Portrayal of gays in Hollywood films is ‘sad’, says screenwriter

Hollywood screenwriter Abdi Nazemian has criticized Hollywood films like Dallas Buyers Club and Philadelphia for their depictions of gay men who are saved by straight, homophobic characters  

Portrayal of gays in Hollywood films is ‘sad’, says screenwriter
01 June 2014

A US screenwriter has criticzed Hollywood depcitions of gay men, branding them ‘a very sad depiction of gay culture.’

Hollywood screenwriter and author Abdi Nazemian, who has worked on films The Quiet and Revolution, spoke about the negative depictions of gay men in the majority of Hollywood films with HuffPost Live.

Nazemian, who is gay, spoke about feature films with gay storylines but had straight lead protagonists like Dallas Buyers Club and Philadelphia.

‘Personally I think the depiction of gay men in Hollywood is horrible,’ he said.

‘There’s this idea of a straight saviour. In both cases the lead character is not only a straight man but a homophobic straight man that saves the day and saves gay men.’

‘It’s such a common narrative. There are two things that really bother me about it, the first is that when the AIDS crisis first started gay men really didn’t get much help from the straight community, and so they had to mobilize themselves and that is not honoured by those films.

‘Second is that the characters are not just straight they’re homophobic and so there’s an assumption on the part of the filmmakers that viewers need a homophobic character as a point of entry and I don’t think that’s true anymore.

‘And of course there are other narratives — I mean, now HBO made ‘The Normal Heart,’ which is a great counter-narrative to those. So there is great stuff being done, but when you look at it on a whole, especially in feature films, I think it’s a very sad depiction of gay culture.’

Nazemian initially broached this subject in an article he wrote last year for the Hollywood Journal, where he criticized Hollywood films for attributing straight men as the saviours of the gay community.

‘The truth is that the gay community mobilized in an unprecedented way in response to the AIDS epidemic. They did not wait for a homophobic cowboy or a homophobic attorney to save them. They saved themselves,’ he wrote.

Tom Hanks won an Oscar for his performance in Philadelphia, as did Jared Leto for his portrayal of a transgender AIDS victim in Dallas Buyers Club.



No thumbnail available

Ian McKellen: 'I've never met a gay person who came out and who regretted it'

'I often thought my gravestone would say, 'Here lies Gandalf. He came out,"' says the 75-year-old actor who came out publicly 25 years ago
Feel London's heart beat from these Soho homes

Feel London's heart beat from these Soho homes

There is no place quite as alive as a home in the district between Oxford Street and Shaftesbury Avenue
No thumbnail available

Hollywood hates LGBT actors, new study reveals

Over half of LGBT respondents to a survey have said they have heard anti-gay comments on set, while one in 10 say they have been turned down for a role for being gay
No thumbnail available

Man gets 25 to 40 years for death of transgender teen

Killer of teen Shelley Hilliard is sentenced to 25 to 40 years
No thumbnail available

The View takes on US governor hopeful

The View co-host Whoopi Goldberg promises to do what she can to help defeat Ken Cuccinelli's campaign to be the governor of Virginia
No thumbnail available

Sports heroes tackling gay-hate in Eastern Europe

GSN meets the European Gay and Lesbian Sport Federation who are playing a leading role in fighting homophobia
Italy becomes fifth country in the world to allow trans people to change gender without a doctor

Italy becomes fifth country in the world to allow trans people to change gender without a doctor

Italy joins Argentina, Denmark, Malta and Ireland in acknowledging the right of trans people to self-determine their own identity
No thumbnail available

The surrogate mom who decided to only carry children for gay men

One Californian mom explains why she regards surrogacy, and helping gay men to become dads, as her own form of ‘Uterine Activism’
No thumbnail available

Michigan Attorney General denounces nationalist group seeking to join him in opposing gay marriage

Michigan’s Republican Attorney General Bill Schuette is seeking to defend his state’s ban on same-sex marriage but he has condemned the far right nationalist Traditionalist Youth Network for trying to join him in doing so
No thumbnail available

Frank Ocean and Chris Brown allegedly brawl over parking space outside recording studio

Law enforcement authorities seeking Brown for questioning