Scalia defends comparing his opposition to sodomy to his opposition to murder

Supreme Court justice has been consistantly anti-gay in his rulings

Scalia defends comparing his opposition to sodomy to his opposition to murder
11 December 2012

US Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, already well known for his opposition to LGBT legal cases, this week defended his comparison between having a moral objection to sodomy and having a moral objection toward things like bestiality or murder.

‘If we cannot have moral feelings against homosexuality, can we have it against murder? Can we have it against these other things?’ Scalia said during a lecture at Princeton University on Monday (10 December).

The justice made the remark in response to a question from a gay student about the comparison in regards to his dissent in Lawrence v. Texas, the criminal case that abolished anti-sodomy laws.

In Lawrence v. Texas, the conservative judge wrote in his dissent the court had joined ‘the so-called homosexual agenda.’

In October, he told an audience that when it comes to gay rights there’s not much to consider.

‘Homosexual sodomy? Come on. For 200 years, it was criminal in every state,’ Scalia said during an appearance at the American Enterprise Institute.

His latest remarks come on the heels of the Supreme Court’s decision to review gay marriage cases involving California’s Proposition 8 and the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA).

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Gay speed skater Blake Skjellerup advises closeted athletes to remain focused on their sport

'Your sport is what makes up who you are more than your sexuality'
No thumbnail available

Five ultra-Orthodox Jews arrested over vigilante attack on New York gay man

Police have arrested five members of a group of Haredi ultra-Orthodox Jews who beat up 22-year-old gay black New Yorker Taj Paterson during a vigilante patrol of their neighborhood
No thumbnail available

Over 150 attend vigil against UK newspaper for printing trans hate speech

Trans supports express disappointment with The Observer for publishing a Julie Burchill comment piece littered with trans slurs
No thumbnail available

Scissor Sisters make the cut with new tour

US pop quintet spawned by New York's gay scene to embark on North American tour following release of fourth album
No thumbnail available

200 angry parents attend school meeting after teacher reads class gay-themed children's book to address bullying

'As a matter of fact, that is bullying me,' one angry father claims to have been bullied when his child was read the book in class
No thumbnail available

North Carolina Baptist pastor urges parents to 'punch' girlish sons

Sean Harris says: 'Dads, the second you see your son dropping the limp wrist, you walk over there and crack that wrist' 
No thumbnail available

Axe man hacks to death Belgian in wave of gay hate crimes

Gay man brutally murdered with an axe in the city of Liège following a string of homophobic attacks across the country
No thumbnail available

Second Republican US senator comes out in favor of gay marriage

Mark Kirk of Illinois says 'life comes down to who you love and who loves you back'
Sean Conroy becomes baseball's first ever openly gay professional player

Sean Conroy becomes baseball's first ever openly gay professional player

His teammates wore rainbow bands and socks to support him
No thumbnail available

Pride London chair Patrick Williams quits

The chair of Pride London, Patrick Williams, has resigned after criticism of the board’s handling of World Pride