School who refused HIV teen a place forced to pay out

School in US chocolate town of Hershey pay damages to 14-year-old with HIV who they said was ‘direct threat’ to other students

School who refused HIV teen a place forced to pay out
14 September 2012

A school in Pennsylvania has paid $700,000 (€) in damages after they refused admission to a 14-year-old boy because he is HIV-positive.

A federal lawsuit alleged Milton Hershey School, Hershey, had violated the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) when it denied admission to the student in last year.

The student, who is only identified by the pseudonym Abraham Smith, filed the suit along with his mother on 30 November 2011, in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.

The Department of Justice said: ‘Under the settlement agreement, the school is required to pay $700,000 to Smith and his mother, adopt and enforce a policy prohibiting discrimination and requiring equal opportunity for students with disabilities, including those with HIV, in the school’s programs and services, and to provide training to staff and administrators on the requirements of the ADA.

‘The school must also pay a $15,000 (€) civil penalty to the United States.’

Zane David Memeger, US Attorney for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania said: ‘This is a very significant case, affirming the rights of persons with HIV, and we applaud the school for working so cooperatively to amend its position on this matter.’

The ADA requires that public accommodations, including private schools, like the Milton Hershey School, to provide individuals with disabilities, including those with HIV, equal access to facilities, services, privileges, accommodation, advantages and goods.

‘Abraham’, 14, who is now a ninth-grader had been denied admission last year to the eighth-grade class at the Milton Hershey School, founded in 1909 by the Hershey chocolate magnate and his wife.

The school administrators had claimed the honor roll student presented a ‘direct threat’ to the health and safety of other students.

According to a press release announcing the settlement: ‘In order to protect our children in this unique environment, we cannot accommodate the needs of students with chronic communicable diseases that pose a direct threat to the health and safety of others.’

In addition to the financial settlement the school is also required to conduct HIV training for its staff and students.

Anthony J Colistra, the school’s president, finally publicly apologized to ‘Abraham’ and his mother on 6 August and offered to reconsider his application.

He also announced ‘a new equal opportunity policy clearly stating that the School treats applicants with HIV no differently than any other applicants.’

And he added the school was ‘developing and providing mandatory training for staff and students on HIV issues’.

The settlement concludes the federal HIV discrimination lawsuit brought against the school by the non-profit AIDS Law Project of Pennsylvania.

Ronda B Goldfein, executive director of the AIDS Law Project of Pennsylvania said: ‘This case renewed a nationwide discussion about whether people with HIV represent a risk to others in casual settings.

‘The question has once again been definitively answered: They do not.’

The AIDS Law Project of Pennsylvania also reported ‘Abraham’ and his mother have decided that he shall now not attend the school but instead plan to use the settlement to cover other educational expenses.

On hearing of the settlement ‘Abraham’ said: ‘I am very glad this is over.

‘It should have never been an issue in the first place. I will never recoup my eighth-grade year in school. Though I had a good one academically, I was too engulfed with this… to enjoy the fun of going to high school. Now it’s time for me to start healing internally and my mother said that will come in time also.’

The Department of Justice provides a webpage dedicated to information about the ADA and HIV here.



No thumbnail available

Ukraine LGBTI pride cancelled for fear of homophobic attacks

As the police could not guarantee the safety of those celebrating LGBTI pride, today’s event had to be cancelled
No thumbnail available

US pundit angry new film Noah didn’t blame flood on gay people

Anti-gay spokesman believes the 'left' is using religion to further causes, such as climate change and homosexuality
No thumbnail available

Italian lawmakers to debate civil unions bill in September

Italian Prime Minister Matteo Renzi has announced that his government will move forward with legislation to allow same-sex couples to enter into civil unions and to recognize same-sex marriages performed overseas
No thumbnail available

Ricky Martin's pantless tweet goes viral

Singing star auctioning off his trousers for HIV/AIDS fundraiser
No thumbnail available

The business world, corporate culture and LGBTI rights – why it all matters

Our Business Editor, David Hudson, explains what you can expect from the new Gay Star News business section
No thumbnail available

Canadian man finally gets apology for anti-gay slur in his 1970 high school yearbook

Robin Tomlin, who is battling liver disease, calls it a 'happy day'
No thumbnail available

Oklahoma judge bars trans people from changing names

Citing the Bible, Judge Bill Graves says transgender men and women are changing their names for 'fraudulent purposes'
No thumbnail available

Pastor giving the benediction at Obama's inauguration has given anti-gay sermon

Louie Giglio quickly proving to be a controversial choice
No thumbnail available

How anti-gay Christians are denying us freedom of speech

Young Jamaican activist Matthew Thomas examines how Christians in his own country, and Nigeria, Georgia, Uganda and Russia, are seeking to silence LGBT people
No thumbnail available

Kylie to headline BBC Proms

Australian pop sensation Kylie Minogue to headline BBC Proms In The Park