Political claims and counter claims on same-sex marriage in Australia

Deposed Australian prime minister Kevin Rudd has denied telling LGBT activists that same-sex marriage would have been legalized if he was still leading the country and that his successor’s opposition on the issue is pure politics

Political claims and counter claims on same-sex marriage in Australia
22 July 2012

Former Australian prime minister Kevin Rudd has denied claims by three witnesses that he told them that same-sex marriage would have been legalized if he was still prime minister, and that the current prime minister, Julia Gillard, got her job through a deal with the Christian right of her party to oppose same-sex marriage

Rudd, who was deposed by his Australian Labor Party colleagues in favor of Gillard in June of 2010, denied making the comments to former Australian Medical Association head Kerryn Phelps and wife Jackie Stricker-Phelps, which were also heard by marriage equality campaigner Geoff Thomas.

‘He absolutely said that if he was prime minister [it] would have gone through,’ Stricker-Phelps told The Sun Herald newspaper, ‘We couldn’t believe how open and forthright he was.’

Thomas, a Vietnam veteran and plumber who has been campaigning for same-sex marriage since his son came out, corroborated what Phelps had told the newspaper.

‘I hope you know if I was prime minister this would be law … The reason Julia Gillard is in power is because of a deal she did with the Australian Christian Lobby and [Catholic union leader] Joe De Bruyn,’ Thomas said he had heard Rudd say.

Thomas told the Sun Herald that Rudd had told him that Gillard, who is an unmarried atheist in a long term relationship, had supported marriage equality in cabinet before becoming prime minister but had since changed her tune for political reasons.

Gillard has consistently said she opposes same-sex marriage since becoming prime minister, telling a forum hosted by Google as recently as yesterday that her opposition was because marriage had a special cultural status, but then said same-sex relationships were equally valued.

‘I don’t think that heterosexual relationships are more valued than same-sex relationships,’ Gillard said.

‘I think people who are in loving, committed relationships, all of those relationships should be valued. I think my relationship should be valued and I’m not married.’

Gillard has promised a conscience vote on the issue before the end of the year but there are not enough votes to pass a bill on the issue on the Government benches so some Opposition votes would also be needed.

But Opposition leader Tony Abbott will not allow his frontbench a conscience vote on the issue which will tie up key votes.

The comments were allegedly made by Rudd at the Labor Party’s National Convention in Sydney in December last year.

Rudd made an appearance at a function during the convention put on by Rainbow Labor, the party’s LGBT caucus.

But a spokeswoman for the former prime minister denied he had made the comments.

‘The content of the reported conversations contained in your inquiry is not accurate, including your references to cabinet discussions, which, as a matter of principle, Mr Rudd does not comment on,’ she told the Sun Herald.

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Ex-boyfriend of embattled Arizona sheriff Paul Babeu speaks out

Mexican national says he is in US legally and wants to get on with his life
No thumbnail available

Jeremy Joseph: From club mogul to marathon man

We find out how Britain’s leading gay nightclub owner, Jeremy Joseph, hopes to raise a quarter million for Elton John AIDS Foundation with his London Marathon run
No thumbnail available

Sweet or sour: Your Valentine’s food treats

André Dang tracks down the perfect foodie gifts for Valentine’s Day whether you are with a loved one or just want to stab something
Comment: Surrogacy law reform is a gay issue

Comment: Surrogacy law reform is a gay issue

Surrogacy is in the news, and gay men looking to become parents should pay attention, says Natalie Gamble from law firm Natalie Gamble Associates
No thumbnail available

Human Rights Watch to Malaysian government: allow sexualities festival a day in court

Uncertainty whether decision to ban Seksualiti Merdeka sexual diversity festival will be reviewed in court
No thumbnail available

Boys Scouts of America upholds its ban on gays

'This breaks my heart,' says Eric Jones, the 19-year-old Eagle Scout kicked out this week
No thumbnail available

Despite anti-gay laws in Russia, gay MSNBC anchor Thomas Roberts to host Miss Universe pageant in Moscow

Aggressively went after gig because 'it is a huge, visible opportunity for LGBT people'
No thumbnail available

David LaChapelle-designed Audi raises $150,000 for HIV and AIDS at Vienna Life Ball

As part of Europe’s biggest HIV and AIDS charity fundraiser, the iconic American artist had his way with a four-wheeled piece of art provided by Audi
No thumbnail available

Uruguay votes for gay marriage

Uruguay's lower chamber completes a historic legislative process to legalize marriage equality in the country
No thumbnail available

US diplomats’ first gay pride in Kenya sparks praise and boycott

Kenyan LGBT activists divided about plans for LGBT pride event at US embassy on 26 June