Study sheds light on police ‘trans’ abuse in New York area

Transgender people in Queens district of Jackson Heights are twice as likely to be stopped and searched by police, report claims

Study sheds light on police ‘trans’ abuse in New York area
25 October 2012

Transgender people in Jackson Heights, New York, have been targeted by police for stop-and-frisk searches at more than twice the rate of the rest of the population, a new study claims.

The report, which spoke to 305 residents in the Queens neighborhood, was conducted by Make The Road New York and the New York City Gay and Lesbian Anti-Violence project.

‘Transgender and gender nonconforming people of color are particularly vulnerable due to their visibility,’ the study notes.

‘In order to combat police misconduct, there must be legislation and policies that minimise the risk of these kinds of abuse occurring in our communities.

‘Of the people that took part in the study, 167 listed themselves as either lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender or "other".

‘Of that group, 51% of LGB or other respondents claimed to have been stopped by police, with a third saying they were also physically harassed.

‘For the trans participants, this figure was much higher, 59% said they had been stopped by police, and almost half of them had been physically harassed.’

Of the non-LGBT residents questioned, only 28% had claimed to have been stopped and frisked.

Jackson Heights councilman Daniel Dromm believes that the police should be doing more to build trust with LGBT people.

Speaking to local news website DNAinfo.com, he said: ‘The majority of LGBTQ people who have come to this neighbourhood, or who live in this neighbourhood, in many instances have come to live here because of persecution in their own country only to face further persecution in this country.’

Speaking at an event held at Make the Road’s office in Jackson Heights on Tuesday (23 October), several members of the trans community said they were being accused of being sex workers.

Christina, a transwoman who spoke at the event, claimed she was accused of being a sex worker after police officers frisked her and found condoms in her bra.

She said ‘After seeing the condoms they asked if I was sure that I was not working. I told them that I was with my boyfriend and they said that he was not my boyfriend.’

Make the Road organizer Karina Caudio-Betancourt hopes this study will help to raise awareness of how LGBTQ people are targeted by the police.

She said: ‘We’ve reached out to them, and they’re aware the report is out.

‘We want to engage in a more thorough conversation with them, specifically about the demands that are more directed towards the precincts.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

From pizza to Twitter, backlash begins against Arizona legislators for passing anti-gay bill

Democratic House Leader Chad Campbell says it's time for same anger towards his state as people have against Russia for anti-gay law
No thumbnail available

Nepal to issue passports with third gender

Activists say recognition on travel documents will help tackle discrimination
The Glass Closet: What happened next

The Glass Closet: What happened next

EXCLUSIVE: Lord John Browne shares an extract from his foreword to the paperback edition of The Glass Closet
No thumbnail available

Newly out Frank Ocean to perform at MTV VMAs

R&B singer is nominated for Best New Artist award alongside One Direction and Carly Rae Jepson
No thumbnail available

Australian state election pledge to end historical convictions for gay sex

The Labor Party in the Australian state of Victoria has pledged to wipe convictions for homosexual acts that were prosecuted prior to decriminalization in 1981 and has called on the Liberal Party to do the same
No thumbnail available

Trans girl, 9, wins fight to use girls’ school toilets

When her mother told the school officials her daughter wanted to wear girls' clothes, she was forced to sign a document banning her from netball or swimming
The Falling gives us a strong cast grappling with powerful emotions

The Falling gives us a strong cast grappling with powerful emotions

Carol Morley's intense period film takes us deep into the psychology of teenage girls
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Include intersex in Bill, say lobby groups and legal experts

'Intersex' must be listed in a separate category in new Human Rights and Anti-Discrimination Bill, Australian Senate hearing told
No thumbnail available

Montana Democrat airs gay marriage ad

Candidate Dave Strohmaier makes an ad that pushes for gay marriage