The six ways gay marriage in England and Wales isn’t quite ‘equal’

LGBT rights campaigners are reminding those celebrating the same-sex marriage bill there is a lot more work to do to achieve full marriage equality

The six ways gay marriage in England and Wales isn’t quite ‘equal’
17 July 2013

As England and Wales celebrates same-sex marriage soon becoming law, LGBT rights campaigners are reminding people it is not ‘equal marriage’.

It comes as both the House of Commons and House of Lords have given their approval to the bill, and are now awaiting to be signed into law by Queen Elizabeth II.

Human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell says there are ‘six discriminatory aspects’ of the new legislation.

Consummation and Adultery

Among the several debates in the House of Lords, one of the most consistent was that lesbian sex is not defined as ‘consummation’ under British law.

‘Rightly or wrongly, the existing grounds for the annulment of a marriage – non-consummation and adultery – do not apply in the case of same-sex marriages,’ he said.

Church of England and Church in Wales Banned

Under the ‘quadruple lock’, ensuring no gay couple can force the Church of England and the Church in Wales from performing religious same-sex marriages.

Tatchell considers it to be discrimination, saying ‘even if they decide they want to’ they are unable to perform them.

Costs of Religious Same-Sex Marriages

The third point he considers to be a problem with the bill is the cost of registering premises for the conduct of religious same-sex marriages are much ‘harsher’ than opposite-sex couples.

‘In the case of shared premises, all other sharing faith organizations have to give their permission for the conduct of marriages involving LGBT people. In effect, they have a veto,’ Tatchell added.

Pension Rights

The human rights campaigner also says pension inheritance rights are fewer on death of a same-sex marriage spouse, with the surviving partner not entitled to inherit the full value of their pension if it began prior to 1988.

Despite this, ministers have pledged to look at eliminating any difference in the treatment of gay couples when it came to pension schemes.

Straight Civil Partnerships

One of Tatchell’s longest problems with the bill has been not opening up civil partnerships to opposite-sex couples.

‘Straight couples continue to be banned from having a civil partnership, even though the government’s own public consultation on equal marriage found that 61% of respondents supported the right of heterosexual couples to have a civil partnership if they desire one. Only 24% disagreed.’

When asked about civil partnerships, equalities minister Maria Miller said the Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill was the wrong place to discuss them.

Trans Rights

And, despite the Lords suggesting an amendment to the bill giving equality to trans people, the Commons rejected it yesterday (16 July).
Tatchell said: ‘Trans people – especially those already in marriages or civil partnerships – get a raw deal.

‘Among other flaws, married transgender people will need their spouse’s written permission before they can get a gender recognition certificate. This amounts to a ‘spousal veto’ over a trans person’s life.’

Writing in a comment piece for Gay Star News earlier this year, Trans Media Watch’s Helen Belcher said: ‘Trans people I have spoken to support the principles behind the same-sex marriage bill being debated in parliament by an overwhelming majority, with caveats.

‘There are significant worries that, once again, trans people’s rights are being seen as secondary to other peoples’ concerns.

‘And that speaks volumes about the way trans people are still seen by policy makers.’

What’s Next?

Queen Elizabeth II is expected to sign the same-sex marriage bill into law this week.

Scotland has just launched its legislation, with a debate and vote planned for October and November this year.

In Northern Ireland, every attempt to get it through the Assembly has so far failed.

While same-sex marriage in England and Wales has its problems, it is still a big step to full marriage equality.



No thumbnail available

Glee stars Jane Lynch and Chris Colfer snubbed by Globes

Glee stars Jane Lynch and Chris Colfer snubbed by Golden Globes after both won last year
No thumbnail available

Stephen Colbert chides Ellen Page for not coming out on his show - demands do-over

Host of The Colbert Report says such an announcement would have given his Comedy Central show a ratings boost
No thumbnail available

Senior Tories plead with backbench MPs to vote for gay marriage

George Osborne, Theresa May and William Hague has written a letter asking Conservative MPs to back marriage equality in the vote
No thumbnail available

Backlash from Italy's LGBT groups as Parliament votes on 'useless' gay hate ban

Italian LGBT groups are unsatisfied with a proposed anti-homophobia bill that passed in the lower Chamber of Deputies last night, arguing the bill's freedom of speech protections still allow discriminatory transgressions
No thumbnail available

A first for Puerto Rico as lesbian lawyer is nominated for a seat in Supreme Court

Maite Oronoz Rodriguez was nominated by Governor Alejandro García Padilla for a seat in Puerto Rico’s Supreme Court, and she thanked her partner at the press conference
No thumbnail available

Government of Senegal bans all gay exhibits at Biennale of Contemporary African Art

The Senegalese Government has forced the closure of all LGBTI themed exhibitions at the Dak’Art 2014 biennale after a gallery was attacked by Islamists
No thumbnail available

Puerto Rico's House of Reps approves sweeping measures to protect LGBT people

Senate already has approved and governor has promised to sign into law
No thumbnail available

LGBT film characters are still mostly male, still mostly white and it's not improving fast enough

No US studio has ever received an 'excellent' rating in the GLAAD film report
No thumbnail available

Landlord fired five months after turning pub gay

Pub manager claims he was forced to leave his home and place of work after he chose to give Ipswich their gay pub back
No thumbnail available

Australian former councilor forced to apologize for gay slur after 9-year legal battle

Entitled to express homophobic views but 'Gay Rights? Under God's law the only rights gays have is the right to die' bumper sticker goes too far, says Tribunal