world of stereotypes.’

Brave was released in North America on 22 June.  

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Gates' give $500K to Washington state gay marriage campaign

Microsoft Chairman and co-founder Bill Gates, and his wife donated $500,000 to Washington State’s marriage equality campaign
No thumbnail available

Governor Deval Patrick signs beefed-up anti bullying bill

Massachusetts law has strenghtened protections for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender students and students with disabilities.
No thumbnail available

Gay US Marine and partner speak out about homecoming kiss

Brandon Morgan and Dalan Wells happy to see their reunion smooch go viral
No thumbnail available

Anderson Cooper reveals to TV audience that gay pal Andy Cohen is a top

Cooper: 'Believe me, there's nothing wrong with that, but I'm just saying I think that would surprise people'
No thumbnail available

NYC high rise fire claims life of gay newlywed; his husband is hospitalized

Daniel McClung, a 27-year-old playwright, was trying to escape flames by taking smoke-filled stairwell
No thumbnail available

Google refuses to pull gay 'cure' app as Apple bins it

Google Play keeps Setting Captives Free app which aims to ‘cure’ gay people in 60 days
No thumbnail available

Gay couples banned from suing churches for not marrying them

Equalities Minister Maria Miller has said there will be primary legislation preventing gays from using European law to sue
No thumbnail available

Top US football coach wants gay people in sport

Influential college sports coach speaks on the importance of tolerance and diversity in sport
No thumbnail available

BBC cancels lesbian drama Lip Service

The British Broadcasting Corporation has revealed the beloved drama will not be back for a third series
No thumbnail available

A future for gay Egypt?

Lesbian and gay Egyptians express their concerns for the future and suggest a way forwards