Plan to open Yale campus in Singapore hits controversy

Yale faculty concerned about civil rights in Singapore, where homosexuality is illegal

Plan to open Yale campus in Singapore hits controversy
11 April 2012

An agreement between Yale and the National University of Singapore has hit controversy after a resolution that states ‘concern regarding the history of lack of respect for civil and political rights in the state of Singapore’ was passed by the faculty last week.

Yale has already agreed to open its first overseas campus in Singapore, where homosexuality is illegal, so the vote is largely symbolic, but it’s evidence of a fierce debate about whether a liberal arts university should open a campus in a less than liberal location.

Seyla Benhabib, a political science professor at Yale who brought the resolution to the faculty, told the New York Times that ‘the faculty is feeling disempowered, that it has no voice in what is going on’.

The agreement between Yale president Richard C Levin and the National University of Singapore was made a year ago, without the involvement of the faculty and Yale-NUS has already started recruiting staff for a student intake in 2013. Levin said the Yale staff didn’t need to be involved in the decision because the students won't receive Yale degrees, and the institution is being entirely funded by NUS.

Singaporeans responded to the resolution saying that the Yale faculty lack understanding of the political situation in Singapore. ‘Both the tone of the resolution and some contributions to the debate have definitely struck a note of moral superiority,' John Richardson, a director at NUS told Yale Daily News. ‘More generally, both the resolution and certain comments assume that Yale, and the US behind it, should and will enlighten the less fortunate parts of the world.’

But author of Singaporean gay culture and politics blog Yawning Bread, Alex Au, told Yale Daily News he thought the faculty’s resolution was fair, and concerns about ‘moral superiority’ should not prevent discussion about the lack of political freedom in the city-state.

‘I would say this strikes me as being similar to one of the Singapore government's favorite defences whenever their human rights record is called into question,’ Au said. ‘As a Singaporean, I reject such a facile attempt at Singapore- or Asian-particularism. If anything, I think it is demeaning to think that we are incapable of aspiration [for more liberties].’

Singaporean and Yale linguistics graduate student E-Ching Ng wrote a response to the resolution in the Yale Daily News that said: ‘Homosexual intercourse is illegal in Singapore the way underage drinking is illegal at Yale. The police have never bothered my openly gay brother, writer-activist Ng Yi-Sheng, despite his public gender-bending antics and book of coming-out stories with real names and faces, which became a Singaporean bestseller.’

The lively voices heard in this debate suggest Yale is already bringing greater political freedoms to a country ranked 135th (above Honduras and below Tunisia) out of 179 in Reporters Without Borders' Press Freedom Index.  

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Ireland’s constitutional convention votes for gay marriage

Special convention overwhelmingly recommends to Ireland’s government to legalize marriage equality
No thumbnail available

UN tells Russia to scrap anti-gay ‘propaganda’ bill

UN rights experts advise Russian Duma to scrap bill on ‘homosexuality propaganda’
No thumbnail available

One in four gays is abused by their partner

25% of gay and bisexual men and 80% of trans people suffer from domestic abuse in the UK, according to a new charity report
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Homophobes hug gay people in parody First Kiss video

Following the viral success of the First Kiss video uploaded to YouTube this week, the Gay Women Channel has recorded its own version, with alleged homophobes hugging gay people
No thumbnail available

Openly gay singer Bright Light Bright Light to open for Elton John

The electro-pop singer joins the Rocket Man singer on his North American tour this autumn
No thumbnail available

Third judge in three weeks strikes down Florida's gay marriage ban

Ruling only applies to Broward County and judge issued immediate stay
No thumbnail available

Indian LGBT theatre troupe challenges social norms

Members of an LGBT theatre troupe based in Chennai, southeast India, speak about the empowering effect of the stage
This is what happened when a seven-year-old girl faced off with an anti-gay preacher
No thumbnail available

Glee’s Puck and Finn become new Kurt and Blaine

Straight characters Puck and Finn will swap bodies with gay couple Kurt and Blaine in an upcoming episode