Review of blood donation discrimination does not go far enough

An Australian Red Cross review of blood donations rules does not go far enough to end discrimination against gay men, campaigners say

Review of blood donation discrimination does not go far enough
24 May 2012

Campaigners who want to change Australia’s discriminatory blood donation rules for gay men say a review by the Australian Red Cross does not go far enough.

The newly published review recommends that the time gay men have to abstain from sex before giving blood be reduced from 12 to six months.

The Tasmania Gay and Lesbian Rights Group said that if the new recommendations are introduced the majority of gay men will still be unable to give blood.

Micheal Cain is legally challenging blood donation discrimination by taking a case before the Tasmanian Anti-Discrimination Tribunal. He said:

‘Like most gay men I will still not be able to donate under the proposed policy, even though I have a far, far lower risk of catching HIV than many heterosexual people who can currently donate.

‘The only way to remove discrimination from blood donation and increase the pool of safe blood from donors such as myself is to adopt a policy which screens all donors for the safety of their sexual activity rather than the gender of their partner.’

Tasmanian Gay and Lesbian Rights Group’s Rodney Croome said the Australian Red Cross’s review was flawed because it draws data about rates of HIV among gay men from studies done in sex venues and bars.

‘Experts who appeared in Michael Cain’s case made it clear that the data upon which the current ban is based only takes into account people with high HIV risk and ignores the vast bulk of gay men who are at much lower risk,’ said Croome. ‘It’s extremely disappointing that the review has replicated this mistake. The only way to resolve this issue is for the Government to commission a truly independent review.’

The Australian Red Cross’s review calls for a further year-long study of 100,000 donors to ascertain the accuracy of the information people give before giving blood.

Spokesperson for the Australian Red Cross Kathy Bowlen told AAP that the current rules around blood donation were not discriminatory. ‘It’s never been found to be discriminatory because we’re required to rule people out on the basis of risk,’ she said.

Bowlen said an earlier study showed that a quarter of blood donors between 2005 and 2010 whose blood contained transmissible infections had not been open about information that would have barred them from donating. She said providing accurate information was very important as blood screening does not pick up infections in their early stages.

The review will not be considered by the state and federal bodies that regulate blood donations.

Internationally, Japan and South Africa currently have a six month deferral for male donors who have sex with men. In the United States, Canada and much of Europe sexually active gay men cannot donate blood at all, while in the UK and Hungary, a one year deferral is in place.

‘The review’s recommendations are not a step forward and leave me feeling really frustrated that the focus continues to be on my partner’s gender rather than how safe we are,’ Cain concluded.



No thumbnail available

Ian McKellen ‘feared the worst’ after prostate cancer shock

Gay British acting legend has also revealed he fancied his fellow gay thespian Sir Derek Jacobi while at university
No thumbnail available

Power Gays: Mel Kenyon

We meet theatre agent Mel Kenyon - one of the driving forces behind smash-hit musical Matilda.
No thumbnail available

Agony Aunt tells dad: Don't take your kids to brother's gay wedding

'With all due respect, there is no need to invite children aged six and eight.'
No thumbnail available

Proposed US immigration act will not recognize gay couples

Democrat and Republican members of the Senate Judiciary Committee say they do not want to jeopardize immigration reforms
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Dive into the fun at the gay Pink Lake festival

The picturesque Woerthersee lake in Austria, up in the mountains, is hosting a long LGBT weekend of entertainment, sunshine and relaxing
No thumbnail available

Uganda clerics hold gay hate Easter march

Ugandan religious figures, backed by US evangelical groups, held gay hate march next to the home of grieving elderly mother of slain gay rights activist
No thumbnail available

One Million Moms now targeting The Gap

Anti-gay group objects to billboard in Los Angeles featuring male couple sharing a single T-shirt
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Washington Gov. Christine Gregoire speaks from the heart

First governor to do video Americans for Marriage Equality Campaign video