Should trans people fear rejig of Britain’s NHS?

Transgender people and groups want their voices heard about changes to the NHS in England which may impact on gender dysphoria treatment

Should trans people fear rejig of Britain’s NHS?
10 December 2012

Former British Health Secretary Andrew Lansley’s re-organisation of the country’s beloved National Health Service (NHS) is moving forwards, with many parts being implemented in only a few months time.

While for most of us the impact will be difficult to see, many trans people across England are highly concerned about the effects for them.

On the face of it, the movement of gender identity clinic services and genital surgery to be commissioned on a national basis should be a good thing – as it should remove the regional lottery that is often in effect. Some Primary Care Trusts have really good reputations for funding medical treatment of trans people, while others have created no-go areas for trans people due to the difficulty in gaining any funding whatsoever. National commissioning should smooth that out. Also, in theory, it may open the door to more providers – meaning different clinics and new surgeons.

But there is controversy over the specification of these services – what is covered and expected of the providers. Consultation over them with the Department of Health has been patchy – a meeting between them and representatives of various trans groups in May quickly descended into uproar. It did force the Department of Health to consult with service users (as trans people are grandly called in that context), but it was made clear that this government body could not actually tell the new National Commissioning Board what to commission or how.

This new National Commissioning Board has an advisory panel that is stuffed full of medics, and the draft policies all appear to have been drafted by them. A recent survey by the Scottish Transgender Alliance uncovered that 62% of respondents reported at least one issue or conflict with their gender identity clinic.

There is a very real fear that the voices of trans people are still being drowned out, and concerns with current services are not being addressed. An example is the on-going requirement for a trans person to be employed or in training in order to be eligible for surgery. It is a struggle to find any other NHS-provided medical procedure that is dependent upon your ability to earn money.

Another issue is the concern that best practice established in some Primary Care Trusts (PCTs), often after long fights by trans people, will be reduced to a common denominator. (PCTs are the NHS bodies which provide local doctors’ services and so-on.) While this will ensure that services in some areas will improve, others may well see deterioration – with little scope for the individual affected to change the situation. In an area already as contentious as medical care of trans people, this is causing some real concern.

PCTs are being replaced by CCGs (Clinical Commissioning Groups) – groups of doctors who are responsible for commissioning primary care. The ‘family doctor’, or General Practitioner, is very often the first port of call for a trans person wishing to access medical care. And here there are no national guidelines – CCGs are responsible for drafting their own.

There is real concern that some CCGs may decide to make access to the new national care pathways really difficult indeed. Bear in mind that a huge number of GPs don’t believe that gender dysphoria (the medical term for transsexualism) should be treated on the NHS. Trans people suddenly see many new areas of confrontation opening up, often at a point where people are most vulnerable and least able to fight bureaucracy.

Compare this situation to the one in NHS Scotland – where significant changes have recently been made to the service specifications, more accurately addressing the requirements of trans people. The difficulty in Scotland is actually the lack of a surgeon for genital surgery, but the protocols now appear to be more closely aligned to the new recommendations from WPATH – the international body which recommends what health care is appropriate for trans people.

Some trans groups are fighting hard for their voices to be heard, but is anybody actually listening?

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Pro-gay marriage Catholic teacher loses job over beliefs

New Zealand teacher lost his job after disagreeing with the religious principal who opposes gay marriage
No thumbnail available

X Factor hunk Shayne Ward strips off for new issue of Attitude

The latest issue of the magazine marks Ward’s return to the world of pop with an exclusive photo shoot and interview: ‘I get called gay all the time’
Looking (good)

Looking (good)

Andrew Haigh gets it right again with a clever slice of life in San Francisco.
No thumbnail available

Hunky gay surfer searches for love in Marry Me video that closed Syndey Mardi Gras

To soundtrack of Macklemore's Same Love, he finds true love after series of meaningless  encounters with other hot men
No thumbnail available

‘Traumatized’ student tortured by Russian gang returns home

Originally believed to be South African, the Swazi student was made to strip, simulate oral sex with a beer bottle and had his head forcibly shaved
No thumbnail available

Lesbian ex-couple battle over debt in Beijing court

Chinese gay women take disagreement over a 500,000RMB ($80,900, €62,600) debt to Beijing City Court following their break-up
No thumbnail available

New Zealand pastor tells gay author to kill himself

'I pray that you will commit suicide, you filthy child molesting fag'
No thumbnail available

Gay Uganda group office vandalized and robbed

The office of the Sexual Minorities of Uganda (SMUG) has been vandalized and robbed potentially putting gay Ugandans at risk
No thumbnail available

Gay icon Bette Midler to celebrate girl groups with first new album since 2006

 It’s The Girls will include songs originated by The Supremes, Martha & The Vandellas, The Shirelles and many more
No thumbnail available

Miley Cyrus surprises homeless youth with a visit to Los Angeles LGBT Center

'What is important to teach people is you can't judge other people'